Part II, Chapter X — The Mirror
Some rooms teach you how to belong. Others teach you who you are.
Rush had been happening for weeks.
Not all at once. Never that. It accumulated the way weather did, almost impossible to notice until suddenly everyone was talking about the same names.
The dining hall.
Football games.
Late-night study breaks in the chapter room.
Freshmen lingering a little longer after dinner.
Brothers suddenly taking different routes across campus because they “happened” to be heading the same direction.
By October, the conversations had become less about meeting people and more about comparing impressions.
“You talked to the kid from Charlotte?”
“What about the swimmer?”
“I heard his dad was a Sigma Nu at Carolina.”
“That one wears a tie to class.”
“I kind of respect that.”
“No, you don’t.”
Ethan mostly listened.
Last year, every conversation about Rush had felt like it might somehow determine his future.
Now it felt strangely…administrative.
Like watching people sort books onto shelves.
He hadn’t realized how little of it involved him until Mark pointed it out.
“You’ve been completely useless.”
They were walking back from economics together, cutting across the quad while students sprawled across the grass pretending the afternoon wasn’t warm enough to justify skipping class entirely.
“I’ve talked to people.”
Mark snorted.
“You’ve talked to the same three people.”
“I like the same three people.”
“Exactly.”
Mark shoved his hands into the pockets of his windbreaker.
“You know how many names I’ve got?”
“I’m afraid you’re going to tell me.”
“Twenty-seven.”
Ethan looked over.
“You’ve counted.”
“I have a legal pad.”
“I don’t know why that surprises me.”
“It should impress you.”
“It doesn’t.”
Mark laughed.
“You know what’s wrong with you?”
Ethan sighed.
“Probably.”
“You think Rush is about finding your best friend.”
“It isn’t?”
“It’s about building a pledge class.”
“They’re not mutually exclusive.”
“No,” Mark admitted. “But they’re different.”
They crossed in front of the library.
A freshman Ethan vaguely recognized nodded awkwardly as they passed.
Mark returned the greeting immediately.
“Morning, Ryan.”
The freshman brightened.
“Hey, Mark.”
They exchanged maybe six words before Ryan continued toward class.
Mark watched him go.
“See?”
“What?”
“He smiled.”
“I’m happy for both of you.”
Mark grinned.
“He’ll pledge.”
“You know that?”
“I know people.”
Ethan watched Ryan disappear into the stream of students.
Neat haircut.
Pressed khakis.
Backpack carried on both shoulders.
Last year Ethan would have noticed none of those things.
Now they seemed obvious.
Trying very hard.
Not hiding it particularly well.
“You’ve adopted him.”
“I recruited him.”
“There’s a difference?”
“There better be.”
Mark laughed again, clapping Ethan once on the shoulder before peeling off toward the business building.
“Chapter meeting tonight.”
“I know.”
“Wear something respectable.”
Ethan looked down at his jeans.
“I resent that.”
“You should.”
The chapter room smelled faintly of old carpet and dry erase markers.
Someone had dragged the whiteboard to the front of the room.
Names already covered half of it.
Some circled.
Some crossed out.
Some with question marks beside them.
Ethan took his usual chair near the middle.
Connor leaned back beside him, balancing dangerously on two legs.
“You vote yet?”
“I didn’t know we were campaigning.”
Connor pointed toward the board.
“Everybody campaigns.”
Marco wandered in carrying a pizza box despite the meeting not starting for another fifteen minutes.
“Bribery?”
Connor asked hopefully.
“For me.”
Teddy followed him.
“No chance he shares.”
“I heard that.”
“I wanted you to.”
The room slowly filled.
Sophomores and juniors drifted into familiar seats.
The seniors, suddenly very few of them, settled near the front almost out of habit.
It struck Ethan how different the room looked without Jason.
Not emptier.
Just…rearranged.
There was no obvious center anymore.
The president called the meeting to order with the gavel everyone pretended to hate and secretly loved.
Rush reports came first.
Treasurer.
Social calendar.
Homecoming budget.
Half the room paid attention.
The other half perfected the appearance of paying attention.
Finally, recruitment.
The recruitment chairman stood.
“We’ve got twenty-three men who’ve attended at least three events.”
A low whistle.
“That’s better than last year.”
Someone muttered, “Housing crisis.”
A few laughs.
The chairman nodded.
