The house didn’t settle.

That was the first thing Ethan noticed.

By the second week of classes, it should have. The rhythm should have come back. The easy division of space, the unspoken rules about who belonged where, who spoke when, who mattered. It always did.

But now the edges wouldn’t hold.

There were too many people.

The front door stayed open longer than it should have, voices carrying onto the lawn in uneven bursts. Shoes piled in the entryway. Someone had dragged a mattress halfway down the hall and left it there, angled against the wall like a decision that hadn’t been finished.

It wasn’t chaos.

It was worse than that.

It was expansion.

Ethan stepped over a duffel bag just inside the door and paused. The common room was already full, more bodies than the space really allowed, conversations overlapping just enough to keep any one of them from settling.

Connor had taken the couch again, feet up, one arm thrown across the back like it was still his. Teddy was sunk into the chair across from him, not even pretending to sit up. Marco leaned in the doorway, half in the room, half out of it, laughing at something that didn’t quite land but didn’t need to.

And threaded through all of it:

Freshmen.

You could spot them immediately. Not by what they wore, though that helped. It was the way they moved. A half-second hesitation before stepping into a space. The way they laughed just a beat too late, waiting to see if they were allowed.

One of them hovered near the kitchen doorway, hands jammed into his pockets like that alone might hold him together. Connor clocked him instantly.

“Hey,” Connor said, snapping his fingers once. “You. What’s your name?”

The kid straightened. “Ryan.”

“Ryan what?”

“Dalton.”

Connor nodded like he’d just been handed something useful. “You got a room?”

“Kind of?”

“Good,” Connor said. “Then you can help us out.”

Ryan hesitated.

Then nodded.

Of course he did.

Ethan looked away before the moment could settle.

Across the room, Mark stood near the center of it all, already moving like he’d been doing this for years. He had two of the freshmen pulled into a loose circle, one hand resting on a shoulder here, a quick laugh there, guiding the conversation without ever looking like he was doing it.

“We’ve got half a class handed to us,” he was saying. “Might as well make it count.”

Connor perked up from the couch. “Now you’re talking.”

“That’s efficient,” Mark shot back, grinning.

Marco shook his head, smiling. “You don’t waste time.”

“Never have.”

It wasn’t forced.

That was the thing.

Mark wasn’t trying to be anything. He had just stepped into it, like the room had been waiting for him to fill it.

Ethan felt something tighten.

It made sense.

That was the problem.

He leaned back against the wall and let the noise move around him. It wasn’t overwhelming, not the way it had been last year. This was different.

He could see it now. The way the room shifted depending on who spoke. The way attention gathered and dispersed.

From the far side of the room, Tyler stood against the wall, a beer in his hand that didn’t look touched. He hadn’t moved much since Ethan walked in.

Not disengaged.

Just not pulled.

Ethan pushed off the wall and made his way over, weaving through bodies and half-heard conversation.

“Fun,” Tyler said as he stepped up beside him.

“Something like that.”

Tyler’s eyes flicked toward Mark’s group, then back. “He’s not wasting any time.”

Ethan followed his gaze. “No.”

A beat.

“You think they know what they walked into?” Tyler asked.

Ethan watched Ryan again, the way he nodded too quickly at something Mark said, the way his shoulders stayed just a little too tight.

“No,” Ethan said. “Not yet.”

Tyler let out something that might have been a laugh.

Behind them, the stereo crackled, cut out, then snapped back on louder than before. Someone cheered like that alone justified it. The sound filled the room, pushing everything forward a half-step.

It didn’t need direction.

It just needed bodies.

Ethan took a beer from someone passing by without really looking. He didn’t drink it. Just held it, letting the condensation collect in his palm.

Across the room, Mark caught his eye.

Grinned.

Raised his bottle.

Ethan lifted a hand in answer, not quite a wave.

Then Mark was pulled back into it, someone saying his name, another voice cutting in, the center of the room shifting around him like it had already decided where he belonged.

Tyler didn’t move.

“Come on,” he said quietly.

Ethan glanced over. “Where?”

Tyler tipped his head toward the hallway. “Anywhere but here.”

Ethan hesitated.

Not because he didn’t understand.

Because he did.

He set the beer down on the nearest surface without taking a sip.

“Yeah,” he said.

They moved down the hallway without speaking, the noise fading just enough to feel like distance without actually disappearing. A couple of freshmen sat on the floor near the stairs, backs against the wall, talking in low voices like they were trying not to be noticed.

They stopped talking as Ethan and Tyler passed.

Of course they did.

Outside, the air hit clean.

Not cold yet. Just enough to cut through the heat of the house and make everything feel sharper. The deck was fuller than it had been earlier, small groups clustered near the railing, someone leaning too far over the edge, another couple talking quietly near the steps like they’d carved out a pocket of space that belonged to them.

Ethan leaned against one of the columns, the wood still warm from the day.

Tyler stood beside him.

Close.

Not touching.

“You good?” Tyler asked.

Ethan let out a breath. “Yeah.”

Tyler glanced back toward the room.

Inside, the music swelled again, louder now, the bass carrying through the walls. Someone shouted something that got lost before it reached them. Laughter followed anyway.

The house had tipped.

Fast.

Like it had been waiting for this.

Ethan looked back through the open door.

Mark was still there, exactly where he’d been, the room gathered around him now without question. Connor had pulled two of the freshmen into something that looked suspiciously like a drinking game. Teddy was calling out rules from the couch. Marco leaned in the doorway, watching it all unfold like he’d seen it a hundred times before.

Which he had.

So had Ethan.

Only now he could see it.

Not from inside.

From the edge.

“It’s the same,” Tyler said.

Ethan nodded once. “Yeah.”

A beat.

“Doesn’t feel the same.”

“No.”

They stood there another second.

Then Tyler said, “There’s something happening tonight.”

Ethan looked over.

“Off campus,” Tyler said. “Same place.”

That landed differently this time.

Not like the first time, when it had felt like an invitation to something he didn’t understand. He already knew what it was. The house. The music. The way he had stopped thinking about himself for a few hours without realizing it.

A place that didn’t need anything from him.

“You don’t have to,” Tyler said.

“I know.”

Inside, someone called Ethan’s name.

He didn’t turn.

“When?”

“Later. Around ten.”

Ethan nodded once.

The noise behind them swelled again as the door opened wider, carrying the night with it.

Same House. Just louder now.

Ethan glanced back once.

Mark caught his eye again.

Grinned.

Like everything was exactly where it was supposed to be.

Ethan held it for a second.

Then looked away.

“Yeah,” he said. “Alright.”

Tyler didn’t react much, but something in his posture settled.

“Alright.”

They stood there another second, the space between them quiet in a way that didn’t need filling.

Then Tyler pushed off the railing.

“I’ll meet you out front.”

Ethan nodded.

Tyler stepped back inside without looking to see if he followed.

Ethan stayed where he was.

The yard stretched out in front of him, worn in the same places it had been last year. The same patches of dirt where grass refused to grow. The same uneven line where the lawn gave way to the street.

Nothing had changed.

Not really.

Behind him, the house roared on, louder now, pulling people in, reshaping itself around whoever stepped through the door.

Ethan let out a slow breath.

Then he stepped off the porch and into the dark.

The street looked narrower than Ethan remembered.

Not because it had. The same sagging porches leaned toward each other across the road, the same patchy sidewalks gave way to dirt and crabgrass, the same old houses sat with their lights burning low behind curtains that didn’t fully close. But last time he had arrived half-braced, still carrying the stiffness of Westmore in his shoulders. The place had felt hidden then, like something he’d stumbled into by accident.

Tonight it just felt farther away from campus than the map suggested.

Tyler parked behind a battered Subaru with a cracked Kerry sticker on the bumper and killed the engine. For a second neither of them moved.

The house sat at the end of the block with a porch that looked one hard winter away from surrender. A strand of leftover white lights still hung unevenly from the railing, half-burned out, giving the whole place the look of something surviving on charm longer than structure. Music drifted through the screen door, low and unhurried, a female voice Ethan didn’t recognize, something all guitar and ache.

Tyler pushed his door open first.

“You coming?”

Ethan nodded once and followed him up the walk.

The porch boards complained under their weight. Somewhere inside, someone laughed, not loudly, just fully, without the clipped edge people wore at Westmore when they were trying to sound relaxed in front of each other.

Tyler didn’t knock. He pulled the door open and held it just long enough for Ethan to step through ahead of him.

Warmth met him first.

Then scent.

Patchouli again, faint this time, mixed with sangria, old wood, cigarettes, something sweet burning in the kitchen. The house was full, but not crowded the way Delta Chi always was. Conversations rose and dipped. Music lived inside the room instead of sitting on top of it.

Ethan stopped just past the threshold, not because he felt out of place but because his body seemed to remember before his mind caught up.

The place had changed less than he had.

A girl with cropped black hair sat cross-legged on the floor near the record player, arguing cheerfully with someone in wire-rim glasses about whether R.E.M. counted as Southern Gothic. A broad-shouldered guy in a thermal leaned against the kitchen archway, listening with his whole face. Two men stood near the back windows sharing a cigarette, heads bent toward each other in a way that wasn’t furtive or staged.

That still struck him.

Tyler touched his elbow lightly.

“You’re doing the thing again,” he said.

“What thing?”

“The standing in the doorway like somebody waiting for someone to tell him he belongs.”

Ethan huffed a laugh. “Maybe they should.”

“They won’t,” Tyler said.

Then he stepped away, not abandoning him, just moving into the room with the same easy confidence he carried everywhere that wasn’t the fraternity house. He paused near the kitchen arch, greeted someone with a nod and a quick hand to the shoulder, then leaned down to hear something over the music.

No performance.

Just Tyler.

A woman in an oversized cardigan appeared beside Ethan, holding a chipped wine glass

“You look less terrified this time,” she said, offering it.

Ethan took the glass automatically. “That obvious?”

“Only to people who were here the first time.”

He looked at her more closely then. Same faded ACT UP shirt under the cardigan, same amused steadiness in her face. He remembered her now.

“You remember me?” he asked.

“I remember all of Jason’s boys,” she said. “Some of you arrive looking like you’re about to be arrested for breathing wrong.”

That got another laugh out of him.

He looked down into the glass. Sangria, homemade, dark and fragrant, the fumes from the cheap wine burning his nostrils.

“Jason’s not here?” she asked.

“Richmond, I think. I’m sure he won’t be able to stay away for long.”

She nodded like that made sense. “You’ll survive without a chaperone.”

Before he could answer, someone called her name from the other room. She tipped two fingers against the rim of his glass in parting.

“Go stand somewhere like you meant to,” she said. “It helps.”

He watched her disappear toward the kitchen, then realized he was smiling into his drink.

The room hadn’t gotten quieter.

He had.

He moved farther in, just enough to stop behaving like he’d been dropped there by mistake. A cluster of people near the bookshelf shifted to let him through without needing to be asked. Someone brushed his shoulder in passing and didn’t apologize for taking up space.

Near the mantel, the lanky guy in the Henley from the first visit was digging through a stack of records. He looked up, squinted once in recognition, then smiled.

“Westmore.”

Ethan lifted the glass slightly. “That obvious too?”

“Only because you look like you’re noticing everything.”

“I’m trying not to.”

“That seems like a waste.”

The guy pulled out a record and held it up. “You still listening to whatever sad boys from your tape deck got you through high school?”

Ethan laughed. “Depends who’s asking.”

“Neil,” the guy said. “History, technically. Poor judgment, otherwise.”

“Ethan.”

“I know.”

“Should I be worried about that?”

“Not unless you’re dull.”

Neil slid the record from its sleeve with practiced care and set it on the turntable. “Relax. You survived Jason Whitmore dragging you here the first time. You can survive me.”

“That’s not how I remember it.”

“That’s because it happened to you.”

The needle dropped. A softer song came in, older, low enough that the room seemed to angle itself around it. Neil stepped back from the turntable and glanced over Ethan’s shoulder.

“Your friend’s watching you,” he said.

Ethan turned.

Tyler was in the kitchen doorway now, one forearm braced against the frame, talking to a dark-haired girl in a denim jacket Ethan didn’t know. He wasn’t staring exactly. But his eyes had drifted back more than once.

When Ethan met his gaze, Tyler tipped his head once.

You good?

Ethan answered with the smallest shift of his shoulders.

Yeah.

Neil noticed anyway.

“Nice,” he said.

Ethan looked back at him. “What is?”

Neil shrugged. “Whatever that was.”

Before Ethan could answer, someone crossed between them calling Neil toward the dining room. He went easily, leaving Ethan standing by the turntable with the wine in his hand.

He hadn’t expected the place to feel familiar.

He had expected to remember it. The smell. The warmth. The relief of not having to guard every angle of himself at once.

Familiarity was different.

He wandered toward the back of the house, passing framed prints gone slightly crooked on the walls, a kitchen table crowded with bottles, and a bowl of cigarettes and loose change and matchbooks like some communal offering.

Two women stood by the sink, laughing over something one of them was trying and failing to cut with a dull knife. Neither stopped talking when he came in. One of them just slid the cutting board farther toward the center to make room and kept going.

Not being ignored. Being included without ceremony.

He set the glass down long enough to reach for one of the oranges and was halfway through slicing it when Tyler appeared in the doorway.

“There you are,” he said.

Ethan looked up. “I’ve been in the kitchen for maybe thirty seconds.”

Tyler leaned one shoulder against the frame, hands in his pockets. “Long enough.”

The woman with the knife glanced between them. “Either help or stop hovering.”

Tyler pushed off the frame and moved beside Ethan at the table. “What’s the task?”

“Proof you’re useful.”

“That’s a high bar.”

“Then start with the apples.”

He did, reaching for the paring knife beside Ethan’s hand, their wrists knocking lightly in the process. Neither of them pulled away too fast.

The women kept talking. Something about a professor. Something about a girl named Marian who’d gone home with a Baptist and then claimed not to remember it. The conversation moved around Tyler and Ethan without making them perform for it, and they fell into the work easily. Slice. Core. Drop. The apples piled into a mixing bowl between them, skins curling into long red strips.

Tyler glanced down at the orange in Ethan’s hand. “That’s not how you do it.”

“It’s working.”

“It’s tragic.”

Ethan smirked. “You volunteering?”

Tyler took the orange from him, their fingers brushing sticky with juice and spice, then cut the peel in one clean spiral without breaking it.

“Show-off,” Ethan said.

“Competence isn’t showing off.”

“In this room maybe not.”

Tyler looked at him then, the hint of a smile still at one corner of his mouth.

“That is the point.”

One of the women shoved the bowl toward the stove. “You can brood later. Stir this.”

Tyler laughed and handed the spoon to Ethan instead. “You stir. Apparently I’m no help.”

“That’s true everywhere,” the other woman said, and the room broke around it in easy laughter.

Ethan leaned over the pot, the steam carrying up wine, citrus, all of it softened by heat. Tyler stayed beside him, close enough that the outside of his arm pressed briefly against Ethan’s before either of them shifted.

Across the room, someone started singing quietly along with the record, off-key but not embarrassingly so. More voices joined, not to take over, just because they knew it.

Tyler leaned down slightly, voice low enough to stay between them.

“You look different this time.”

Ethan kept stirring. “How?”

“Less like you’re waiting to be found out.”

That landed harder than he expected.

He glanced sideways. “Maybe I’m just getting better at hiding it.”

Tyler shook his head once. “No.”

The steam rose between them, briefly blurring Tyler’s face before clearing again.

“Last time,” Ethan said carefully, “I kept thinking somebody would walk in and decide I was wrong.”

Tyler was quiet for a second. Then: “And now?”

Ethan let the spoon circle once, twice. “Now I think maybe that’s just Westmore talking.”

The answer sat there between them.

Tyler didn’t rush to fill it. He reached for Ethan’s glass, took a sip without asking, then set it back down in the same spot.

“Yeah,” he said. “Probably.”

The woman with the knife took the spoon from Ethan’s hand and shooed them both sideways. “Enough domesticity. Go get drunk”

Tyler nodded solemnly. “Cruel but fair.”

Ethan picked his glass back up, still warm from Tyler’s mouth, and followed him out of the kitchen.

The side room was barely a room.

Two old chairs, a narrow bookshelf bowed in the middle, and a lamp with a yellow shade that made everything look softer than it was. The window behind the chairs was cracked open just enough to let in the night air and the hum of insects from the yard.

Tyler leaned against the doorframe instead of sitting.

Ethan stayed standing for a second, glass still in his hand, listening to the house continue around them. A laugh rose from the front room and fell away. Someone crossed the hallway outside, footsteps light, then gone. The record in the other room changed over with a soft pop.

It didn’t feel hidden.

Just smaller.

Tyler folded his arms loosely across his chest. “You went quiet.”

Ethan looked over. “Did I?”

“A little.”

Ethan smiled faintly. “You say that like you’ve known me forever.”

Tyler shrugged. “Long enough.”

That landed somewhere low and quiet.

Ethan moved to the window and rested the glass on the sill, looking out at the dark slope of the yard. Somewhere beyond that, past the neighborhood and the roads and the river, Westmore still sat where it always had, all brick and order and the illusion of permanence.

It felt farther away than it should have.

Behind him, Tyler stepped into the room.

Not close enough to crowd him. Just enough that Ethan could feel the change in the air.

“You alright?” Tyler asked.

Ethan kept his eyes on the yard. “Yeah.”

Tyler waited.

Then: “That’s not really an answer.”

Ethan let out a soft breath. “I know.”

He turned then, leaning one shoulder back against the sill. Tyler was standing near the bookshelf now, one hand resting on the bent middle shelf as if testing whether it would hold.

For a second neither of them spoke.

It wasn’t uncomfortable.

Speech just wasn’t urgent.

“I forgot what this felt like,” Ethan said finally.

“What?”

Ethan gestured toward the house beyond the room. “Being somewhere and not feeling like I have to get myself right before anybody notices me.”

Tyler’s expression softened. “Yeah. That part’s hard to unlearn.”

Ethan looked down at his hands. “I keep thinking I should know what I’m doing by now.”

Tyler gave a small exhale. “Why?”

Ethan looked up.

“Seriously,” Tyler said. “Why?”

“Because everyone else seems to.”

Tyler smiled a little. “They don’t.”

“That’s easy for you to say.”

“It’s not easy for me to say. It’s just true.”

Ethan leaned his head back against the window frame.

“I don’t mean just here,” he said after a second. “I mean in general. Westmore. The house. Everything.” He paused. “Last year at least I had the excuse of being new.”

Tyler moved to the chair nearest the lamp and dropped into it, one arm slung over the side.

“You think sophomore year is where everybody suddenly becomes a person?” he asked.

Ethan laughed despite himself. “Isn’t it?”

“No.”

Tyler tipped his head toward the door, toward the rest of the house.

“Half those guys are just louder now.”

That got him.

A real laugh this time, quick and low enough that Ethan felt it loosen something in his chest.

Tyler smiled at the sound of it, then looked down, rubbing his thumb over the worn arm of the chair.

The house shifted around them again. Someone called from the kitchen for more wine. A voice answered. The front door opened and closed, letting in a brief wash of colder air that moved down the hallway and disappeared.

Ethan stayed where he was.

He hadn’t been this still around someone in a long time without it turning into tension.

With Tyler it felt easier.

Tyler glanced up again. “What?”

Ethan blinked. “Nothing.”

Tyler watched him, waiting.

Ethan looked away, smiling into it. “You always know when I’m lying?”

“Pretty much.”

“That seems arrogant.”

“I’m comfortable with that.”

Ethan shook his head.

Then, because he was tired enough not to stop himself, he said, “This feels easier with you.”

Tyler didn’t look away.

“Yeah,” he said. “It does.”

Simple as that.

Ethan felt the answer go through him more sharply than he expected.

He looked down at the floorboards, at the scratches in the varnish, the dark knot in one plank near his shoe. Heat climbed into his face.

Tyler watched him for another second, then stood.

He crossed the room slowly, not tentative, not careless either. When he stopped, he was close enough that Ethan could see the faint line where the collar of his t-shirt had gone soft from too many washes.

Neither of them moved right away.

From somewhere down the hall came another burst of laughter, then the scrape of someone dragging a chair across wood. The sound should have broken the moment.

It didn’t.

Tyler’s hand came up first, not even really to touch at first. Just the backs of his fingers brushing once against Ethan’s wrist where it rested on the sill.

A question.

Ethan didn’t answer it out loud.

He turned his hand over.

That was enough.

Tyler’s fingers closed gently around his, warm and sure without tightening. Ethan felt the contact in his throat before he felt it anywhere else.

He hadn’t realized how much of the year had been spent bracing until that moment, when something in him stopped.

He looked up.

Tyler was close enough now that Ethan could see the small scar near his chin, the one he’d noticed before but never long enough to ask about. Lamp light. Open window. The warmth of another person standing close and not asking him to become somebody else first.

Tyler’s thumb moved once against the inside of his wrist.

“You don’t have to figure it out tonight,” he said.

Ethan swallowed. “I know.”

Tyler held his gaze. “I mean it.”

There was no pressure in it.

That, more than anything, made Ethan want to move closer.

He did, but only by an inch.

Maybe less.

It was enough that Tyler’s hand loosened, slid from his wrist into his palm. Enough that the space between them stopped feeling abstract and started feeling chosen.

Ethan let out a breath that was almost a laugh. “You always this patient?”

Tyler’s mouth tipped faintly at one corner. “No.”

“Good.”

Tyler smiled properly then, brief and unguarded.

Ethan had the sudden urge to touch his face just to see if the expression stayed there.

Instead he said, “If Mark saw us in here, he’d absolutely say something stupid.”

Tyler’s mouth tipped. “He’d say something stupid if he saw a lamp.”

Ethan laughed. “That’s true.”

Tyler’s fingers shifted in his hand, tightening slightly.

“You worried about him?” he asked.

Ethan knew who he meant.

Mark.

Maybe more than Mark.

The whole house. The whole structure of it. The way being seen there was never just being seen, but categorized, used, pulled into place.

He thought about Mark on the deck that afternoon saying, You don’t have to make it weird.

He thought about how little and how much that meant.

“A little,” Ethan said honestly.

Tyler nodded once. “Me too.”

That surprised him enough to show on his face.

Tyler saw it.

“I’m not scared of him,” he said. “Or any of them.” He glanced toward the hallway. “But that doesn’t mean I’m in the mood to hand them anything.”

Ethan let that sit.

It was one of the first times Tyler had said something that plain. Not buried under a joke or a shrug. Just true.

Ethan looked at their hands, still joined between them.

“You make it sound easy.”

Tyler shook his head. “No. I just don’t think easy is the point.”

The words landed softly, but they stayed.

Outside, something brushed against the side of the house. A branch maybe. The sound scraped lightly and passed. Somewhere in the front room, the song changed again, slower now, almost low enough to disappear.

Tyler looked at him for a long second.

Then he lifted their joined hands slightly, just enough to draw Ethan forward the last inch or two.

Not much.

Enough.

Ethan could feel the warmth of Tyler through his shirt now, the exact line where their bodies almost touched. He didn’t think about what came after. He just let himself want the nearness of it.

Tyler’s forehead brushed his once.

It could have become a kiss.

Instead they stayed there, slight and steady.

Ethan closed his eyes for half a second.

When Tyler stepped back, he didn’t let go immediately. His thumb slid once across Ethan’s knuckles before their hands came apart.

“We should go back before somebody comes looking,” he said.

Ethan opened his eyes. “Yeah.”

Neither moved.

Tyler smiled faintly. “In a second.”

That made Ethan laugh again, softer this time.

The house found them a minute later anyway. A voice from the hallway calling for Tyler. Another from farther off asking where the extra glasses were. Life reasserting itself with no respect for timing.

Tyler glanced toward the door, then back at Ethan with something like resignation and amusement folded together.

“There it is,” he said.

Ethan nodded.

He picked up his glass from the sill, now only faintly warm, and followed Tyler out into the hallway.

The house received them without noticing anything had changed.

The music was still low. The kitchen still bright with steam and motion. Neil was back near the turntable, arguing now with someone in a flannel over whether the next record was too depressing for the hour. People had shifted rooms, changed positions, picked up and set down conversations, but the feeling of the place remained intact.

It held.

Tyler peeled off toward the kitchen after a quick look back, one that didn’t have to mean more than it did.

Ethan stayed where he was for a second, near the little side-room door, watching the whole thing move.

No one scanned him.

No one sorted him into place.

No one asked him to prove he deserved to be there.

Later, when he and Tyler stepped back out into the night, the air had gone cooler. The walk to the car felt shorter than the walk in.

They didn’t talk much.

The quiet came back easily, settling between them without effort. Tyler drove with one hand on the wheel, the other resting near the gearshift, the dashboard throwing pale green light across his wrist. The road curved back toward campus through patches of dark woods and empty intersections, the occasional porch light glowing in the distance like a held breath.

Ethan watched the headlights move over the road ahead.

Westmore would still be there when they got back.

The noise. The pressure. The roles waiting to be stepped into.

None of that had gone away.

He looked out the window, then over at Tyler, who kept his eyes on the road.

For a second Ethan let himself imagine what it would feel like not to split so cleanly between one life and another. Not yet. Just someday.

The thought didn’t scare him the way it once would have.

When the bell tower finally came into view through the trees, white against the dark, Ethan felt the old tightening in his chest begin out of habit.

Then stop.

Not disappear.

Just stop ruling everything else.

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

It wasn’t the distance. The same long stretch of highway unspooled past the windshield, the same gas stations and exit signs he half-recognized without fully placing. But something about it moved faster now, like the trip had lost whatever weight it carried the first time.

Or maybe he had.

Tyler drove.

He had one hand loose on the wheel, the other resting against the open window, fingers tapping absently against the door as warm air pushed through the car. The late August heat had started to break, just enough to take the edge off the humidity. It carried that faint dry smell Ethan associated with the end of summer, something shifting whether you noticed it or not.

They hadn’t talked much in the last hour.

Not in any deliberate way. It just settled there, the quiet between them not empty so much as already filled. A kind of understanding that didn’t need checking in on.

Ethan rested his elbow against the window and watched the trees blur past. He could feel Tyler beside him in that way that had become familiar over the summer: steady, unintrusive, always there without asking for attention.

It still surprised him sometimes. Not the feeling itself. That had stopped being surprising weeks ago. It was how easily it had become normal.

He didn’t say that out loud.

Tyler finally broke the silence.

“Nervous?” he asked, casual enough that it almost passed.

Ethan let out a quiet breath. “A little.”

“That’s a lie.”

Ethan smiled faintly. “Yeah.”

They drove another few seconds without speaking.

Tyler tapped his fingers once against the door. Then:

“You think Mark’s gonna be weird?”

Ethan glanced over. “About what?”

Tyler didn’t look at him. “Yeah.”

A beat.

Ethan looked back out the window. “We left it fine.”

“Fine’s not the same thing.”

“No.”

That was as far as it went.

Westmore came into view slowly, the brick buildings rising out of the trees in that same deliberate, almost staged way he remembered. White columns. Symmetry. The kind of place that looked like it had always been there, even if you knew better.

Tyler slowed as they passed the sign at the entrance.

“You sure you’re good?” he asked, not looking over.

Ethan nodded once. “Yeah.”

It was the same answer he’d given the first time he’d arrived. It felt different now.

They drove through campus without speaking, past the quad, past the bell, past clusters of students moving in uneven lines between dorms and cars. There were more people than he expected for this early—groups already forming, voices carrying across the lawns, the low hum of a place waking up again.

But something about it felt off.

Not wrong. Just slightly misaligned.

Tyler seemed to notice it too.

“Feels busier,” he said.

“Yeah.”

Ethan watched a group of freshmen dragging suitcases across the grass, one of them already sweating through his shirt, another laughing too loudly at something that didn’t quite land. The energy was familiar. Too familiar. It felt like a memory he wasn’t inside of anymore.

Fraternity Row looked the same.

That was the first thing that hit him as they turned onto the narrow street. The houses sat in their same uneven line, porches wide and open, lawns worn down in the same patches from years of use. Delta Chi stood where it always had, white porch railing chipped , the front steps worn down from people coming and going.

But the lawn was crowded.

Not with brothers. Not exactly.

Boxes. Bags. People who didn’t look like they belonged there.

Tyler pulled up along the curb and killed the engine.

For a second neither of them moved.

Ethan looked at the house, then at the people moving in and out of it. A kid in a wrinkled polo struggled with a duffel bag that looked too heavy for him. Another stood on the porch with a clipboard like it meant something, gesturing vaguely toward the front door while someone else dragged a mattress inside.

“What the hell is this?” Tyler muttered.

Ethan shook his head slightly. “No idea. Coming back this early, I figured it would just be freshmen and a few guys.”

He reached for the door handle, then paused.

That same feeling again. Not wrong. Just… not what he’d expected.

He opened the door and stepped out into the heat.

Inside, the house felt tighter.

Not physically smaller. Just… full.

The entryway was lined with bags, stacked unevenly against the walls like they’d been dropped and forgotten. Voices echoed from deeper in the house, overlapping in a way that made it hard to track who was saying what.

Ethan stepped around a suitcase that had no business being in the middle of the floor and glanced toward the stairs.

A freshman stood halfway up, looking lost, like he’d taken a wrong turn and wasn’t sure how to correct it.

“Hey,” Ethan said, almost automatically.

The kid looked at him, relief flickering across his face. “Uh—do you know where—”

“No idea,” Ethan said, not unkindly. “Just got here.”

The kid nodded like that answered something, then continued up the stairs anyway.

Tyler came in behind him, closing the door with his foot.

“This isn’t right,” he said quietly.

“No.”

Ethan didn’t elaborate.

They moved through the house together, navigating around people, stepping over boxes, adjusting their pace without needing to say anything.

By the time they reached the stairs, Ethan already knew.

Whatever this year was supposed to be—

It wasn’t going to look like he’d imagined.

Their room was at the end of the hall. Eli’s old room.

Or at least, it was supposed to be.

Ethan pushed the door open and stopped.

Two beds. Close together. One already partially claimed by a duffel bag tossed across the mattress like a placeholder. Clothes spilling out of it. A jacket he recognized immediately.

Tyler stepped up behind him. “That yours?”

Ethan shook his head slowly.

“No.”

He stepped inside anyway, set his bag down against the wall, and took in the space. It felt smaller than it should have. Or maybe it was just the way it was already occupied.

Tyler leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed loosely.

“This isn’t what we talked about.”

Ethan let out a quiet breath. “No.”

He didn’t say more than that.

Because there wasn’t anything to say yet.

The door slammed open before either of them could move again.

“Jesus, it’s like a refugee camp down there—”

Mark.

He came in fast, like he always did, energy hitting the room before the rest of him caught up. A backpack slung over one shoulder, another bag dragging behind him, already talking before he fully registered who was there.

“—they’ve got kids in the chapter room, I swear to God—”

He stopped mid-sentence.

Grinned.

“Well, shit.”

He dropped the bag without ceremony and crossed the room in three quick steps, clapping Ethan on the shoulder hard enough to jolt him forward.

“You made it.”

Ethan laughed, the sound coming easier than he expected. “Yeah.”

Mark turned to Tyler, pulling him into a quick, easy half-hug like no time had passed.

“You too. Good. We’re gonna need it.”

Tyler smiled faintly. “Looks like it.”

Mark snorted, already moving again, unpacking in that chaotic, unfocused way that never seemed to bother him.

“You have no idea,” he said, kicking his bag onto the empty bed like it belonged there. “They shut down McClintock. Whole freshman dorm. Remodeling or some bullshit. So now they’re just—” he gestured vaguely toward the floor below them “—sticking people wherever they can fit.”

Ethan glanced at Tyler.

There it was.

Just like that.

No buildup. No warning.

Mark kept going, oblivious.

“I walked in and there’s, like, four kids sleeping on couches downstairs. Some of them are in here, some are in other houses, I think they rented a place off campus too—no one knows what’s going on.”

He pulled a t-shirt out of his bag and tossed it onto the bed, then looked up like something had just occurred to him.

“Oh—yeah. I’m in here with you guys.”

Of course you are.

Ethan nodded once. “Makes sense.”

Mark didn’t catch anything in his tone. He rarely did.

“Right?” he said. “Better than getting stuck in some random house with people I don’t know.”

Tyler shifted his weight slightly, still leaning against the doorframe.

“Yeah,” he said. “Better.”

He didn’t sound convinced.

The hallway felt narrower on the way back down.

Ethan stepped around a stack of boxes someone had abandoned against the wall, the cardboard already soft at the corners from being dragged. Voices carried from downstairs, louder now, overlapping in a way that made it impossible to follow any one conversation for long.

Mark had disappeared almost immediately after they came down, pulled into a knot of guys near the stairs like he’d never left. Tyler lingered for a minute, said something to someone Ethan didn’t catch, then drifted toward the back of the house.

Ethan stood there a second longer than he needed to.

Then turned and headed outside.

The deck was empty.

Late afternoon light stretched across the lawn, catching the dust in the air, the edges of things. The heat had settled into something duller, less aggressive, the kind that made everything feel slower without actually cooling anything down.

Ethan leaned against the railing and let out a breath he hadn’t realized he was holding.

The house sounded different from out here. Muffled. Contained.

“Thought I’d find you out here.”

Ethan glanced over.

Mark stepped through the door, already halfway into a cigarette he must’ve grabbed on the way out. He leaned against the railing beside him like it was the most natural thing in the world.

“You always do this,” he said, lighting it properly now, cupping the flame against the breeze. “Get here, disappear for ten minutes, come back like nothing happened.”

Ethan smiled faintly. “It’s been five.”

“Feels longer.”

Mark exhaled, watching the smoke drift out over the lawn. For a second, neither of them said anything.

It wasn’t uncomfortable.

Just quieter than the rest of the house.

“You talk to Eli any?” Mark asked.

Ethan shook his head. “No.”

“He was home earlier this week,” Mark said. “In and out. Same as ever.”

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” Mark shrugged. “He’s got something lined up in Atlanta, I think. Or Richmond. Depends which day.”

Ethan nodded once.

Mark flicked ash over the railing.

“Catherine was there too. Of course.”

That almost got a reaction.

Almost.

Mark caught it anyway.

He didn’t say anything about it.

“I was thinking about last year,” Mark said after a beat.

Ethan didn’t look at him.

“Yeah?”

“Yeah.” Mark shifted his weight slightly, cigarette hanging loose between his fingers. “I didn’t really know what to do with it at the time.”

Ethan let out a quiet breath. “You didn’t have to do anything.”

“I know.” A pause. “Still.”

The word hung there for a second, unfinished.