“Housing crisis helped.”
He uncapped a marker.
“Let’s talk bids.”
The room shifted.
Actually shifted.
People sat forward.
Names became people instead of ink.
“Ryan Dalton.”
Mark’s hand went up before the chairman finished speaking.
“Absolutely.”
Connor grinned.
“I think Mark’s already adopted him.”
“He’ll be a great brother.”
“Because he plays lacrosse?”
“Because he shows up.”
There were murmurs around the room.
Mostly agreement.
The vote wasn’t even close.
The chairman drew a check beside Ryan’s name.
“Caleb Renshaw.”
Even Ethan knew this one.
Confident.
Atlanta.
Always seemed to arrive exactly where conversations were already happening.
“He gets it,” somebody said.
“What does that even mean?”
Connor asked.
“You know exactly what it means.”
Another easy vote.
Another check.
Then the room slowed.
“Daniel Kline.”
Silence.
Not hostile.
Just uncertain.
Someone near the back shrugged.
“Nice enough.”
“Little awkward.”
“Real awkward.”
“He tries too hard.”
Connor leaned toward Ethan.
“Poor bastard.”
The words weren’t cruel.
Just observational.
Like discussing the weather.
Danny’s name stayed on the board while people weighed him.
Finally another check.
Not enthusiastic.
Just enough.
Then…
“Evan Mercer.”
The chairman looked around.
Nothing.
No hands.
No comments.
Almost as if nobody quite remembered him.
Ethan surprised himself.
“I liked him.”
The room turned.
The chairman looked over.
“You know him?”
“Not really.”
“What’d you see?”
Ethan hesitated.
It was harder to explain than he’d expected.
“He…”
He searched for it.
“He actually listened.”
Connor frowned.
“That’s your selling point?”
Ethan smiled slightly.
“He noticed people.”
A beat.
“He asked questions after everyone else stopped talking.”
Marco looked thoughtful.
“The Asheville kid?”
Ethan nodded.
“Yeah.”
“I remember him.”
Connor shrugged.
“Quiet.”
“Maybe,” Ethan said.
“But he wasn’t trying to be somebody else.”
Nobody spoke for a second.
Then the recruitment chairman made a small check beside Evan’s name.
“Anybody opposed?”
Silence.
“Good.”
The meeting moved on.
More names.
More votes.
More discussion.
But Ethan found himself looking back toward the board.
Toward one name.
He couldn’t have explained why.
Only that something about Evan had stayed with him.
Not because the freshman reminded him of himself.
He hadn’t realized that yet.
Only because, somehow, he had been the only one in the room who remembered the kid was there.
By seven o’clock, the house had started to hum.
Not loudly.
Not yet.
The music stayed low, the front door opened and closed every few minutes, and somebody had already managed to scatter pizza boxes across the chapter room before anyone admitted they were actually hungry.
Outside, October had finally settled over Westmore.
The afternoon heat had disappeared with the sun, leaving behind the kind of evening that made people linger on porches a little longer than they intended. Across the Row, lights flickered on one house at a time. Laughter drifted across the lawns before anyone had really earned it.
Ethan stood on the front porch with Marco, both leaning against the railing while Connor tried unsuccessfully to teach Teddy how to tie a bow tie.
“You’ve had twenty-one years,” Teddy protested.
“I’ve had twenty-one years not caring.”
“You look like you’re strangling yourself.”
“I feel like I’m strangling myself.”
Connor walked past carrying a cardboard box filled with bid cards.
“If either of you dies before the freshmen get here,” he said, “drag yourselves behind the house.”
Marco nodded solemnly.
“We’re very considerate.”
The front door swung open.
Mark appeared wearing a blazer Ethan had never seen before.
Connor stopped.
“What happened to you?”
Mark looked down at himself.
“I own clothes.”
“You own that?”
“My mother bought it.”
“That explains everything.”
Mark ignored him, smoothing an imaginary wrinkle from his sleeve.
“Presentation matters.”
Connor looked toward Ethan.
“See? This is what leadership does to people.”
“It makes them shop?” Ethan asked.
“It makes them terrifying.”
Mark only smiled.
“You’ll thank me when half this class says yes.”
The first cars arrived just after eight.
Not all together.
Ethan smiled when he saw the young men wearing coats instead of T-shirts.
Appearances mattered.
The fraternity understood that.