Mark tapped the cigarette once against the railing, then glanced over.

“You good?”

Ethan nodded. “Yeah.”

Mark held his gaze for a second longer than necessary, like he was deciding whether to push it.

Then didn’t.

“Good,” he said.

It didn’t settle anything.

But it was enough.

From inside, someone shouted Mark’s name.

He turned his head toward the door automatically.

“Duty calls,” he said, pushing off the railing.

He paused for half a second, then added, almost as an afterthought:

“You don’t have to… you know. Make it weird.”

Ethan looked at him.

Mark shrugged. “You’re fine.”

Then he was gone.

Ethan stayed where he was.

The yard stretched out in front of him, worn in the same places it had been last year. The same patches of dirt where grass refused to grow. The same uneven line where the lawn gave way to the street.

Nothing had changed.

Not really.

He pushed himself off the railing and went back inside.

The house had filled in while he was gone.

Music now—low, but present. Someone had set-up the old stereo system and after a spark and a whiff of ozone, it came to life. They decided that was enough of a reason to celebrate. The kitchen was crowded, two guys arguing over something that didn’t matter, another leaning against the counter like he’d claimed it permanently.

Connor was already mid-story when Ethan walked in.

“—I’m telling you, the kid tried to put his mattress in the hallway like that was gonna work—”

“Who?” Teddy asked from the couch, not looking up.

“Some freshman. Polo tucked in, like that was gonna save him.”

“That’s your first mistake,” Teddy said. “You show up tucked in, they smell it on you.”

Marco laughed from the doorway, shaking his head. “You’re all acting like you weren’t exactly the same.”

“Speak for yourself,” Connor shot back.

“I am,” Marco said. “You were worse.”

That landed.

Connor grinned, unbothered. “Yeah, well. Look at me now.”

“That’s not helping your case,” Teddy muttered.

Ethan leaned against the wall, watching.

It was the same rhythm.

The same jokes. The same cadence. The same easy overlap of voices that made it feel like nothing had changed at all.

But the edges were different.

Connor wasn’t trying to impress anyone. Teddy didn’t bother sitting up. Marco moved through the room like he knew exactly where he fit.

They weren’t performing. They were settled.

Or better at pretending not to.

A freshman hovered near the kitchen doorway, clearly unsure if he was supposed to step in or keep moving.

Connor spotted him immediately.

“Hey,” he called, snapping his fingers once. “You. What’s your name?”

The kid straightened. “Uh—Ryan.”

“Ryan what?”

“Dalton.”

Connor nodded like that meant something. “You got a room?”

“Kind of?”

“Good,” Connor said. “Then you can help us out.”

The kid blinked. “With what?”

Connor grinned. “We’ll figure it out.”

Teddy laughed quietly. Marco didn’t say anything.

Ethan watched the kid hesitate.

Then nod.

Mark reappeared out of nowhere, clapping the kid on the back like they were already friends.

“Ryan, right? Welcome to the show.”

The kid looked overwhelmed and relieved at the same time.

Mark turned, catching Ethan’s eye across the room.

There was something there.

Recognition, maybe.

Or just timing.

“They’ve got half a pledge class handed to us,” Mark said to no one in particular. “We’d be idiots not to use it.”

Connor perked up. “Now you’re talking.”

“Live-in pledges?” Teddy said, finally sitting up. “That’s aggressive.”

“That’s efficient,” Mark shot back. “They’re already here. Might as well make it worth it.”

Marco shook his head, smiling. “You don’t waste time, do you?”

Mark grinned. “Never have.”

Ethan didn’t move.

He watched Mark slide into it like it was nothing.

Like this was exactly how it was supposed to work.

Maybe it was.

That was the problem.

Tyler stood across the room, leaning against the far wall, watching the same thing.

He didn’t say anything.

He didn’t need to.

Ethan could feel it anyway.

Someone turned the music up.

Not loud. Just enough.

A shift.

The room adjusted around it without anyone calling it out.

More people filtered in from the hallway. Someone opened a beer. Someone else laughed too loudly at something that didn’t quite land.

The house didn’t need a plan.

It just needed people.

Ethan stayed where he was for a second longer.

Then pushed off the wall and stepped into it.

By the time Ethan grabbed a beer, the house had tipped.

Not all at once.

It never did.

It was the small shifts: the music turned up just enough to bleed into the hallway, a second cooler dragged out from somewhere, someone propping the front door open like that alone made it an invitation.

People moved differently now.

Looser. Louder. Like they’d collectively decided this was happening without needing to say it.

“Here,” Connor said, shoving a can into Ethan’s hand without looking at him. “You’re standing there like a narc.”

Ethan took it. “Good to see you too.”

Connor grinned. “You never left.”

“Feels like it.”

“That’s your first mistake,” Connor said, already turning back to whatever story he’d been telling before Ethan walked up. “You think you leave. You don’t.”

Teddy laughed from the couch, feet up on the armrest. “He’s right. Place just waits.”

Marco appeared in the doorway, beer already in hand. “Like mold.”

“That’s not reassuring,” Ethan said.

“Wasn’t meant to be,” Marco replied.

Near the kitchen, Mark had already pulled together a loose circle, half brothers and half freshmen, all of them talking over each other in that early-semester way where nobody quite knew what the night was yet.

Ethan watched as Mark leaned in toward Ryan, hand on the kid’s shoulder like they’d known each other longer than ten minutes.

“You play anything?” Mark was asking.

“Uh—lacrosse,” Ryan said.

Mark’s grin widened. “Perfect. You’re already ahead.”

Ryan looked like he wasn’t sure if that was a joke.

It wasn’t.

Tyler stood near the wall, exactly where Ethan had left him.

He hadn’t moved much.

Beer in hand, untouched.

Watching.

Not disengaged. Just not pulled in.

Ethan made his way over, weaving through bodies, catching fragments of conversation he didn’t need to follow.

“Fun,” Tyler said as Ethan stepped up beside him.

“Something like that.”

Tyler glanced toward Mark’s group. “He’s not wasting any time.”

Ethan followed his gaze.

Mark laughed at something Ryan said, clapping him on the back again, already positioning himself at the center of it.

“No,” Ethan said. “He’s not.”

Tyler took a sip of his beer, finally. “You think they know what they walked into?”

Ethan watched the freshmen—how they hovered just a second too long before speaking, how they laughed a beat too late, how they kept checking the room like they were looking for cues.

“No,” he said. “Not yet.”

A group pushed through the front door, bringing with them a burst of louder voices, the kind that carried across the whole house whether you wanted it to or not.

Someone turned the music up again.

This time, nobody pretended it was background.

Ethan felt it then.

Not the noise.

The shift.

The way the room shifted around it, like this was the part everyone had been waiting for.

He took a sip of his beer, barely tasting it.

Tyler was still beside him.

Close. Not touching. Close enough that Ethan could feel the heat from his arm if he leaned even slightly.

He didn’t.

Across the room, Mark caught his eye.

For a second, everything else dropped out.

Mark didn’t look confused. He didn’t look suspicious. He just looked.

Then someone said his name and he turned away, pulled back into the center of things like it was gravity.

“Come on,” Tyler said quietly.

Ethan glanced over. “Where?”

Tyler tipped his head toward the hallway. “Anywhere but here.”

Ethan hesitated.

Not because he didn’t want to go.

Because he knew what it meant to leave.

Just for a minute.

Just long enough to step out of it.

He set his beer down on the nearest surface without finishing it.

“Yeah.”

They made it halfway down the hallway before someone called Ethan’s name.

He stopped.

Tyler didn’t.

Not right away.

He took another step, then paused, turning back just enough.

Ethan looked over his shoulder.

Mark stood near the kitchen, arm slung around someone Ethan didn’t recognize, grinning like he owned the place.

“Where you going?” he called.

Ethan held his gaze for a second.

“Just a minute,” he said.

Mark nodded like that made sense.

Because it did.

By the time Ethan turned back, Tyler had already stepped away.

Not far.

Just enough.

The distance was small.

It felt bigger than that.

They didn’t say anything as they stepped outside.

The deck was fuller now, voices spilling out into the yard, someone leaning too far over the railing, another group gathered near the steps like they’d claimed that space for the night.

It wasn’t quiet. Just less.

Ethan leaned against the column, the wood warm from the heat of the day.

Tyler stood beside him.

Close again.

Not touching.

“You good?” Tyler asked.

Ethan let out a breath. “Yeah.”

Tyler watched the yard for a second.

“Doesn’t feel like it,” he said.

Ethan didn’t argue.

From inside, the music swelled again, louder now, the bass carrying through the walls.

Someone laughed too hard.

Someone shouted something that got lost before it reached them.

The house had settled into it.

Fast.

Like it had been waiting.

Ethan looked back through the open door.

Mark was still there, exactly where he’d been, surrounded now, talking, laughing, already shaping the night around him without effort.

Connor had pulled two of the freshmen into something that looked suspiciously like a drinking game. Teddy was calling out rules from the couch. Marco leaned in the doorway, watching it all unfold like he’d seen it a hundred times before.

Which he had.

So had Ethan.

Only now he could see it.

Not from inside.

From the edge.

Tyler shifted beside him, just enough that their shoulders almost touched.

Almost.

Ethan didn’t move closer.

He didn’t move away either.

“It’s the same,” Tyler said.

Ethan nodded once. “Yeah.”

A beat.

“Doesn’t feel the same.”

“No.”

They stood there for another second.

Long enough for the moment to become something.

Not long enough to do anything with it.

“Come on,” Tyler said finally, pushing off the column. “We’ll miss everything.”

Ethan huffed a quiet laugh. “Yeah.”

He followed him back inside.

The noise hit them again immediately.

Louder now. Fuller.

The house completely alive.

Ethan stepped into it without hesitation this time.

Not pulled.

Not pushed.

Just there.

Across the room, Mark caught his eye again.

Grinned.

Raised his beer.

Ethan lifted his hand in response, not quite a wave.

Not quite anything.

Around them, the night kept building.

Freshmen laughing too loud.

Brothers settling into roles they already knew.

Music carrying through the walls.

The whole thing moving forward exactly the way it always did.

Ethan stood in the middle of it, watching.

It was the same place. The same system. The same noise.

Only now he could see where he fit.

And where he didn’t.

He took a drink, finally tasting it this time.

Warm. Flat. Familiar.

And for the first time since he’d arrived, he couldn’t tell if that was supposed to feel better.

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

Over the past year, I’ve been serializing Line & Verse here — one chapter at a time, following Ethan’s first year at Westmore College.

Today, the complete freshman-year edition is available as a collected e-book.

The serialized chapters will remain here. But this edition brings the full arc together in one place — revised, tightened, and shaped intentionally as a single narrative. What begins with orientation and initiation moves through exhaustion, secrecy, desire, collapse, and finally something steadier: the beginning of self-possession.

At its core, Line & Verse is a story about belonging — and what it costs. About masculinity as performance. About ritual, silence, and the quiet moments that undo both. It traces the space between who we pretend to be and who we slowly allow ourselves to become.

If you’ve been reading along, this is the definitive freshman-year volume.

The e-book is available on Amazon here:
Amazon link

If you’ve read the series — here or in the collected edition — an honest review on Amazon would genuinely help the story reach more readers. Leave a Review Here

Paid subscribers have received a complimentary copy as a thank-you for supporting the project early. I’m deeply grateful to those who’ve been here from the beginning.

This is only Year One.

—

Caleb Reed

Further Reading

II keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The hallway outside Ethan’s room didn’t quiet down after dinner the way he expected. Showers ran on both ends of the hall, water pounding tile, steam rolling under the doors like the building itself was exhaling. Someone down the corridor blasted Counting Crows on a shelf stereo with blown-out speakers, the trebles warping each time the door opened. Laughter ricocheted down the hall, followed by a thud loud enough to shake the fluorescent light overhead.

The RA yelled something about “quiet hours start at eleven,” which earned a chorus of dramatic groans and one sarcastic, “We love you, Tyler!” from an unknown door.

Ethan stood in his doorway, towel around his neck, taking it all in. He felt both invisible and on display. Everyone here seemed to know who they were performing for, even when no one was watching.

Tyler McKay walked by with a gym bag slung over one shoulder, hair still damp from the pool. He nodded once, efficient and self-contained, the kind of gesture that meant acknowledgment rather than greeting. It landed harder on Ethan than it should have.

“You ready?” Mark asked behind him.

Ethan wasn’t. “Yeah.”

They crossed the quad together. The air was warm enough to feel heavy, thick with the smell of fresh mulch and whatever clung to the old brick buildings after a hot day. Students streamed toward the Welcome Back mixer in small clusters, groups of boys falling into loose formation without needing to speak.

The chapel lawn had been transformed into what looked like the world’s least convincing festival. Lanterns dangled from poles in uneven lines, and a banner proclaiming WELCOME BACK, GENTLEMEN sagged between two trees like a surrender flag. Folding tables overflowed with popcorn, lemonade, and bowls of pretzels that already tasted stale. A few faculty members hovered near the edges wearing name tags, smiling with that hopeful, brittle energy adults used when trying too hard.

Mark looked around with a grin. “This is awful. You’re going to love it.”

Ethan wasn’t convinced. His stomach tightened the way it always had at the start of something unfamiliar—his version of bracing for impact.

A cluster of freshmen played an awkward game of catch nearby, shouting each other’s names too eagerly. Others stood in small circles, performing confidence as if it were a team sport.

Mark introduced him to a blur of people—Walker from Richmond, Andy from Charlottesville, Ben who played golf, someone with the improbable nickname “Biscuit.” Every handshake felt like a mild test. Ethan smiled like his mother had taught him: warm enough not to look standoffish, reserved enough not to look desperate.

He wasn’t sure what these boys saw when they looked at him. His mother had always said he had “the right family polish,” but that had never fit comfortably. His father’s business—the marine supply shop he’d built from nothing—was practical, unpretentious, the opposite of lineage. His mother, though born into her Charleston pedigree, carried herself like someone maintaining a standard no one had explicitly asked her to uphold. Ethan had grown up between those worlds, fluent in both and fully at home in neither.

A hum passed through the crowd.

Not a sound—more like a shift in attention, a turn of heads, a tightening of posture.

Ethan didn’t have to guess at the cause.

Eli crossed the lawn with two juniors flanking him. He wasn’t dressed differently—just a clean T-shirt, mesh shorts, sneakers—but his presence rearranged the energy around him. Some guys straightened unconsciously; others tried not to stare. Eli didn’t appear to notice any of it.

He spotted Mark immediately and shifted his path.

“You two made it,” Eli said, clapping his brother’s shoulder.

His eyes slid to Ethan.

“Roommate,” Eli said, not unkindly.

Ethan nodded. “Hey.”

“You guys heading to the house later?” Eli asked Mark, his tone casual but unmistakably directive.

Mark grinned. “Wouldn’t miss it. Ethan’s coming too.”

Eli held Ethan’s gaze a beat longer this time, a faint flicker of something—curiosity, maybe—crossing his expression.

“If he’s with you, he’s good.”

And like that, he peeled off again, swallowed by boys eager to talk to him.

Mark nudged Ethan. “That’s a big deal.”

“I’ll take your word for it.”

“Oh, you should.” Mark looked delighted. “You’re already not invisible. That’s half the battle here.”

Ethan wasn’t sure if that was comforting or terrifying.

The event began to dissolve. Faculty packed up the nametag table. Someone unplugged the speakers mid-song, creating an awkward, echoing silence. Groups drifted away, all headed toward the same direction—Fraternity Row.

Mark tossed his empty cup into a bin. “Delta Chi time.”

They cut across the quad, now lit by the amber glow of lampposts. Voices echoed off the brick. The night smelled like wet grass and anticipation.

As they approached Delta Chi, Ethan felt it before he saw it—music thumping, bodies moving in ways that didn’t make sense from a distance. The house was alive. Boys leaned over the porch railing shouting greetings. Red cups littered the steps like breadcrumbs.

Mark didn’t knock. He didn’t even slow down. He pushed through the front door as if it had been built for him.

Heat hit instantly—thick, humid, smelling like beer, sweat, cologne, and something sharp he couldn’t identify. The living room was a crush of bodies—older guys sprawled across mismatched couches, pledges from last year running drinks, laughter ricocheting off the walls.

Ethan froze.

Mark had to tug his sleeve. “Come on. You’re fine.”

But Ethan wasn’t fine. He was overwhelmed and underprepared. The rules of this room were different from anything he understood. He recognized the choreography—the mirrored version of his mother’s cocktail parties back home—but here it was amplified, unfiltered, stripped of polite disguise.

Jason was perched on the arm of a chair at the edge of the room, speaking low to a group of brothers. His posture was relaxed, but his eyes scanned the room—calm, steady, supervisory without seeming authoritative. Ethan realized instantly: nothing got past him.

Mark pushed Ethan forward. “Jason, this is Ethan.”

Jason smiled. “Still upright. Good sign.”

Someone stumbled into them, sloshing a drink. Jason caught the cup mid-air, handed it back, and said, “Let’s make better choices,” with the tone of someone who meant it.

Ethan admired the economy of it.

The Delta Chi living room was a blur: clashing music, half-finished conversations, shoulders brushing his as people passed, laughter erupting in pockets. Ethan did his best to follow Mark’s lead, nodding through introductions, gripping his beer too tightly, trying to understand where to stand, how to hold himself.

And then he saw Eli.

He was leaning against the far hallway doorway, arms crossed, head tilted as he listened to someone. He wasn’t the loudest one in the room—he didn’t have to be. People moved around him like water around a rock, adjusting their paths without noticing.

Ethan’s breath hitched—embarrassing, but involuntary.

He looked away quickly, trying to swallow the reaction.

The crush of noise suddenly felt like too much. His chest tightened. His grip on the beer slicked with sweat.

“I’m going to—” Ethan gestured vaguely.

Mark nodded immediately. “Porch. Go.”

Ethan slipped through the kitchen and pushed out the side door.

Night air hit him like a reprieve—cooler, cleaner. He leaned against the porch railing and inhaled until he could feel his heartbeat again.

Boys lingered on the lawn—someone vomiting behind a hedge, two guys arguing over who owed who for a pack of cigarettes, a laughing group tossing bottle caps at the streetlamp.

Ethan rubbed the back of his neck. He felt stupid for needing a break so early. He felt even more stupid for caring.

The porch door creaked behind him…

The porch door creaked behind him. Ethan didn’t turn at first. He didn’t want to make awkward eye contact with someone coming out here to puke or to hook up.

A lighter clicked. The faint scratch of flint, a brief flare of orange.

“You hiding or breathing?” a voice asked.

Eli.

Ethan turned his head, just enough.

Eli stood a few feet away, one shoulder against the porch post, cigarette cupped in his hand against the breeze. The porch light caught the side of his face, turning the sharp lines softer, the curve of his jaw still visible.

“Little of both,” Ethan said. It came out rougher than he meant.

Eli huffed a soft laugh, exhaling smoke toward the yard. “First Delta Chi party?”

“First… any of this,” Ethan admitted.

“Yeah.” Eli nodded once. “It’s a lot.”

He said it so easily that Ethan almost believed him. It was strange to realize Eli remembered being new here, too.

They stood in silence for a moment, the muffled thump of bass vibrating through the floorboards under their feet. Down on the lawn, someone shouted for a ride. A bottle clinked against the curb.

Eli glanced over, really looking at him now. “Mark gave you the full sales pitch yet?”

“Some of it.”

“That tracks.” Eli flicked ash off the end of his cigarette. “Look, you don’t have to like all this to survive here. You just have to learn how to move through it.”

“How long does that take?”

Eli smiled, but there was something tired in it. “Depends what you’re trying to prove.”

Ethan didn’t have an answer for that.

His mother would have said he didn’t have anything to prove—that he’d already been raised correctly, that Westmore was simply the next proper step. His father would have said he didn’t need any of this, that work mattered more than old buildings and old names.

Standing on the porch, Ethan wasn’t sure either of them understood what this place actually was.

“You’ll be fine,” Eli said, like it was a conclusion he’d come to. “You don’t look like an idiot. That helps.”

“High praise,” Ethan said, a little surprised to find himself teasing back.

Eli’s mouth twitched, like he hadn’t expected that either.

From inside, someone yelled his name. The door swung open for a second, spilling light and noise across the boards. A brother stuck his head out.

“Bennett, we need you for a minute. Travis is about to do something incredibly stupid.”

“On my way.” Eli crushed the cigarette out on the railing with two fingers and flicked the butt into an empty cup by the door. He paused, hand on the knob.

“You get overwhelmed,” he said quietly, “step out. Don’t just disappear. It freaks the brothers out if they can’t find you. And Mark.”

Ethan nodded.

Eli gave him one last quick look—something like approval, or maybe just recognition—then disappeared back inside.

The house swallowed the noise again.

Ethan stayed on the porch long enough for his breathing to slow. He felt less like he was about to jump out of his skin, but more aware of how precarious all of this was—how easy it would be to misstep, to become the story people told for the rest of the year.

He picked up his beer, now mostly foam, and went back in.

The music hit harder after the quiet outside. The living room felt smaller, but he saw more details now—the carved paddle hanging crookedly above the fireplace, the framed composite on the wall with rows of faces frozen in time, the gouges in the hardwood where something heavy had been dragged one too many times.

Mark spotted him from across the room. “There you are,” he said, relief obvious even through the alcohol-softened edges of his voice. “Thought you’d bailed.”

“Just needed air.”

“Fair. Come on, I want you to meet a couple of guys.”

He dragged Ethan into a small circle near the back of the room—Connor from Richmond, Teddy from Raleigh, Marco from somewhere in New Jersey who wore it like a punchline.

“This is my roommate, Ethan,” Mark said. “He’s pre-med and smarter than all of us.”

“Low bar,” Connor said, raising his cup.

“Always inspiring,” Teddy added.

“Jersey, huh?” Marco asked, squinting at Ethan.

“South Carolina,” Ethan corrected.

“Better,” Marco said, as if that settled it.

The conversation flowed around him—stories about high school misadventures, complaints about the dining hall, rumors about which professors were brutal and which ones didn’t take attendance. Ethan listened more than he spoke, absorbing the rhythm of it.

Jason brushed past once, stopping long enough to pluck keys out of a clearly drunk sophomore’s hand. “No,” he said. “Tomorrow.”

The guy opened his mouth to argue, then seemed to think better of it. Jason squeezed his shoulder and moved on.

A commotion rose near the front door. Ethan turned to see a group of girls coming in—Waverly and Kingston, by the look of them. Sundresses. Hair just tousled enough to look accidental. Pearls that caught the light as they laughed.

Catherine was with them.

He didn’t know that yet, not as a name, but he could tell she mattered. She walked slightly ahead of the others, voice carrying, eyes already scanning the room like she knew who she was there to see.

She made a line for Eli.

“About time,” she said, looping an arm around his. Her perfume cut through the beer and smoke—something sharp and floral that reminded Ethan of the women at his mother’s club parties.

Eli’s smile shifted, brightening on command. He bent his head to hear something she said, hand automatically finding the small of her back.

Mark leaned toward Ethan. “Kingston,” he said, as if announcing a royal title. “That’s Catherine.”

“The on-again?” Connor added.

“And off-again,” Teddy said.

“Mostly on-again when alcohol is involved,” Marco put in.

They all laughed. Ethan didn’t.

He watched the way Eli’s posture changed—looser, more performative. The way Catherine tilted her head, exposing her throat just enough. The way everyone around them seemed to take half a step back, making space without being asked.

It was a scene he’d seen versions of back home—men and women choreographing themselves around each other in drawing rooms and on verandas—but here it stripped down to something more crude, more honest.

He realized, suddenly, that he was staring.

He forced himself to look away.

“Relax,” Mark said quietly. “You’re doing fine.”

Ethan didn’t ask how he’d guessed what he was feeling. He just nodded.

The night thickened. The room stopped being a series of discrete conversations and became one humid, swirling noise. The air tasted like sweat and stale beer. Someone started chanting something Ethan couldn’t make out. Someone else tripped over the edge of the rug and took down two others with him.

At some point, Ethan lost track of him and Mark as separate units. They moved together or not at all. Mark laughed with his head tipped back, eyes bright, completely at ease in the chaos.

Ethan envied it.

He also didn’t entirely believe it was real.

They left the house only when the air felt too thick to breathe and Mark’s sentences started losing subjects.

Outside, the row buzzed with its own ecosystem. Another house blasted classic rock; somewhere a bottle smashed, followed by cheers. The night had turned heavy and cool, the kind of air that clung to clothes and skin.

“Successful evening,” Mark declared as they cut back across the quad. “You didn’t puke, you didn’t cry, no one had to drag you home. Gold star performance.”

“High standards,” Ethan said.

“You’d be surprised how many people fail them.”

The lampposts haloed their faces in sickly yellow. Crickets formed a constant, low chorus beneath everything. The chapel tower loomed dark against the sky, bell silent now.

McClintock was quieter than it had been earlier. A couple of doors stood ajar, light spilling into the hallway. Someone muttered into a phone halfway down the corridor. The RA’s door was closed, a towel stuffed under the crack to block the smell of whatever he was clearly ignoring.

Inside their room, Mark kicked off his shoes and face-planted onto his bed.

“I might die,” he mumbled into the pillow.

“You’ll be fine,” Ethan said.

Mark rolled onto his back, one arm thrown over his eyes. “You good?”

“I think so.”

“Good.” His voice was already fading. “You’re gonna like it here.”

He was asleep before Ethan could decide whether he believed him.

Ethan turned off the overhead light and left the lamp on his desk burning low. The fan in the window hummed and rattled, pulling in air that smelled faintly of damp earth and cigarette smoke.

He peeled off his shirt, damp with sweat from the house, and tossed it over the back of his chair. The room was cluttered now with the evidence of two lives being unboxed—laundry bags, books, posters still rolled in tubes. It already looked less like a blank slate and more like a holding pattern.

He lay down on his bed and stared at the ceiling.

His body still felt keyed up, like the music was still reverberating somewhere in his chest. His ears rang with leftover noise. When he closed his eyes, he saw the living room again—the couch, the composite, the cluster of brothers at the fireplace, Catherine’s arm looped through Eli’s, Jason’s hand closing around a set of keys, Tyler’s head turning in his direction without stopping.

He thought of his parents.

His mother would have liked the idea of tonight if not the execution—the right people, the right connections, the boys you’ll be alongside in boardrooms later, that whole speech. She’d have hated the beer on the floor and the music too loud to carry a proper conversation. She would have told him to be charming but not eager, interested but not impressed.

His father would have said something like, Don’t let these boys make you soft. You’re here to get an education, not a social life, and then asked quietly, later, if anyone seemed like the kind of person you could trust.

None of that had been on his mind when he was in the house.

All of that crowded in now.

He thought about Eli on the porch, cigarette burning down between his fingers. The way his voice had softened a notch when he’d said First night’s a lot. The way he’d advised: step out, don’t disappear. The way he had looked at him twice, like he was filing him under something more specific than “Mark’s roommate.”

He thought about the moment Catherine walked through the door and how the entire room had seemed to recalibrate. The way Eli’s posture shifted into an easy charm Ethan didn’t entirely trust.

He turned onto his side and watched Mark’s slow, steady breathing.

This was just the first night, he told himself.

Maybe by next week he’d be able to walk into that house without feeling like his skin was on inside out.

But another thought crept in behind it, quieter, less comforting and more honest:

Something in him had recognized this place immediately.

Not just the brick and oak and bell tower—the way these boys moved, the tight bond and rough edges, the casualness that wasn’t casual at all.

He’d felt it in the spring.

He’d felt it tonight.

It scared him a little that he already wanted more of it.

The fan rattled. Somewhere down the hall, someone laughed, then shushed themselves. A toilet flushed and the building’s pipes answered with a metallic groan.

Ethan stared at the ceiling until his eyes blurred.

Whatever Westmore asked of him, he realized, it wouldn’t be small.

Whatever it changed in him, it wouldn’t be easy to undo.

He finally drifted off with the image of Eli in the doorway still bright in his mind, cigarette ember marking the moment like a small, persistent star.

Like the new chapter? Be sure to catch up on the entire series - all chapters posted here: Line & Verse Serial Novel

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

Ethan had been driving long enough for the air in the Jeep to feel stale. He cracked the window and let the early fall warmth roll in, thinner than South Carolina heat, carrying just the faintest edge of dry leaves. It reminded him of that first visit back in the spring, when nothing much had been happening and somehow that had been the most unsettling part.

The Beck CD in the console stuttered in its familiar spot when the tires hit a seam in the road. He knew the skip by heart. He caught himself waiting for it, half comforted, half irritated that he hadn’t burned a new disc before he left.

He should’ve been thinking about classes or textbooks, all the “opportunities” his parents kept repeating like a script they’d been given. Instead his mind kept circling back to Westmore itself, the part nobody had put in the brochure.

Back home, boys were always acting like someone had a camera pointed at them. Hallways full of too-loud jokes and chest-bumping and “just kidding” shoves with too much force behind them. Every move calibrated for whoever might be watching, especially if there was a girl in the zip code. The confident ones shouted over everyone else. The quiet ones pretended not to care. Everybody was faking something.

Westmore had been different.

That dead April weekend, the admissions office had apologized on loop for the bad timing. Finals, they said. Reading days. No big events. But even half-empty, the place had felt charged. Not loud, not wild. Just full in a way he couldn’t explain.

He remembered standing on the quad while his parents toured the chapel, watching small clusters of guys move across the grass. No girls. No dates. No one leaning in to impress anyone who wasn’t already there. A group leaned against a low wall, talking quietly with their hands in their pockets. Two others tossed a football back and forth, not trying to out-throw each other, just killing time. They slouched on benches, sprawled on the steps of academic buildings, shirts untucked, ties loosened, not performing for anyone beyond the ring they were standing in.

It was still a boys’ club. You could feel the rules running under it like wiring. But in the absence of an audience, something changed. The edges softened. The constant reaching eased a little.

Ethan hadn’t had a word for it. Still didn’t. It wasn’t attraction—at least not in the way he understood that word. It wasn’t simple envy either. It felt more like recognition at a distance, like watching people relax into a version of themselves they didn’t show in public.

For one thin slice of an afternoon, he’d imagined what it might feel like not to brace all the time. To be in a place where the noise of pretending dropped, even half an inch.

He’d liked that feeling more than he wanted to admit. It had bothered him that he liked it. That was the piece he never said out loud.

He lit a cigarette, took a quick drag, and flicked it out the window before he could talk himself into a second. The last thing he needed was to step out on day one smelling like he was trying to be interesting.

The trees opened up, the road straightened, and the bell tower appeared over the treeline, clean and white against the sky. The same tower that had loomed over him in April, when he’d stood under it and thought, So this is where you go if you want to come out the other end with a certain kind of life.

His father had liked that.

His mother had liked the brochure.

Ethan still wasn’t sure what he liked, but he’d mailed the deposit anyway.

He downshifted as the turn-off approached. There was no way back now that didn’t involve more explaining than he knew how to do.

The stone pillared gate announced WESTMORE COLLEGE in carved serif letters, as if anybody who’d made it this far still needed the reminder. He followed the curve past a manicured lawn with a statue of some founder in a frock coat, then up a slight hill, and there it was: the quad.

He rolled to a slow crawl.

The campus wasn’t empty this time. The place buzzed with move-in day—parents double-parking, trunks yawning open, boys wrestling oversized TVs out of back seats. But even in chaos, there was that same undercurrent from the spring. Packets of guys already in their comfort zone, shouting across the grass, cutting through groups without apology.

No high-pitched laughing from girls at the edges. No clusters of friends in sundresses critiquing outfits from a safe distance. Just men. All shapes, all levels of polish, filling the space in a way that made it feel smaller and larger at the same time.

A pair of young-looking guys in blazers walked past his bumper, one balancing a box fan on his shoulder. Another upperclassman leaned against a tree with his arms crossed, watching a family struggle with a trunk, chin tipped up like he’d seen it all before. A pickup truck idled near the chapel with the bed full of mismatched furniture, two boys perched on the tailgate passing a cigarette back and forth like they had all afternoon.

Nobody looked for an audience beyond whoever was in front of them. It was the same thing he’d felt in April, just louder now. More bodies, same current.

He felt it in his ribs this time, a low hum. Maybe it was nerves. Maybe it was something else. Either way, it was too late to analyze it.

He followed the hand-lettered MOVE-IN signs toward a brick rectangle labeled McCLINTOCK HALL, eased the Jeep into a spot that probably wasn’t legal, and killed the engine.

For a moment he just sat there, fingers resting on the keys. The bell rang the half hour, sound scattering off every red-brick surface like it had nowhere better to go.

“Okay,” he said out loud, to no one. “Here we are.”

The stairwell of McClintock smelled like sweat, bleach, and the faint, permanent tang of old beer that no cleaning crew ever seemed able to erase. Someone had propped the front door open with a cinder block, and the heat poured in unchecked. Music leaked from somewhere above—a muffled guitar riff, cut off mid-strum every time someone opened a door and closed it again.

Ethan hefted his duffel and took the stairs two at a time, partly to look like he wasn’t afraid of them, partly to get it over with.

The hallway was a jumble of open doors and half-unpacked lives. A guy in a Phi something T-shirt shouldered past him carrying a microwave, nodding without smiling. Another leaned in a doorway with a clipboard, calling out room numbers to nervous-looking parents and kids who hadn’t figured out yet that being nervous here was a liability.

McClintock 214, the slip from the admissions packet had said.

The door was already standing open.

His roommate was on the bed by the window, cross-legged, tearing open a roll of posters. Blond, tan, easy grin. The kind of guy who’d never had to worry about whether or not anyone wanted him around.

“You must be Ethan,” he said, like he’d been expecting him for hours. “I’m Mark.”

Ethan shifted the bag on his shoulder. “Yeah. Hey.”

Mark hopped down, crossing the room in two easy strides. His handshake was quick and warm, his eyes already scanning Ethan’s duffel as if cataloging what kind of person he might be based on what he’d packed.

“You find it okay?” Mark asked. “The campus, I mean. It’s not that big, but everyone gets lost once.”

“Not really.” Ethan dropped the bag at the foot of the other bed. “We came up in the spring.”

“Oh, for one of those tours?” Mark rolled his eyes. “I grew up here. Those things are a joke. They only show you the nice parts.”

Ethan tried to think of what they hadn’t shown him that day. He remembered the dining hall, the bell, the empty fraternity row. He wasn’t sure anything had looked particularly nice then. That hadn’t been the point.

“Where’s home?” Mark asked, already turning back to his posters.

“South Carolina. Coast.”