The memory arrived so quickly he almost smiled.
“Funny?”
Tyler had appeared beside him without Ethan noticing.
“No.”
“What then?”
“I was thinking about last year.”
Tyler looked toward the sidewalk.
“They all look younger than I remember.”
Ethan followed his gaze.
Ryan climbed out of a silver Honda, straightened his tie, then immediately checked to make sure it was still straight.
Cal stepped out of a Jeep behind him, and walked toward the house like he’d been invited to dinner.
Danny emerged from an aging pickup, carrying himself so carefully it almost hurt to watch.
Last came Evan.
For a moment he simply stood there.
Looking at Delta Chi like he was trying to decide whether he’d walked to the right address.
“I remember that feeling,” Ethan said quietly.
Tyler looked at him instead of the freshmen.
“I know.”
The chapter president welcomed them inside.
There were introductions.
A few jokes.
Enough applause to make everyone slightly uncomfortable.
The bid cards were handed out one at a time.
Ryan grinned before he even opened his.
Cal thanked three different brothers before anyone had spoken to him.
Danny unfolded his slowly, reading every line like it might disappear if he hurried.
Evan turned his over in his hands first.
Then opened it.
Smiled.
Just a little.
Enough.
The room applauded again.
Beer appeared almost magically.
Pizza followed.
Music drifted back into the common room.
Within twenty minutes, the house had become what it always became.
Small circles.
New conversations.
Invisible gravity pulling people toward certain personalities.
Ryan had already found Mark.
Or maybe Mark had found Ryan.
It was impossible to tell.
Cal floated easily from group to group, laughing with juniors one minute and asking thoughtful questions of seniors the next.
Connor somehow had Danny helping him rearrange folding chairs.
“You’re tall,” Connor explained.
“I am?”
“You are now.”
Danny laughed uncertainly and picked up another chair.
Marco quietly intercepted half of Connor’s worst ideas before they reached him.
Nobody noticed.
Nobody except Ethan.
The machine was already working.
Not because anyone wanted it to.
Because everyone already knew their part.
He wandered toward the kitchen for another slice of pizza.
Someone had spilled Coke across the counter.
A sophomore whose name he couldn’t remember was trying to convince three freshmen that the house cat from 1984 still haunted the attic.
One of them actually believed him.
Ethan smiled into his paper plate.
“You survived.”
He looked up.
Evan stood beside him, balancing two slices of pepperoni and a plastic cup.
“Barely,” Ethan said.
Evan laughed.
“So…this is real?”
“The pizza?”
“The fraternity.”
Ethan leaned against the counter.
“What do you think?”
Evan considered it.
“I don’t know yet.”
“Good answer.”
“You think so?”
“I’d worry if you already knew.”
Evan smiled again.
“You remember my name.”
“I do.”
“I’ve met about thirty people tonight.”
“I remember what that feels like.”
Evan nodded thoughtfully.
“I guess you would.”
For a moment neither of them spoke.
The kitchen buzzed around them.
Someone shouted from the deck.
A burst of laughter rolled in from the front room.
Evan looked toward the doorway.
“They all seem like they’ve known each other forever.”
“They don’t.”
“They act like it.”
“They’ve practiced.”
That earned a puzzled look.
Ethan smiled.
“You’ll understand later.”
Evan nodded slowly.
“I hope so.”
“So did I.”
When Ethan wandered back into the common room, Tyler was leaning against the far wall, beer still in his hand.
Their eyes met across the room.
Tyler tipped his bottle toward the kitchen.
“You disappeared.”
“So did you.”
Tyler smiled faintly.
“I’ve been standing here the whole time.”
Ethan laughed.
“Fair.”
Tyler glanced toward Evan, who had just joined a conversation with Danny near the fireplace.
“You’ve found one.”
Ethan frowned.
“What?”
“The Asheville kid.”
“I just talked to him.”
“I know.”
Tyler took a sip of his beer.
“You’ve checked on him three times.”
“I have not.”
“You have.”
Ethan started to object.
Stopped.
Because Tyler was right.
He had.
Without thinking about it.
Without deciding to.
He’d simply kept looking over to make sure Evan had found someone to talk to.
To make sure he wasn’t standing alone.
Tyler watched realization settle across Ethan’s face.
Then looked back toward the room.
“He’ll be alright.”
Ethan followed his gaze.