Mark let out a low whistle. “Nice. We’re from up the road. Lynchburg. Well, officially.” He smirked like there was an inside joke Ethan didn’t know yet. “You’ll meet my brother, Eli. He’s a junior. He’s the one people actually like.”

“You’re not liked?”

“I’m a freshman.” Mark shrugged. “We’re all unliked until we prove otherwise.”

He said it lightly, but there was a truth in it that landed hard.

They unpacked with the door open. The room itself was nothing—a pair of beds, mismatched dressers, two narrow desks, and a window that looked out over the back lawn and the brick side of another dorm. A box fan rattled in the sill, failing to move enough air.

Ethan made his bed with the cheap blue sheets his mother had bought at Belk. Mark slapped up a poster of a band Ethan recognized just enough not to comment on. Every few minutes someone shouted in the hall. A box fell. Someone laughed too loud. A parent’s voice floated in, strained and cheerful: This is nice, honey. Really nice.

On Mark’s dresser, propped against a stack of CDs, a photo in a cracked silver frame caught Ethan’s eye. Two blond boys stood on a beach, shoulders slung together, both squinting into the sun. One was definitely Mark—same grin, just smaller. The other was a little taller, with a sharper jaw and a posture that said he knew someone was taking the picture and didn’t mind.

“That your brother?” Ethan asked.

Mark glanced over. “Yeah. Eli.” A flash of pride there, quick and unguarded. “He’s in Delta Chi. He’ll pretend he doesn’t know me for like a week and then start acting like he invented the place.”

Before Ethan could think of a response, footsteps slowed outside the door. A shadow crossed the threshold, then stopped.

“You moved in without me?” The voice was amused, not actually accusing.

Mark’s face split into a grin before Ethan even turned.

Eli Bennett leaned one shoulder against the doorframe, the way people did when they were used to being looked at. Tall, narrower than Mark but stronger through the arms, sun-streaked hair pushed back damp from a shower. He wore an old Westmore T-shirt with the sleeves cut off and a pair of mesh shorts, the casual uniform of someone who’d already decided this was his house and he could dress how he liked in it.

“You’re late,” Mark shot back, already moving toward him. “We could’ve used your charming presence.”

Eli’s mouth quirked. “Traffic.”

He and Mark did a quick one-armed hug, the kind that was more of a collision than an embrace. Ethan watched the way their bodies slotted into a pattern that had clearly been there for years.

“This your roommate?” Eli finally asked, eyes flicking past Mark to Ethan.

“Yeah. Ethan Harris. From South Carolina,” Mark said, like it was a credential.

For a heartbeat, Eli’s gaze settled on him fully.

It wasn’t intense. That would’ve been easier to process. It was assessing, but not in a harsh way. Like he was taking Ethan in from the outside and filing him somewhere, then circling back to some part that had caught his attention without meaning to.

“Long drive,” Eli said. His voice had a soft drawl, not as thick as some Ethan had grown up with, but carrying enough to mark its origins. “You pick a hell of a place to land.”

“I guess we’ll see,” Ethan managed.

Eli smiled then—small, genuine, the kind that made the earlier smirk look like a warm-up.

“Welcome to Westmore,” he said. “Such as it is.”

He pushed off the frame. For a second, he seemed like he might say something else. Instead he tapped a cigarette from behind his ear, waggled it in a silent question at Mark.

“I’m out,” Mark said.

“Of course you are.” Eli tucked it back, already stepping into the hall. “Come by the house later. I’ll show you the civilized part of this circus.”

He lifted a hand in a loose half-wave in Ethan’s direction without looking back, then disappeared into the current of bodies outside.

The smell of his cologne—something clean and faintly sharp—lingered in the doorway after he was gone.

“See?” Mark said, climbing back onto his bed with a grin that looked both proud and impressed. “Told you he’s something.”

Ethan sat down on his own bed, suddenly aware of how damp his shirt was against his back.

“Is he in charge of something?” he asked, immediately wondering if it was a stupid question.

“In charge of everything he thinks he is,” Mark said. “Delta Chi. Half the tailgates. Anything that involves people having fun and possibly getting arrested.” He sounded fond, not critical. “You’ll see.”

In the hallway, someone shouted a last name, followed by muffled laughter. A box thumped against a door. Farther off, the bell tower rang the hour, the sound rolling across the quad and into the cinder block walls.

Ethan leaned back on his elbows and looked up at the ceiling, the cheap stucco catching the light from the open window in uneven shadows. The room smelled like new cardboard, detergent, and the faint trace of whatever Eli’s cologne had been.

He felt that same low hum he’d first noticed in April, now threaded with something sharper. Anticipation. Unease. Maybe both.

He’d wanted to get away from home, from the small-town watchers and their quiet calculations. He’d wanted a clean start. Westmore didn’t feel clean, exactly. It felt like a place that already knew who it wanted him to be.

He wasn’t sure which version of himself had gotten out of the Jeep.

He wasn’t sure which one would still be here when it was time to go home.

But as the hallway noise surged and settled around him, one thing was suddenly clear:

Whatever this year turned him into, Westmore—and people like Eli—were going to have something to do with it.

Like the new chapter? Be sure to catch up on the entire series - all chapters posted here: Line & Verse Serial Novel

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The room was gray, the kind of thin morning light that made everything look like it was waiting. The air through the cracked window felt fresher than it had in days, carrying the faint smell of cut grass from the quad. Somewhere distant, a lawn mower grumbled to life too early, then cut off again.

Tyler was still asleep beside him, one arm thrown across his face, the sheet twisted around his waist. For a moment Ethan just lay there, listening—to the slow, even rise and fall of Tyler’s chest, to the building’s old bones settling, to the low murmur of voices floating up from outside as early-arrival parents staked out parking.

He eased out of bed, careful not to jostle Tyler, and pulled on jeans and a T-shirt. Mark’s bed was still empty, his grandmother’s insistence on “everyone under one roof” winning out over convenience. The Coke-can ashtray sat on the sill, quarter beside it, both catching the weak light.

Tyler blinked awake as Ethan laced his shoes.

“What time is it?” Tyler mumbled.

“Too early.”

“So… graduation time,” Tyler said.

“Pretty much.”

Tyler pushed himself up onto his elbows. “You okay?”

Ethan thought about it, the way he’d answered that question so many times that year with a lie he almost believed himself. “Yeah,” he said. “I think I am.”

“Good.” Tyler yawned. “Go watch the circus. I’ll find coffee and try not to let Clay assign me to ice duty.”

They continued the joke even though Clay was finally graduating this year, ready to hand his clipboard off to someone else.

“See you out there.”

Tyler reached over, hooked two fingers lightly around Ethan’s wrist, and tugged him down for a quick kiss—simple and unhurried, like they’d been doing it for years.

“Don’t cry when they throw their caps,” Tyler said. “I don’t want to have to console you in public.”

“I’ll keep it together.”

By ten, the campus was dressed for ceremony.

White folding chairs spread in tight, disciplined rows across the quad, legs biting into the damp grass. At the far end, a temporary stage had been built over the worn slate path, draped in bunting and the college seal. The fountain ran again, throwing mist into the air that turned gold whenever the sun broke through the clouds.

Parents appeared in clusters, holding program booklets and Ukrop’s bags of snacks. Professors in polyester robes drifted toward the faculty section, adjusting their hoods, pretending not to be checking the time. Someone from the music department had assembled a brass ensemble under a canopy; the warm-up scales floated thin and bright over the murmuring crowd.

Ethan stood by the fountain, watching the water fall back into itself, hands wrapped around a paper cup of bad coffee.

Jason found him there, robe unzipped over his blazer, mortarboard in his hand.

“You look like a man waiting for a verdict,” Jason said.

“Just waiting.”

Jason handed him another cup. “Enjoy it. This is the one day we’re allowed to be sentimental and blame it on tradition.”

“You think you won’t be?”

“I already have a job in Richmond,” Jason said. “Pretending’s practically in the job description.”

Jason glanced toward the gathering line of black robes forming near the library steps.

“I should go let them alphabetize me,” he said. “Wouldn’t want to miss my big moment of getting a blank diploma case.”

He clapped Ethan’s shoulder. “See you on the other side, Harris.”

Ethan watched him jog up the walkway, robe flapping, swallowed easily by the long black line of seniors.

He found a spot near the back of the quad, where the rows of chairs met the heat of the sidewalk. The sun pressed down; the stones warmed beneath his shoes.

The bell rang—abrupt, unceremonious.

The brass band lurched into “Pomp and Circumstance.” The line of seniors began to move, robes whispering as they shuffled towards the stage.

From where he stood, Ethan could pick out familiar frames: Jason’s tall silhouette, Clay’s stiff shoulders, Luke’s lazy swagger, Tyler’s wave from across the crowd. And Eli—of course — was two rows from the front, taller than most of the students around him. His posture was perfect, shoulders relaxed just enough to signal confidence, tassel already angled like he knew where the cameras would be. Even from behind, Ethan could read the effort it took to look that effortless.

He tried not to stare. He failed.

The speeches washed over them—President, Board Chair, some retired judge who had donated money and therefore earned the right to be long-winded. Words like opportunity and responsibility and tradition floated in the thickening heat. The crowd responded where it was supposed to—polite laughter here, murmured assent there.

A grandmother in the row behind Ethan cried in quiet, steady intervals, dabbing at her cheeks with a balled-up tissue that left white lint on her face.

One by one, the seniors crossed the stage—shook hands, accepted empty cases, posed for a picture, smiled for their mothers, blinked into the bright future everyone promised them.

Ethan clapped with everyone else, but not for the stage. For the year that had somehow not ruined him.

When it was his turn, Ethan watched him, the tilt of his chin, the small, unguarded softness to his mouth for that one second. Then someone called another name, and the spell broke.

After the recessional, the quad fractured into a dozen different scenes.

Families clustered around the fountain, around the bell, under the magnolias. Faculty dodged hugs. Siblings threw confetti. Alumni tried to make small talk with each other without admitting they’d already forgotten names.

Jason found him again under the magnolia, robe half-unzipped now, cigar tucked behind his ear.

“You made it,” Jason said.

“So did you.”

“Yeah,” Jason said. “They haven’t revoked it yet. Give ’em time.”

He pulled the cigar out, lit it with a practiced flick. “You did good this year, Harris.”

“Doesn’t feel like it.”

“That’s how you know you’re not delusional,” Jason said. He took a drag, then handed the lighter to Ethan without thinking. “Hold that a second.”

It was a cheap Bic, not anything important, but the motion made something shift in Ethan’s chest anyway. Objects meant different things now.

“Where you headed?” Jason asked.

“Home. Then back in August.”

Jason nodded as if he’d already known. “Good. This place needs people who see it clearly and stay.”

“And you?”

“Richmond. Beige conference rooms. Middle management. Glamour.”

Ethan huffed out a small laugh. “You’ll survive.”

“Barely,” Jason said. “But barely counts.”

He clenched the cigar between his teeth. “Listen,” he said, turning serious. “We didn’t talk about it much, but… I saw what this year did to you. And what you didn’t let it do. That matters. If you ever need anything, you call me. Doesn’t have to be about this place. Doesn’t have to be about… any of it. Just call.”

“I don’t have your number,” Ethan said.

Jason smiled. “I wrote it in your Orgo book.”

“Jason—”

“Don’t make it weird,” Jason said. “I’m older. It’s my job to be sentimental in ways that will make you roll your eyes later.”

He drifted to the edge of the crowd instead, toward the shade.

That’s where Eli found him.

He’d ditched his robe, sleeves rolled, tie loosened, hair damp at the temples. He held the silver lighter from Bid Night—more nicked now, the shine dulled—but unmistakable.

“Guess this belongs to you,” Eli said.

Ethan looked at it but didn’t take it. “I never asked for it.”

“You didn’t have to.”

“You sure you don’t need it where you’re going?”

“No,” Eli said. “I’m done lighting things on fire.”

Catherine’s voice carried across the crowd, calling his name like it was a performance. Eli glanced back.

“Take care of yourself,” he said.

“You too.”

He pressed the lighter into Ethan’s palm. Their fingers brushed—just enough to register—and then Eli stepped away, swallowed by the blur of pastel dresses and camera flashes.

Ethan stood there a long moment, the lighter cool and heavy in his hand.

It wasn’t enough, not for everything that had passed between them. It wasn’t an apology, or an explanation, or a confession. But it was what he could give.

The lighter sat in Ethan’s palm, cool and small and heavier than it should have been.

The Delta Chi house after graduation smelled like beer and barbecue and whatever cologne a dozen boys had been given for Christmas two years ago.

Parents spilled out onto the porch, balancing paper plates loaded with ham biscuits and deviled eggs. Alumni leaned against the railings, cigars in hand, telling minor variations of the same stories they’d been telling since they were the ones in the basement scraping vomit out of the carpet.

Inside, the air was cooler, the music quieter. Somebody had put on a playlist that tried to split the difference between parental approval and nostalgia—Eagles, some old Springsteen, the occasional Hootie track everyone pretended not to like.

Ethan moved through it on autopilot—refilling ice, answering where-are-you-from-again questions, accepting praise for surviving a year that had almost broken him without correcting anyone’s assumptions about what that meant.

Tyler found him in the kitchen, leaning against the counter, staring at a tray of sweating cheese cubes like they held the secret to the universe.

“You look like you’re planning a heist,” Tyler said.

“Just contemplating the lifespan of room-temperature cheddar,” Ethan replied.

“You want to get out of here for a bit?” Tyler asked. “Walk?”

“Can’t,” Ethan said. “Clay already caught me trying to leave once. Said I’m part of the decor until at least three.”

“Human centerpiece,” Tyler said. “Rough gig.”

He reached out, straightened the edge of Ethan’s tie. The touch was small, casual, but it sent a quiet jolt through him.

“Later then,” Tyler said. “I’ll rescue you once the old guard thins out.”

He squeezed Ethan’s elbow—quick, grounding—and disappeared back into the doorway.

Ethan stayed another half hour, maybe more. Time stretched in that particular way it did at events that weren’t for you but required your body as proof something had been accomplished.

He was refilling a cooler when he felt someone watching him.

Mark stood in the doorway to the den, hands in his pockets, hair slightly messed from someone’s grandmother hugging him too hard. His tie was crooked; his eyes were clearer than they’d been in the dorm.

He jerked his chin toward the hallway.

It wasn’t an invitation. It wasn’t exactly a command either. Ethan followed.

The den was half-dark, only one lamp on in the corner. The noise from outside came in blurred, as if the walls had decided to muffle the specifics out of mercy.

Mark stood by the window, curtain shifted just enough to see the lawn.

“I’m not ambushing you,” Mark said, before Ethan could say anything. “I just didn’t want to do this in front of my parents. Or yours. Or whoever counts as whose now.”

“Okay,” Ethan said cautiously.

“I saw you with him,” Mark said. “Out there. Under the tree.”

“With Eli,” Ethan said.

“Yeah,” Mark said. “Him.”

He let the curtain fall, turned. “He gave you that stupid lighter?”

Ethan’s hand tightened around it in his pocket. “Yeah.”

“Good,” Mark said. “One less thing in his room for Mom to cry over when she finds it.”

There was venom in the line, but it wasn’t aimed squarely at Ethan.

“I’m still mad,” Mark said. “Just so we’re clear.”

“I know.”

“But,” Mark went on, “I don’t… I’m not sitting around thinking you seduced my innocent brother and ruined his life anymore. That was a nice fantasy for, like, five minutes. Then I remembered who he is.”

Ethan almost smiled. “Who is he?”

“A guy who’s been lying to himself longer than any of this has been going on,” Mark said. “Even I can see that now.”

He scrubbed a hand over his face. “I still feel like an idiot. And I still don’t know what to do with the fact that you and I lived in the same ten-by-twelve room all year and I never figured it out. That’s on me.”

“It’s not your job to figure me out,” Ethan said quietly. “Or him.”

“Maybe not,” Mark said. “But I wanted to believe I knew the two people I spent the most time with. Turns out, I didn’t know either of you as well as I thought.”

He shifted his weight, looking suddenly older in a way that had nothing to do with the gown hanging on a hook by the door. “I meant what I said the other night. I don’t hate you. I don’t forgive you either, because I’m not sure there’s anything to forgive. I’m just… not there yet.”

“That’s fair,” Ethan said.

“But I don’t think this is the end,” Mark added. “You and me. I think one day we’re going to be drunk at some reunion, giving each other shit for our receding hairlines, and this will be… part of the story. Not the whole thing.”

“Yeah?” Ethan said.

“Yeah,” Mark said. “Assuming we survive year two.”

He smirked, briefly, like the old Mark showing through a crack.

From outside, his mother’s voice floated in, calling his name, stretching it into two syllables.

“I gotta go let my grandmother tell me I look handsome ‘like your brother did at that age,’” Mark said, rolling his eyes. “Don’t leave without saying goodbye. I’ll take that personally.”

“I won’t,” Ethan said.

Mark hesitated at the doorway. “You staying?” he asked. “Next year?”

“Yeah,” Ethan said. “I am.”

Mark nodded once. “Good.”

He disappeared back into the noise. The door swung half-shut behind him, the lamp’s halo shrinking.

Ethan stood there a moment longer, letting his shoulders drop.

By Monday, the Row looked stripped.

Tents were gone. Banners came down, leaving sun-faded rectangles on white paint. The lawn bore the scars: patches of dead grass where coolers had sat, ruts where someone had tried to drive out before the ground was dry.