Evan was listening more than talking.
Danny was saying something animated with his hands.
Marco had quietly drifted into the conversation without interrupting it.
Maybe he would.
Maybe that wasn’t why Ethan kept checking.
He wasn’t sure.
Outside, someone started another round of applause as a late arrival walked through the front door.
The house welcomed him exactly the same way.
Ethan watched from the edge of the room, no longer wondering where he fit inside it.
Instead, for the first time, he found himself wondering who else might still be looking for a place to stand.
By eleven, the house had begun to exhale.
Not because people were leaving.
Because everyone had found somewhere to belong.
The music had settled into the background again. The kitchen was still crowded, but now with conversations instead of introductions. The freshmen had relaxed enough to stop standing in perfect posture. Jackets hung over chair backs. Ties had disappeared. Someone had started a card game at the dining room table with rules that changed every hand.
The excitement hadn’t ended.
It had simply become ordinary.
Ethan slipped out onto the front porch with another beer he wasn’t particularly interested in drinking.
The night had cooled enough that the wood beneath his forearms felt cold against his skin.
Across the Row another fraternity had begun singing something half the campus knew by heart. The voices drifted through the trees before dissolving into laughter.
Westmore had a way of making traditions sound older than they really were.
The screen door creaked behind him.
Connor stepped outside carrying two empty pizza boxes.
“There you are.”
“I escaped.”
Connor nodded toward the lawn.
“They seem alright.”
“They do.”
Connor balanced the boxes against the porch rail.
“I always forget how nervous they are.”
Ethan smiled.
“You?”
Connor laughed.
“I know. Hard to believe.”
He looked back through the front window.
“I was convinced everybody knew I didn’t belong here.”
“You told me last year you’d never had that thought.”
“I lied.”
Connor shrugged.
“Seemed important at the time.”
He gathered the boxes again.
“Don’t tell anybody.”
“I won’t.”
Connor disappeared toward the dumpster behind the house.
For a moment Ethan stood alone again.
The front door opened a second time.
Danny stepped onto the porch.
He didn’t see Ethan immediately.
He walked halfway to the railing before stopping, hands buried awkwardly in his pockets.
After a moment Ethan spoke.
“You surviving?”
Danny jumped slightly.
“Oh.”
A sheepish laugh.
“Sorry. Didn’t know anybody was out here.”
“I wasn’t doing anything interesting.”
Danny nodded.
“Me neither.”
They stood quietly.
Across the street someone started a pickup football game with entirely too much confidence and entirely too little light.
Danny watched them.
“I keep saying the wrong thing.”
Ethan glanced over.
“What makes you think that?”
Danny laughed through his nose.
“Everybody keeps looking at me.”
“They’re freshmen.”
“No…”
Danny shook his head.
“The brothers.”
Ethan leaned against the railing.
“They’re looking because you’re new.”
“You sure?”
“No.”
Danny smiled despite himself.
“I appreciate the honesty.”
Before Ethan could answer, the screen door opened again.
Connor leaned his head outside.
“Danny.”
Danny looked over.
“We need another body.”
Connor pointed toward the dining room.
“Apparently Teddy’s cheating.”
“I don’t know how to play.”
“Perfect.”
Connor disappeared before Danny could protest.
Danny sighed.
“I should probably…”
“You should.”
He started toward the door, then hesitated.
“Thanks.”
“For what?”
Danny shrugged.
“I don’t know.”
Then he was gone.
The porch settled again.
A few minutes later the screen door opened once more.
This time it was Evan.
He carried a paper cup instead of a beer.
He looked surprised to find Ethan still there.
“Mind if I…”
He gestured toward the empty rocking chair.
“It’s your porch now.”
Evan laughed softly.
“I don’t think that’s how this works.”
“No.”
He sat anyway.
For a while neither of them spoke.
The chair rocked quietly against the old floorboards.
Finally Evan said,
“I thought it’d be louder.”
“It usually is.”
“I mean…” He searched for it. “Scarier.”
Ethan looked out across the lawn.
“That comes later.”
Evan laughed.
“Great.”
“I meant the first week.”
“I know.”
Silence returned.
Comfortable this time.
Evan looked down into his cup.
“I almost didn’t come.”
Ethan turned.
“To Bid Night?”
“To Westmore.”
That wasn’t the answer he’d expected.
“My guidance counselor talked me into applying.”