McClintock’s hallways smelled like dust and bleach. Doors stood open, exposing bare rooms in various stages of abandonment. Someone had left a milk crate full of mixtapes in the lounge with a paper sign that just said TAKE.

Ethan’s side of the room fit into three boxes and a duffel: clothes, books, the lamp, a few odds and ends that didn’t belong anywhere else. His white coat brochure from pre-med advising sat folded in one of the boxes, more question mark than map.

Mark’s half was already empty. The Coke-can ashtray, the quarter, and a lone Westmore baseball cap were the only things left on the windowsill. Ethan picked up the quarter, turned it once between his fingers. It had weight, but less than it used to.

He set it back down beside the ashtray.

Some things could stay here.

He carried the last box down the stairs. The air outside felt thicker, sun leaning into the afternoon.

Tyler was by the Jeep, wrestling with a bungee cord across the back hatch. The boxes were already arranged in a kind of rough geometry: dorm room Tetris, practiced after a year of watching guys move in and out every August and May.

“That the last of it?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah.”

“Good,” Tyler said. “Any longer and I was going to start throwing your stuff out the window and pretending it was a tradition.”

They heaved the box into place. Tyler slammed the hatch, tested the bungee, nodded, satisfied.

Ethan looked back at the building. Mark stood in the doorway, parents flanking him, grandmother parked on a folding chair just outside the shade line like she refused to concede anything to the heat.

“You ready?” Tyler asked.

“I think so,” Ethan said.

“Go do your curtain call,” Tyler said. “I’ll warm up the Jeep.”

Ethan crossed the patch of grass between the parking lot and the steps.

Mark’s mother hugged him first, leaving a powdery imprint of her makeup on his shoulder. “You boys,” she said, pulling back to look between her son and Ethan. “You made it.”

“Barely,” Mark said.

“Barely counts,” Ethan echoed.

Mr. Bennett shook his hand with a grip that was firmer than their first meeting but still carried the faintest whiff of my son’s world, not mine.

Nana patted his arm. “You take care of my grandson,” she said, voice unexpectedly sharp for someone wrapped in a cardigan in May.

“I’ll try,” Ethan said.

When the adults drifted toward the car, searching for something in the trunk, Mark hung back.

“So,” he said.

“So,” Ethan echoed.

“This is the part where I’m supposed to say ‘have a great summer’ like we didn’t spend nine months practically on top of each other in that shoebox.”

“I hear that’s the custom,” Ethan said.

“I’m not going to,” Mark said. “Because that sounds like something you say to the guy you copy notes from in Psych, not the dude who helped you drag yourself home from the Annex at four in the morning.”

“Okay,” Ethan said.

“I will say this,” Mark went on. “I’m glad you’re coming back in the fall. Even if I’m not happy with you yet.”

“That’s enough,” Ethan said. And it was.

Mark nodded, once, a punctuation mark. “See you around, Harris.”

“See you around, Bennett.”

They didn’t hug. They didn’t shake hands. It would have felt wrong. They just stepped back, giving each other space that wasn’t empty.

Ethan walked back to the Jeep.

Tyler had the engine running, arm slung casually over the wheel, the windows already rolled down to coax some kind of breeze through the old interior. The radio was off, for once.

“All clear?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah,” Ethan said. He climbed in. “Let’s go.”

They pulled away from the lot, tires crunching over the gravel. As they turned onto the main campus road, the bell rang once—deep, low, echoing across the green like it was saying goodbye and good riddance all at once.

Ethan looked back only when they hit the curve by the chapel.

McClintock’s brick facade caught the sun; one window on the third floor flashed. The quarter on the sill gave off a brief, dull glint, then disappeared as they angled away.

“Leave it,” Ethan said, more to himself than to Tyler.

Tyler shifted into the next gear. “Already did,” he said.

The road out of town bent once, then straightened. The bell tower shrank in the side mirror until it became just another dark line against the trees. Past the last gas station, the last strip mall, the last hand-painted sign for boiled peanuts, the sky opened up a little.

The air through the open window felt wider. Not clean, not yet. But his.

Tyler drummed his fingers lightly on the steering wheel. “So,” he said. “Year two.”

“Year two,” Ethan said.

“Think we’ll survive it?”

“Barely,” Ethan said.

Tyler smiled. “Barely counts.”

The highway unspooled ahead of them, lane after lane of maybe. Ethan rested his head back against the seat, closed his eyes for a second, and let the hum of the engine and the rush of the air and the steady presence of the boy at the wheel be enough.

For the first time in a long time, it was.

Epilogue — Move-In Day

August Second Year.

The heat had sharpened, the sky hard blue. A new set of freshmen spilled across the quad, shoulders pink from orientation. Someone was already handing out rush flyers near the fountain.

Ethan parked behind the Delta Chi house, the tires crunching gravel in the same rhythm they had last fall. The porch looked new—fresh paint, cleaned columns, the ghosts sanded off. He laughed under his breath. Every house on campus had learned to look reborn by the start of term.

Tyler climbed out from the passenger side, stretching.

“We’re really doing this,” he said.

“Looks that way.”

They carried boxes up the side stairs to the second floor. The hall smelled faintly of Pine-Sol and old smoke, familiar in a way that didn’t sting anymore. Eli’s old room waited at the end, door open, sunlight falling in a perfect rectangle across the bare floor.

Ethan set the lamp on the desk, the framed photo of the creek beside it. Tyler dropped the last box and leaned against the wall.

“Can you believe it’s the same place?” he asked.

“It’s not,” Ethan said.

Tyler smiled. “Good.”

Outside, the bell rang for convocation, the sound bright and almost kind. Ethan looked out the window—students crossing the quad, the fountain catching light. On the sill sat a coin someone had left behind, edge dulled by time. He turned it once between his fingers, then let it fall back into place.

“Ready?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah. Coffee?”

“Always.”

They walked down the stairs and out into the heat. The door swung shut behind them, not a bang this time but a simple click.

From the window, sunlight stretched across the empty floor, catching the edge of the coin, flaring bright.

The same light, finally theirs.

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

Habit, maybe. Or superstition. The same Beck CD skipped in the same places when the Jeep hit certain seams in the road; he could almost feel them coming before the tires did. Somewhere around Rocky Mount the last trace of salt left the air. By the time he crossed into Virginia, the sky had flattened into that particular gray that always felt like it belonged to Westmore.

He topped the hill before the exit and saw the bell tower first, cutting the horizon. The campus spread out beneath it in familiar lines: quad, chapel, a smudge of Fraternity Row through the trees. It should have felt like coming back. Instead, it felt like walking into the last scene of a play he already knew the ending to.

Inside the gates, the roads were dusted yellow. Pollen clung to windshields and brick. Campus waited behind a veil of early light and spring grit, red buildings shining wet from last night’s rain.

Magnolia petals stuck to the sidewalks like damp paper. Trash cans overflowed with Styrofoam cups, their sides collapsing in on themselves. A banner between two lampposts drooped in the still air: GOODBYE SENIORS, the middle letters warped by water, the exclamation point half torn.

Fraternity Row looked professionally laundered. White columns scrubbed, hedges clipped with mean precision, front lawns picked clean of beer cans and cigarette butts. Banners for Senior Week had already gone up—giant, overly cheerful things with dates and slogans that tried too hard. The same Greek letters that once felt like gatekeepers now looked like decorations you could take down with a ladder and a free afternoon.

His eyes went to the end of the Row automatically, to the spot where Eli’s truck was always crooked in the gravel, tailgate scarred, old lacrosse sticker peeling on the bumper. The space was empty.

The silence felt earned.

He parked behind McClintock and sat there a moment with his hand on the key, listening to the engine tick itself down. Somewhere across the quad, a staticky version of “Closing Time” leaked from somebody’s radio. He killed the ignition and let the quiet expand around him.

Inside, the dorm smelled like lemon cleaner and hot pipes. Open doors exposed stripped beds and bare bulletin boards. Most were not staying for graduation. Fresh tape squares waited on some doors where new names would go in August; others had old name tags curling at the corners, pulled away and stuck back too many times.

Mark’s bed was already stripped, mattress bare except for a single folded towel in the middle. His side of the room looked wrong without the mess—no pile of laundry at the foot of the bed, no stack of empty Coke cans, no Rush shirts on the chair.

Ethan set his duffel on his own bed. The springs complained the familiar way. He unpacked slowly, not so much moving in as setting things down—books on the desk, cigarettes in the top drawer, the cheap halogen lamp with its crooked shade back in its usual place.

He stopped once, hand resting on the edge of Mark’s mattress. The absence felt louder than any argument would have.

He showered, put on a clean shirt that still smelled faintly like his mother’s detergent, and walked across the quad to Broadmoor.

Dr. Carroll’s office seemed smaller without the fortress of lab reports on every surface. There was space on the shelves now, gaps where journals had been returned to their proper volume order. Light slipped between the blinds in sharp white bars, striping her desk, her hands, the manila folder with his name on it.

She signed his grade sheet without ceremony. “You came through it intact,” she said.

“Barely.”

“Barely counts.” She uncapped and recapped her pen like a period. “The hard part isn’t leaving. It’s not becoming what they told you to be once you go.”

He didn’t answer right away. She looked up, and the air shifted. She had the kind of gaze that made excuses die before they reached your mouth.

“You know what you are now, don’t you?” she asked.

He nodded. The word itself stayed in his chest, but the nod felt like saying it out loud.

“Good,” she said. “Don’t apologize for it. Not here. Not when you leave. Especially not when you leave. It’ll save you years.”

It landed with more weight than any exam grade.

Outside, magnolia blossoms drooped under their own size, edges already browning. He stood under one, tucked between the branches and the building’s shadow, and tried to picture his life beyond this place. The curve of it was still more feeling than outline, but for the first time the blank space didn’t scare him.

He wanted that blank space to stay his.

The next morning Tyler ran the perimeter road before sunrise.

Mist clung low to the track, wrapping the far turn in a gauzy blur that burned off slowly under the floodlights. His breath came out in small, white ghosts. Running early made the day feel possible. It was the only time nothing and no one was asking anything of him.

Halfway through his second lap he noticed a figure near the bleachers, hands in his pockets, shoulders hunched against nothing in particular. Ethan. He wasn’t watching the runners. He was staring at the field—the empty rectangle where games had been played, parties thrown, tents set up, and where, in a week, rows of chairs would mark off a final ritual.

Tyler slowed coming off the turn. The gravel under the old cinder layer popped beneath his shoes. He could have pretended he hadn’t seen him. It would have been easy enough: head down, pick up pace, let the fog do the work.

Ethan turned as if he’d felt something change. Their eyes met over the low chain-link fence.

Tyler lifted his chin, the smallest acknowledgment.

Ethan nodded back. No wave, no call over the hum of the lights.

It was nothing. It was everything.

Tyler lengthened his stride again. He didn’t know exactly what had broken between Eli and Ethan over Spring Break, but he knew the shape of the cracks now: in the way Ethan held his shoulders, in the way Mark’s voice changed when he said his brother’s name, in the fact that Ethan was out here at dawn, staring at a field instead of sleeping.

Whatever came next would be quieter, less fueled by denial.

Quiet, he could work with.

Senior Week didn’t feel particularly senior.

The college had printed schedules with logos and titles—Senior Toast, Honors Convocation, President’s Reception—but it all blended into one long, mismatched reel. One day bled into the next in a way that felt more like August than May—everyone slightly off balance, looking for where they belonged without admitting that’s what they were doing.

By afternoon there were cookouts: paper plates, borrowed grills, yellow beer in plastic cups. By evening the houses filled; by night the Annex took whoever was still vertical.

Ethan found himself at the house most nights, not because he wanted to celebrate anything, but because it felt worse to sit alone in a half-empty dorm.

Jason moved through it all with a kind of tired ease, shaking hands with alumni, letting mothers hug him, taking photos with freshmen he barely knew. Clay barked at nobody in particular about cooler placement and trash bags, trying to make his clipboard matter a little longer before he finally graduated and had to pass it on. Connor and Teddy turned everything into a bit, laughing too loud, trying to stretch their roles as comic relief into some kind of armor.

Eli drifted like weather: appearing on the porch with a cigarette, vanishing into a circle of alumni, reappearing later at the keg. If you didn’t know anything else, he looked fine. Better than fine. Relaxed. He’d landed a job in New York. He slipped talk of it into conversations without sounding like he was bragging. He made Catherine laugh at the right times.

The only time Ethan saw the mask slip was at the Annex.

It was late; the party had bleached itself out. Most of the bodies had moved back toward campus or deeper into the yard, but Ethan had stayed behind.

Eli stood at the kitchen sink, hands braced on the edges, head tipped down. The harsh overhead light picked out the lines at the corners of his mouth that weren’t there in August.

For a moment, he was unguarded. Not tragic, not dramatic. Just… tired. The kind of tired that comes from holding something shut for too long.

Ethan stayed in the doorway, watching. He didn’t say anything.

Eli turned on the tap, splashed water on his face, rolled his shoulders like someone shaking off a hit. When he straightened and turned, his expression had reset: mouth curved, eyes bright, the familiar version of himself back in place.

“Place still standing?” he said, as if nothing inside him had shifted at all.

“Barely,” Ethan answered.

“Barely counts,” Eli said, without knowing he was quoting someone else.

Mark came back to McClintock on Wednesday.

Ethan heard him before he saw him: the stumble of his boots down the hall, the familiar cadence of his laugh, the door creaking open like every other time that year. For a second, motion and memory blended and it felt like September again.

Then Mark stepped in, and it wasn’t September.

He looked the same on the surface—sun-bleached hair, worn ball cap, T-shirt half tucked in, keys hooked around two fingers. But the easy looseness was gone around the edges. His eyes flicked automatically to Ethan’s side of the room, then away, like he didn’t trust himself to look for too long.

“Hey,” he said.

“Hey.”

He tossed his keys onto the desk, missed, let them bounce off the floor and lie there. “Parents are staying at that crappy motel off the highway,” he said. “The one with the ‘Color TV’ sign like that’s still a selling point.”

Ethan huffed a small laugh. “Classy.”

“Yeah.” Mark dropped onto his bed, the bare mattress thunking against the frame. “They brought my grandmother. She asked if I had any nice girls coming to graduation.”

“What’d you tell her?”

“That I go to Westmore,” Mark said. “Nice girls are shipped in on weekends only.”

Ethan smiled despite himself. They sat in the thin truce of shared jokes for a moment.

Mark leaned over, pulled a Coke-can from the thrash, and set it on the windowsill like it belonged there. He lit a cigarette, exhaled toward the screen.

“You know he told me,” he said finally. “Down at the coast.”

The air changed.

Ethan stared at the pattern in the floor tile between their beds. “Yeah,” he said. “He said he might.”

“He didn’t ‘might.’ He did.” Mark tapped ash into the can. “Sat there on the deck like we were swapping fishing stories.”

“I didn’t ask him to.”

“I know.” Mark’s tone wasn’t accusing on that point, and somehow that made it worse. “He’s still my brother, you know. That doesn’t go away because he decided to… expand his resume.”

Ethan let out a breath. “I never wanted to take anything from you.”

“Intent’s not the problem,” Mark said. He turned his head finally, looking at him full on. There was anger there, sure, but underneath it something more complicated: hurt, confusion, a kind of grief. “My whole life, he was the guy I was supposed to be someday. The map. And now I’m supposed to make sense of the fact that the map left out an entire other continent.”

He laughed once, without humor. “And you’re standing there holding the passport.”

“It wasn’t about you,” Ethan said, quiet, because anything louder would have felt like an argument.

“You think I don’t know that?” Mark snapped, then checked himself. “I know it wasn’t about me. That’s half of why I’m pissed. The other half is—” He broke off, jaw tensing. “I don’t even know what the other half is.”

They sat in it.

“He said it was a mistake,” Mark added after a beat. “You buy that?”

Ethan thought of Eli’s hand at the base of his neck, of the Underground farmhouse, of the way Eli had looked afterward, wrecked in a way that had nothing to do with what they’d done and everything to do with what he couldn’t admit. He thought of Tyler’s quiet steadiness on the dock, the weight in Jason’s voice whenever he said be careful what you let this place take from you.

“No,” Ethan said. “I think he was scared. I think calling it a mistake was easier.”

Mark stared at him for a long moment. “You in love with him?”

Ethan swallowed. “I was.”

“And now?”

“Now,” Ethan said, “I’m trying to stop wanting to fix a thing that doesn’t want to be fixed.”

Mark looked away first. “He loved you,” he said, almost under his breath. “He doesn’t have the language for it, but he did. Does. That’s part of the problem.”

Ethan pushed his hands into his pockets so Mark wouldn’t see them shake. “It’s not your job to carry that for him,” he said. “Or for me.”

“Doesn’t matter,” Mark muttered. “I’m the little brother. That’s the whole gig.”

He ground the cigarette out in the can, the metal pinging. “I don’t hate you,” he said. “I want to. Would be simpler. But I don’t.”

Ethan nodded. “I know.”

“I just don’t know what we are now,” Mark went on. “You and me. Me and him. It’s not what it was in August. That’s gone.”

“Yeah,” Ethan said. “It is.”

They sat with that, each word settling like dust on furniture that wouldn’t be there next week.

“I’m not ready to be okay about any of this,” Mark said finally. “So don’t try to fix it for me. Don’t… use that quiet, reasonable voice on me. Not now.”

“I’m not,” Ethan said. “I don’t know how to fix it either.”

“Good,” Mark said, but his voice had lost some of its hard edge. He pushed off the bed. “I’m heading back to the motel. Mom wants one last ‘family dinner’ where Dad complains about tuition and Nana compliments the biscuits until the server takes it as a personal attack.”

He moved toward the door, then paused with his hand on the knob. “I don’t think this is it for us,” he said without turning. “You and me. I just… need some distance before I figure out how to look at you without seeing him.”

Ethan’s throat tightened. “Take what you need.”

Mark nodded once, almost imperceptibly, and left.

The room felt wrong after that—too big on one side and too small on the other.

It was late when the knock came.

The houses on the Row had hit that point in the night where noise becomes a kind of weather: laughter, music, some guy on the porch yelling the same story for the third time. It seeped across the quad and through the thin dorm windows as a single muffled roar.

Ethan lay on his back, staring at the ceiling. He hadn’t turned the overhead light on. The lamplight carved the room into soft wedges of gold and shadow, highlighting boxes, an open suitcase, the bare geometry of Mark’s empty bed.

The knock was soft, almost an afterthought.

“Yeah?” he said.

“It’s me.” Tyler’s voice through the door.

“Come in.”

Tyler slipped inside and closed the door behind him with care, as if noise itself were a thing they should respect. He looked tired in the particular way that came from being the one everyone leaned on all week.

“You okay?” he asked.

“Define okay.”

“That’s a no, then.”

Tyler moved to the chair at Mark’s desk but didn’t sit. He turned it around and dropped into it backward, arms folded across the back, chin resting on his forearms. It was a posture Ethan had seen him use at the Annex, in the basement, watching the room. Only now the room was just him.

“You talked to Mark,” Tyler said.

“Yeah.”

“How bad?”

Ethan let out a breath that felt like it had been sitting there all day. “He said he doesn’t hate me. He just doesn’t know how to look at me right now.”

Tyler nodded. “That sounds about right.”

“He kept talking about maps,” Ethan said. “How Eli was his map, his model. And now he feels like there’s this whole other thing he didn’t know about. And I’m standing there like proof.”

“Proof isn’t the enemy,” Tyler said. “It’s just uncomfortable.”

“He asked if I was in love with Eli.”

“What’d you say?”

“That I was,” Ethan said. “Past tense.”

“And now?” Tyler asked.

“Now I feel stupid,” Ethan said. “And relieved. And like I’ve somehow blown up two people’s lives by existing.”

Tyler studied him for a moment. “Do you really think you did that? Blew-up-two-lives single-handed?”

Ethan stared at the scuffed place on the floor where Mark’s desk chair had always rocked. “Feels like it.”

“Feeling,” Tyler said, “is not the same as fact.”

“You and Dr. Carroll ought to start a club,” Ethan said.

“We’d make you president,” Tyler answered.

The corner of Ethan’s mouth twitched. It didn’t quite become a smile, but it was proof he still knew how.

“I thought about transferring,” he said, after a moment. “Just… disappearing. Starting somewhere I’m not already a story.”

Tyler didn’t flinch. “Have you ever run from anything in your life before this?”

“I don’t know. Maybe I should have.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

Ethan rolled onto his side, facing him. “No. I haven’t.”

“So why start now,” Tyler said, “right when you’ve finally stopped lying to yourself?”

The words sank in.

“I don’t know how to be here like this,” Ethan admitted. “With Mark knowing something. With Eli still… orbiting. With you and me being whatever we are. I don’t know how we fit.”

Tyler shifted from the chair to the edge of the bed, close enough that their knees touched. “We don’t have to figure out the whole map tonight,” he said. “Just the next turn.”

“What’s the next turn?”

“Question one,” Tyler said, ticking it off on his fingers. “Do you want to be done with Eli?”

“Yes.”

“Question two: do you want… this?” He gestured, not broadly, but with a small, open-palmed gesture between them. “Me. Us.”

Ethan’s chest felt tight, but not in the bad way. “Yeah. I do.”

“Then that’s the next turn,” Tyler said. “We keep going. Here. Next year. We do it on our terms.”

“Our terms,” Ethan repeated. “Which are what, exactly?”

“Honest, quiet, not suicidal,” Tyler said. “You don’t have to be out to the world. You don’t have to put a rainbow sticker on the Jeep. You just have to stop pretending with yourself. And with me.”

“I don’t want to hide,” Ethan said. The words surprised him by how easily they came.

Tyler’s breath left him in a slow exhale he might not have realized he’d been holding. “Okay,” he said. “Then we won’t. Not from each other.”

“What about everyone else?” Ethan asked.

“We let them catch up or not,” Tyler said. “That part’s on them.”

The room was quiet except for the radiator and the distant thump of someone’s stereo. Rain started up again, a light patter against the window.

“You’re the only part of this place that makes sense,” Ethan said, before he could overthink saying it.

Tyler blinked. Then, slowly, he smiled. “Good,” he said. “Then don’t let Eli’s mess or Mark’s shock push you out. They’re allowed to feel whatever they feel. You’re allowed to stay anyway.”

Ethan looked at him, really looked at him—at the shadows under his eyes from too many late nights, at the small scar near his hairline from some forgotten childhood collision, at the calm that didn’t feel like a pose.

“Can you…” Ethan started, then stopped. “Will you stay? Tonight?”

Tyler didn’t joke. Didn’t ask with his eyebrows if Ethan was sure. He just nodded.

“Yeah,” he said. “I’ll stay.”

He toed off his shoes and eased back onto the mattress. It was a narrow bed; they had to negotiate space with care. They lay side by side at first, both staring up at the faint cracks in the paint that made their own map.

After a few seconds, Ethan rolled onto his side, turning toward him. Tyler mirrored the movement. The gap between them shrank.

“Is this okay?” Tyler asked.

Instead of answering out loud, Ethan leaned in and kissed him.

It wasn’t a question; it wasn’t an apology. It was an answer to something that had been humming under his skin since that night on the porch during Hell Week, since the Underground farmhouse, since that quiet joint on the back steps.

Tyler’s hand came up, fingers resting lightly at the base of Ethan’s neck, thumb brushing the line of his jaw. He didn’t pull him closer; he just held him there, as if to say you’re allowed to stay.

The kiss stayed slow. No rush, no grab. When Ethan deepened it, Tyler followed his lead, not trying to steer.

At some point, Ethan’s hand found the hem of Tyler’s sweatshirt, the soft cotton rising under his fingers. Tyler sat up just enough to let him tug it over his head. The shirt landed somewhere on the floor, forgotten. Underneath, Tyler was warm, his skin smelling faintly of chlorine and soap and something that was just him.

Ethan’s own T-shirt joined it a moment later.

They lay back down, bare shoulders touching this time, the contact electric in a way that didn’t scare him. Tyler’s fingers traced a slow line from his shoulder down to his elbow, like he was memorizing the route.

“You sure?” Tyler murmured.

“Yeah,” Ethan said. “I’m sure.”

The world narrowed in a good way.

They kept it simple. Kissing, mostly. Hands exploring—hesitant at first, gaining confidence as they read each other’s breaths, the way they tensed and softened. Jeans stayed on longer than they needed to. When buttons eventually popped and zippers edged down, it happened without fanfare, like the natural next step in a conversation that had been going on all year.

At some point they ended up pressed closer, legs tangled, hips aligned. Ethan felt Tyler’s breath stutter against his mouth and pulled back enough to see his face, to make sure.

Tyler’s eyes were open, steady. “Still okay,” he said.

They moved together, uncoordinated for a second, then falling into a rhythm that felt less like something they were doing and more like something that was finally being allowed to happen. Heat built slowly, not like a match flaring but like coals catching.

Ethan’s world shrank to small things: the warmth of Tyler’s palm at his back, the press of their foreheads, the soft sound Tyler made when Ethan slid a hand along his side, the way their breaths caught at the same time and then refused to sync up again.

When it crested, it wasn’t loud. There were no declarations, no shouted names. Just a sharp inhale, a gasp, fingers clutching at shoulders, everything going white around the edges for a few seconds, then fading back in with the pulse of their breathing.

After, they lay sprawled on the narrow bed, half tangled, skin damp, hearts still drumming.

“For the record,” Tyler said quietly, once his lungs remembered what to do, “still not running?”

Ethan let out a breath that felt like it came from somewhere below his ribs. “No,” he said. “Not running.”

Tyler shifted onto his back, pulling Ethan with him until his head rested on Tyler’s chest. His skin was warm; his heartbeat was steady. Ethan could hear it under his ear, a metronome that finally matched something in him.

“You okay?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah,” Ethan said. The answer surprised him by how true it felt. “I am.”

“Good.” Tyler dropped a light, almost absent-minded kiss onto his hair. “Me too.”

The rain kept up its thin percussion at the window. Somewhere down the hall, a door closed, footsteps passed, water ran in a pipe. The world outside hadn’t changed. Inside the small rectangle of mattress and blanket, everything had.

They didn’t talk anymore. They didn’t need to.

Sleep crept in quietly. Ethan let it, his last conscious thought a simple one: that for the first time since stepping onto campus in August, he didn’t feel like he was performing being himself.

Morning came soft.

Light pressed around the edges of the blinds, washing the room in a gray that hadn’t decided yet what kind of day it would be. The rain had moved on. The air through the cracked window was cool and clean, carrying the faint smell of cut grass from somewhere down on the quad.

Ethan woke slowly, aware first of warmth, then of weight—Tyler’s arm draped across his stomach, the solid line of his body along his back. He lay still for a moment, listening.

Tyler’s breathing was slow, close to sleep. The radiator had gone quiet. A car door slammed outside; someone laughed; a bell rang for a class no one would attend.

He rolled carefully onto his back. Tyler blinked awake beside him, hair smashed on one side, eyes squinting against the light.

“Hey,” Tyler said, voice rough with sleep.

“Hey.”

“You look different,” Tyler said.

“Bad different?”

“Less… haunted.” Tyler yawned, stretching his arms over his head. The motion made a small crack in his shoulder. “How do you feel?”

Ethan thought about it. “Like I’m finally done pretending yesterday didn’t happen,” he said. “And not just last night. All of it. Eli. Mark. The whole year.”

Tyler nodded slowly. “That’s a lot to be done pretending about.”

“Yeah.”

“But you’re still here,” Tyler said. “That counts for something.”

“Barely,” Ethan said without thinking, then caught himself. “Barely counts.”

“Now you’re quoting Dr. Carroll,” Tyler said. “Impressive.”

They lay there a few minutes more, between sleep and the day, between what had been and what would come next.

“What about next year?” Ethan asked the ceiling. “You still want to be here?”

“With you?” Tyler asked.

Ethan turned his head. “Yeah. With me.”

“Yeah,” Tyler said simply. “I do.”

The panic that had been living under Ethan’s sternum for months didn’t vanish. But it had less room.

He sat up, the sheet sliding to his waist. The room looked different in the morning light, and not because of the boxes. Mark’s bare mattress, the open closet, the stack of textbooks by the door—they were still there. But they were background now, not the whole frame.

He stood, pulled on his jeans, found his T-shirt near the foot of the bed. Tyler watched him with an ease that said nothing had shattered overnight. No masks being refastened. No distance being reasserted.

“Coffee?” Ethan asked.

“Always.”

They stepped into the hallway together. No one was there. Just the long run of doors, some closed, some open to glimpses of other half-packed rooms. The building hummed around them, old and familiar.

They walked toward the common room side by side, shoulders brushing once, twice, a contact that felt as natural as avoiding it had once been.

The day would bring whatever it brought—papers to pick up, forms to sign, parties to endure, a graduation schedule taped up in the lobby.

For now, there was just this: a hallway, two mugs waiting by the machine, and the quiet fact that Ethan had decided to stay.

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The drive down took ten hours, though Ethan stopped counting somewhere south of Petersburg.

Pine trees blurred into billboards — SOUTH OF THE BORDER, “YOU NEVER SAUSAGE A PLACE!” — until the air turned briny and flat. The wind through the cracked window smelled like home. Even the paper mill’s sour sweetness felt welcoming to Ethan.

He pulled into the steel-slag driveway near dusk and parked in his old spot. The house looked the same: cypress siding bleached silver, porch fan clicking above wicker chairs, a spaniel asleep in the doorway like she had been waiting all year. Inside, the TV was tuned to Channel 5 and his dad was listening to the Charleston news. Ethan remembered when this anchor first started; now he was the “veteran.” Even though it was April, they were already talking about hurricane season.

“Just waiting for Walter Cronkite to come on!” his dad joked when he walked into the room, cocktail in hand.

It was an old one, but Ethan laughed anyway and sat down just in time for Dan Rather and the CBS Evening News.

By nightfall headlights cut across the marsh road. Jason’s old Volvo station wagon wheezed to a stop, throwing dust over the azaleas. Tyler climbed out first, shoulders loose, eyes rimmed red from the drive. Eli and Mark followed, half-laughing as they unloaded their bags from Eli’s car.

“Welcome to the beach, boys — fun, sun, and surf!” Ethan called out as he went to help them with their stuff.

Ethan’s mother greeted them with the same relentless warmth she used on Christmas guests. His father shook hands once and vanished toward the dock with the dogs. Dinner came fast — shrimp, cold beer, the tang of his mother’s cocktail sauce. Conversation rose and fell like the tide: Jason’s jokes, Tyler’s quiet laughter, Mark’s stories from home that no one corrected.

Afterward they moved to the porch, the night loud with frogs and the hum of the marsh, broken only by the occasional call of a bobwhite or whip-poor-will. The lamppost at the end of the steps threw a soft circle of light, catching the damp sheen on Eli’s arms. Even in early April, the humidity was thick.

“Your parents ever sell this place?” Jason asked.

“Not unless the creek dries up or my dad can’t fish anymore,” Ethan said.

“Then I guess you’re safe,” Tyler murmured.

The talk drifted to jobs, cities, the idea of futures that still felt hypothetical. Jason had interviews in Richmond; Tyler was planning to train with the NOVA contingent of the swim team over summer; Mark hadn’t decided on anything. Eli leaned against the railing, profile caught in the porch light.

“I start in August,” he said. “Bank on Madison Avenue. Catherine’s already apartment hunting.”

“New York,” Jason said, half-teasing. “You’ll hate the cold.”

“Maybe that’s the point.”

Ethan and Jason exchanged glances but remained silent. The sound of water under the dock filled the space for them.

“I’m going in for another beer — anyone need anything?” said Tyler, finally breaking the spell.

He returned with another round for each of them and finally sparked the joint he’d been waiting for since arriving. They passed it around and discussed their plans for the following day.

“Boat day!” they all chanted. Ethan finally relented. “I kinda figured that’s what you guys would say. We can use the jon boat and stick to the creeks, or we can take the Grady White my dad keeps at the marina in town. We’ll head up the river toward Bucksport and Conway.”

They talked for another hour or so, then called it a night.

Later, after the house went quiet, a sleepless Eli found Mark sitting on the dock with a beer balanced between his knees. The moon hung low over the creek; the tide had turned. Eli hesitated, then sat beside him.

“You ever think about how fast this all went?” he asked.

Mark smiled without looking up. “You sound like Mom.”

“I mean it. One minute I’m dragging you to high-school practice, next thing you’re a college kid with opinions.”

Mark laughed softly. “You still think I’m twelve.”

“No,” Eli said. He took a long drink, stared at the bottle’s reflection. “That’s the problem.”

Mark waited. The night hummed.

“I need to tell you something before it gets to you from somewhere else.”

Mark’s shoulders stiffened. “Okay.”

Eli exhaled smoke through his nose, watching it drift toward the water. “It’s about Ethan. Me and him.”

The words hung there, fragile as glass.

Mark blinked. “You and — what?”

“Something happened. It’s over. But I couldn’t keep sitting at the same table pretending.”

Mark’s voice cracked. “You’re joking, right?”

“I’m not.”

“Are you gay?”

He tipped the bottle, letting a trickle fall into the creek. “I don’t know. You don’t have to understand it. I just couldn’t lie to you anymore.”

“What about Ethan? Is he — ”

“You’ll have to ask him, Mark. He’s your roommate.”

Mark stood, breath shaking. “You’re unbelievable. What about Catherine and NYC? Did Ethan know about these plans before tonight?”

“I don’t know.”

“I can’t believe this — my brother and my best friend? Does anyone else know? Have you been with anyone else at Westmore?” His head was spinning.

He walked inside without slamming the door, which somehow hurt worse. Eli stayed where he was, staring at the thin ripples on the water until the beer went warm in his hand. The light above the dock burned steady as guilt.

Morning came slow, all glare and gulls. The tide was already pushing in by the time they loaded the coolers — sandwiches, beer, sunscreen that no one would reapply — into the car. Ethan’s father had left a note on the counter with the marina key: I called to let them know you guys were coming. She’s clean and full of fuel. Keep her in one piece.

They eased out from the dock just after nine. Winyah Bay was glass, and the deep-V hull cut through the water with hardly a splash. The ghosts of old cypress rice trunks leaned into their reflections, and every turn of the channel smelled like salt and mud and gasoline. Jason handled the lines while Ethan ran the boat. Eli and Mark sat side by side near the bow, both wearing sunglasses, neither saying much.

“Feels like August,” Jason said, lighting a cigarette. “Even the air’s sweating.”

Ethan checked the depth finder, trying to remember if he was far enough from the sandbar across from the Coast Guard Station, glad for the noise of the engine. “We’ll go under the second bridge and catch the Waccamaw River. Once we hit the ICW it’s straight up to Myrtle.”