“Asheville’s a long way.”
“My parents thought it was too small.”
“What did you think?”
Evan smiled faintly.
“I thought if I got in, I’d figure the rest out.”
“Have you?”
“No.”
“Good.”
Evan looked over.
“You keep saying that.”
“Because it’s true.”
Another gentle laugh.
“I’ve spent six weeks thinking everybody else already knew how college worked.”
Ethan rested his elbows on the porch rail.
“They don’t.”
“They look like they do.”
“They’re performing.”
The word hung there.
Evan considered it.
“You really believe that?”
“I didn’t last year.”
“But now?”
Ethan looked back through the front window.
Ryan stood shoulder to shoulder with Mark, laughing at something only half the room had heard.
Cal was telling a story to three juniors.
Connor had somehow convinced Danny to deal cards.
Marco was watching all of it with the same quiet amusement he always carried.
“It gets easier,” Ethan said.
Evan nodded.
“I hope so.”
“It does.”
A pause.
“But not because you get better at pretending.”
Evan frowned slightly.
“Then why?”
Ethan thought about it.
About Tyler.
About the little house across town.
About the quiet of their room after everyone else had gone to sleep.
About Jason.
“You find the people you don’t have to perform for.”
The words surprised him as soon as he heard them.
Evan was quiet.
Then he smiled.
“I’d like that.”
“You will.”
“You sound pretty sure.”
Ethan smiled.
“I didn’t used to.”
The door creaked again.
Tyler stepped onto the porch carrying two bottles of water.
He handed one to Ethan.
The other to Evan.
“You’ll thank me tomorrow.”
Evan laughed.
“Probably.”
Inside someone called his name.
One of the other freshmen.
He stood.
“I should…”
“You should.”
He looked at Ethan.
“Thanks.”
This time Ethan understood what he meant.
“Anytime.”
Evan disappeared inside.
The screen door closed behind him.
Tyler leaned against the railing beside Ethan.
“You like him.”
Ethan unscrewed the bottle.
“He seems like a good kid.”
“That’s not what I meant.”
Ethan smiled.
“I know.”
They watched through the front window.
Evan had already been pulled into the card game.
He still looked uncertain.
But he was laughing now.
Not loudly.
Just enough.
Tyler spoke without looking away.
“You remember your first Bid Night?”
“Barely.”
“I do.”
Ethan glanced over.
“You spent half the evening standing exactly where he’s standing now.”
“I did not.”
“You absolutely did.”
Ethan laughed.
“I was more social than that.”
“No.”
“I talked to people.”
“You talked to Jason.”
The laughter faded.
Tyler continued quietly.
“The rest of us just happened to be nearby.”
They stood together, watching the room move beyond the old glass windows.
“I never noticed.”
“I know.”
Another long silence settled between them.
Not empty.
Full.
Finally Tyler smiled to himself.
“Funny.”
“What?”
“You’ve been watching him all night.”
“I guess.”
“The whole time I kept thinking I’d seen it before.”
Ethan looked over.
Tyler took a sip of his water.
“Then I remembered.”
He nodded toward the window.
“Jason spent all of freshman year watching you exactly like that.”
Ethan didn’t answer.
Because he couldn’t.
The image arrived all at once.
Jason appearing beside him after lineup.
Jason sitting down when everyone else walked away.
Jason somehow always noticing when Ethan had drifted to the edge of a room.
Not rescuing him.
Simply…
finding him.
Inside, Evan laughed again at something Danny had said.
This time it came easily.
Tyler pushed himself away from the railing.
“Come on.”
“Where?”
“I’m tired.”
Ethan looked once more through the front window.
The house looked almost exactly as it had a year earlier.
Freshmen trying to become brothers.
Older members pretending they already knew how.
The same walls.
The same worn floors.
The same traditions.
Only now, Ethan wasn’t looking for a place to stand.
He was looking for the person who hadn’t found one yet.
Without another word, he followed Tyler back inside.
Further Reading
Disclosure: This post may include affiliate links (including Amazon). If you buy a book through one of these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Consider it a small contribution to my ongoing habit of buying too many books and writing about them here.
If you prefer to read on your Kindle, you can purchase Line & Verse, Book 1 from Amazon. Paid Subscribers can also download a copy of the eBook version here.
Stay Connected
📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.
📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes
📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed
🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social