They followed the river east until it opened into the Intracoastal. Shrimp boats rocked at their moorings, nets hanging like tired flags. The current shifted under them, darker water sliding beneath the hull as they turned north. “Hang on,” Ethan said as he throttled down enough to get the boat on a plane, the hum of the outboard settling into rhythm with the slap of waves.

Eli stretched out his legs. “This beats the subway already.”

“Everything beats the subway,” Mark said flatly.

Ethan pretended not to hear. He pointed toward the horizon. “Barefoot Landing’s about two hours. We’ll grab lunch, head back with the tide.”

They passed small marinas and houses perched on stilts, the smell of marsh giving way to suntan lotion and fried food as they drew closer to civilization. Ethan pointed out each old rice plantation as they passed: Hobcaw, Arcadia, Hagley, Litchfield, Wachesaw. He knew them from memory, had watched them, save Hobcaw, transform into gated communities.

By noon they were idling into the docks at Barefoot, tying up between a rental pontoon and a tour boat painted with cartoon dolphins. The air shimmered with heat and the chatter of tourists.

At lunch — burgers, beer, the first real crowd they’d seen in days — the mood lightened. Mark flirted with the waitress; Tyler and Ethan traded stories about disastrous high-school summer jobs. Even Jason started to relax. Only Eli stayed quiet, sunglasses hiding his eyes, fingers tracing condensation on his glass.

“Ready to head back?” Ethan asked when the plates were cleared.

Eli nodded. “I’m driving.”

They untied and pushed off, the tide running in their favor. Afternoon light turned the water copper, the air heavy with the promise of a storm somewhere inland. Ethan took the wheel for a while, steering by instinct through the familiar bends. Jason dozed. Tyler watched the horizon, one arm draped along the seatback, close enough that Ethan could feel the warmth of him even in the wind.

Eli sat near the bow, facing the channel ahead. He looked back once, met Ethan’s eyes for half a second, then turned away again. Nothing was said, but the distance between them felt measured, like the space between two boats running parallel wakes.

By the time they reached the marina again, the sun had gone red behind the pines. The tide was high enough that the dock floated level with the deck. They tied off in silence.

“Good trip,” Jason said, stretching. “We didn’t sink, no one lost a finger. That’s success in my book.”

They laughed, thin and tired, gnats already biting their legs.

Back at the house, Ethan’s mother called them to dinner, her voice carrying through the salt air like something safe and ordinary.

Ethan’s mind lingered on the dock a moment longer, thinking about the ripples fading behind the Grady’s hull. For a day it had almost felt like old times — friends, laughter, the illusion that nothing had changed. But even in the quiet he could feel it: the tide had turned, and everything was moving out.

Dinner was the same ritual as every night home: shrimp and grits, bread still warm from the oven, Ethan’s mother asking polite questions that no one quite answered. Jason told a story about getting lost outside Richmond; Mark filled the silence with too much iced tea. Tyler kept catching Ethan’s eye and grinning like he was trying to make him laugh.

Eli stayed quiet, working on his second beer. When Ethan’s mother asked about New York, he gave the kind of careful answers that sounded rehearsed: Yes, Catherine’s excited. Yes, the bank is solid. No, it’s not as glamorous as it sounds.

She told him he’d do fine; he smiled like he already knew that part.

After dinner they drifted back to the porch. The air was still heavy, the marsh humming with insects. The dock light threw a gold track across the creek. Jason started a card game, Tyler fetched another round, and for a while the evening settled into an easy rhythm of jokes and half-finished stories. The sound of the fan above them ticked like a metronome.

Ethan tried to ignore the tension between the Bennett brothers — Mark laughing a little too hard at Jason’s jokes, Eli pretending not to notice. Everyone felt it.

By midnight the house quieted again. Doors shut. Footsteps faded upstairs. Ethan stood at the sink rinsing glasses, the last of the ice melting down the drain. Through the window he could see Eli outside, standing at the edge of the dock, cigarette ember flaring against the dark.

He thought about going out there, then didn’t.

Rain came through before dawn — soft, steady, the kind that makes the world smell new. When Ethan woke, the sky was still gray, the fan moving warm air in slow circles. Tyler was already up, barefoot, making coffee in the kitchen.

“Everyone sleep?” he asked.

Ethan nodded. “Mostly.”

“We going out in the boat again today?”

“I don’t think so. Maybe just the beach today. We’ll head back tomorrow.”

Tyler smiled. “You’ll miss this.”

“I always do.”

One by one the others appeared: Jason hunting for Advil, Mark still half-asleep, Eli last of all, already dressed, hair damp from a quick shower. Breakfast was quiet — eggs, toast, the dogs pacing for scraps. Outside, the rain had cleared; the marsh shone silver under a low sun.

Eli poured another cup of coffee and leaned against the counter. “We still boating?”

“No,” Ethan said. “Just a beach day. We’ll stay close.”

Jason clapped his hands. “Perfect. No work, no schedule, no expectations.”

They all laughed, but Ethan caught Eli’s eyes flick toward him — brief, unreadable — and felt something start to uncoil in his chest.

By late morning the air had already turned thick again, the kind of warmth that made everything slow. Ethan’s mother packed sandwiches and towels while the rest of them loaded the golf cart — a mint-green, gas-powered 1950s Cushman with a canvas top edged in faded fringe. It was a family heirloom more than a vehicle, brought down from his grandparents’ summer place and fitted with a rack for chairs and an old cooler that rattled with every bump.

“Beach club’s less than a mile,” Ethan said, tossing the last towel into the back. “You’ll see why my parents will never give this thing up.”

The Cushman rattled down the sandy road, tassels fluttering like tiny flags in the salt air. It coughed once, backfired like a shotgun, and kept chugging through the tunnel of live oaks and salt-bitten palmettos, past houses built for another time. At the Beach Club gate Ethan gave his name, and the arm rose without a pause. The attendant just laughed at the next backfire.

“Charge it to account two-oh-two-one — Harris,” Ethan said at the cabana desk, and the man nodded without a word.

The beach spread out white and empty, the tide still low, the pool deck glittering beyond the dunes. They staked out a cabana and fell into easy habits — Tyler ordered drinks, Jason claimed the nearest lounger, and Mark and Eli disappeared toward the water with surfboards that hadn’t seen wax in years.

Ethan sat for a while, watching the brothers wade out together, neither quite meeting the other’s eye.

Tyler leaned over. “They’ve been weird since the other night,” he said quietly.

“Yeah,” Ethan answered. “Something’s off.”

After a few minutes he stood. “Let’s take a walk.”

They left the towels and coolers behind and headed north along the beach, the sand firm and cool near the waterline. Gulls wheeled overhead, their shadows flickering across the dunes. The only footprints ahead of them belonged to crabs.

“I can’t believe this is where you grew up,” Tyler said finally.

“No big deal. My parents moved here when they first developed the place. It didn’t look like this then.”

“Still beats the bowels of Northern Virginia.”

Ethan smiled but didn’t answer. Tyler changed the subject. “You think Eli and Mark are okay?”

“They’ll figure it out. They always do.”

They walked in silence for a while, the wind flattening their shirts against their backs. Past the last house the beach curved inward, the surf softening into the rush of the tide through the inlet.

Ethan pointed across the water. “That’s Hobcaw Barony. See that old shed? During the war they used it to winch anti-submarine nets in and out of the water.”

A rust-red shape broke the surface nearby. “And that’s the Boiler,” he said when he noticed Tyler looking at it. “Old steam engine. We fish for sheepshead there. Tough bastards — Dad used to say they’d bite your finger clean off.”

Tyler laughed. “I’ll take your word for it.”

Past the driftwood forest the coast curved to the right, and North Inlet opened before them, North Island hazy across the channel.

“This place gets to you,” Tyler said. “Everything looks the same, but it isn’t.”

Ethan nodded. “That’s the trick. You leave thinking you’ll come back to the same day.”

The sun caught the water just right, turning it white-gold. Without thinking, Tyler reached for his hand. Ethan didn’t pull away. They kept walking, hands brushing at first, then joined, the only movement in the wide, bright silence.

At the bend where the inlet met the sea, Tyler stopped. For a long moment they just stood there, the wind between them. Then he leaned in, a quick, certain kiss — barely more than salt and sunlight.

When they pulled back, Ethan smiled. “We should head back.”

“Yeah,” Tyler said, still grinning. “Before someone puts another round of drinks on your account again.”

They turned south, the cabana flag already a bright speck in the distance, the tide climbing after them.

By late afternoon the sun had gone soft, the kind of light that made the marsh look painted. They rattled back down the sandy road in the old Cushman, skin tight with salt and sunscreen, towels flapping like pennants from the back rack. The house appeared through the trees the same way it always had—half hidden, porch light already on, fan turning lazily above the steps.

Inside, the air-conditioning hit like a wave. Everyone peeled off toward showers, leaving a trail of sand and damp clothes. Ethan heard the pipes groan upstairs, the bathroom doors closing in sequence, the house settling into its evening rhythm.

His mother had left lemonade and a note on the counter—Dinner at seven. Shrimp again.—and a pie cooling beside it. Tyler was already barefoot on the porch with a beer, the newspaper folded beside him. Jason stretched out on the couch, half asleep, the dogs snoring at his feet.

Mark was nowhere to be seen; Ethan guessed he’d gone for a drive. Eli was upstairs. The sound of running water stopped, then started again.

Ethan poured a glass of lemonade, leaned on the counter, and watched the creek through the kitchen window. The tide was turning, pulling the day back out with it. For the first time since they’d arrived, the house felt too quiet—like something waiting to happen.

He set the glass down and went outside, meaning only to walk the dock before dinner. The boards were still warm under his feet, the air thick with the smell of salt and cut grass. Halfway down, he stopped. Eli stood at the end of the dock, barefoot, hair damp, cigarette in hand.

He turned when he heard the door open, but Ethan just waved, deciding not to join him.

That night, Ethan couldn’t sleep. The house felt too still, the kind of silence that follows something breaking. He heard a creak in the hallway and thought it was his father, but when the shadow moved it was Eli—barefoot, t-shirt, cigarette behind his ear.

“Can’t sleep,” Eli said.

“Neither can I.”

They stepped outside again. Clouds had rolled in; lightning flickered far offshore. The air smelled of rain and cigarettes.

“You know this is the last time,” Eli said.

“Yeah.”

“I wish I’d met you somewhere else.”

“You wouldn’t have liked me somewhere else.”

“You’re wrong about that.”

The kiss started small, a release more than a spark. When they moved to Ethan’s room, the floorboards whispered underfoot. The storm held off just long enough for the windows to fog with breath. It wasn’t hungry anymore; it was mercy.

After, Eli sat at the edge of the bed, head in his hands.

“I told him,” he said.

“Told who?”

“Mark.”

Ethan froze. “Why?”

“Because I couldn’t stand pretending he didn’t already know. Because I’m tired.”

He looked back, eyes rimmed red. “You should hate me for it.”

“I don’t,” Ethan said.

Outside, thunder rolled across the marsh.

Eli lay down beside him, arm draped over his chest. “I can’t keep being this person twice.”

“Then don’t.”

Neither spoke again.

By morning Eli was gone. Only a note remained on the nightstand: Thanks for the quiet.

The handwriting looked steady.

Fog wrapped the yard, soft as gauze. Tyler stood on the porch, coffee in hand, watching the tide.

“You’re up early,” Ethan said.

“Couldn’t sleep.”

They watched the fog thin into morning.

“He’s gone,” Ethan said.

“I know.”

Tyler handed him the mug, eyes gentle. “You okay?”

“Ask me tomorrow.”

From inside came Jason’s voice, calling for coffee filters, Mark answering short, flat.

The house woke itself piece by piece, unaware that something had already ended.

When they left that afternoon, the road shimmered with heat. The spaniel barked once from the porch, then settled back down in the shade.

By the time the highway shouldered them north, the marsh light was gone and the radio had turned to static.

Westmore waited ahead, still green with spring and humming with endings.

Further Reading

I keep a running collection of books that shaped this project on Bookshop.org.

Purchases there support independent bookstores—and help sustain this work.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

January arrived thin and colorless. The quad felt smaller when it was cold, sound swallowed by the air like it had distance to cross. Frost webbed the grass around the bell, and the paths were a patchwork of salt and damp brick that turned shoes white at the edges. McClintock’s radiators hissed like they were always mid-complaint. Windows glowed with desk lamps instead of porch lights.

First day back wasn’t a real day so much as a sequence of thuds and doors. Mark came back talking before his bag hit the floor, a stream of half stories from home that trailed into the kind of silence that means both of you know it wasn’t as fun as you’re pretending. That night at the house, Connor swore he’d quit drinking until spring. Teddy rolled his eyes and asked if spring counted as March or as the first day you could stand outside without a jacket. Marco declared a sabbatical from “all structured stupidity” and then immediately volunteered to help string extension cords for a house party that never materialized. Everyone was a resolution until the first syllabus landed with a slap.

Classes resumed like someone had paused them mid-breath and unpaused without apology. Dr. Carroll handed back lab schedules and announced, not unkindly, that “the world doesn’t slow down for rites of passage.” Westmore looked over what it had put the boys through and decided the proper response was homework.

Ethan slipped into routine easily, not because the work was small, but because it was mercifully simple. Read the chapter. Show up. Do the lab, wipe the bench until the Lysol smell outlived the class. He realized the grind didn’t feel like punishment anymore. “Taxing,” the brothers called it back in the fall; now it just felt like living.

Fraternity Row had a winter look: no porch smoke, no porch at all most nights. The Annex sat dark at the end of its rutted track, not dead exactly, just hibernating. January weekends were a TV glow and a half-emptied pizza box and someone insisting you really had to hear this Guster track because it was perfect for the mood. Mostly it was quiet. The quiet didn’t scare Ethan; it gave his head room to stop replaying the fall.

Eli moved like weather—there, gone, unchanged. Tyler was easier to find without trying: running in the mornings, breath white in the air, or in the pool, the steady rhythm of laps replacing words neither of them needed. They said hello like that was all they owed the moment. It was enough and not enough.

By February, even the loud ones learned how to whisper. The ice-rimmed nights forced people to sit closer on the couch, knees touching because there was nowhere else to put them. Someone said Greek Week like a dare and was ignored for two weeks, until flyers appeared with dates that made April sound like a rumor.

One morning the azaleas bloomed all at once, a chorus of pink around the brick. The magnolia leaves turned their waxy faces toward the sun. The bell sounded like it had been polished. Windows opened and stayed open.

By the first week in April, the campus had turned into a carnival of good intentions. The official schedule—posted on bulletin boards, stapled crookedly to trees—listed Philanthropy 5K, Pledge Olympics (yes, this week they were still pledges), Canned Food Drive, and a dozen other events that all somehow ended with someone grilling hot dogs. Every afternoon the quad filled with tents, banners, and the same handful of songs blaring from different speakers.

The whole thing felt like Hell Week’s mirror image—daylight where there had been darkness, cheering where there had been shouting. Same faces, same rules, different lighting. The pledges wore sunglasses instead of blindfolds now; the potential rushees—new ones already whispering about what was coming in the fall—moved through the crowds like they were auditioning for a part.

Jason ran logistics for the whole row, good-natured but half-removed, the weight of graduation visible in his face. “Enjoy it while you can,” he told Ethan. “You’ll blink and it’ll be your turn to wear the gown.”

By midweek the festival had a rhythm. Mornings started with breakfast of champions; afternoons loud then bleeding into late nights. The professors were good natured about it - no drinking in class and don’t don’t show up drunk - the only rules that seemed to be enforced that week.

Field Day turned the quad into a scene from an old brochure—guys in polos throwing Frisbees, girls cheering from picnic blankets, the air hazy with pollen and cheap beer. The Pie a Brother booth raised four hundred dollars in less than an hour, though most of it went to buy more whipped cream. Connor took the first hit to the face, shouting, “All for charity!” through foam.

That night Ethan helped Tyler set up the stage lights for Friday’s concert. They worked in easy silence, running cables and checking plugs, the hum of the generator filling the spaces where words used to fit.

“Remember when this place felt impossible?” Ethan asked.

Tyler didn’t look up. “Yeah. And now it’s just another Friday night.”

They both smiled, knowing it wasn’t true, but it was close enough.

Thursday brought the Greek Olympics: relay races, water-balloon fights, tug-of-war on the football field. Eli captained Delta Chi’s team—shirt damp, hair falling into his eyes, every motion easy and practiced. Catherine stood on the sidelines in sunglasses, clapping too loudly. When Delta Chi lost the final round to Sigma Epsilon, Eli laughed it off, throwing his arm around Clay and calling for another round. The mask fit so perfectly now that even the cracks looked intentional.

Ethan watched from the bleachers with Jason and Teddy, detached from the performance he’d once envied.

“You ever think about what comes after this?” he asked.

Jason grinned. “That’s the curse, Harris. We all think about it. Most never get there.”

Teddy tipped his face to the sun. “Then maybe you’re already ahead.”

By nightfall the lawns were wrecked—deflated inflatables, spilled beer mixing with wisteria, three stereos fighting for dominance. The rest of the campus decided to give up and join in.

At Delta Chi, the house glowed like an overexposed photograph—fairy lights in the hedges, porch crowded, bottles sweating on the railing. Ethan lingered at the edge, watching it all: the laughter, the flirting, the recycled small talk. He spotted Eli at the center, cigarette in hand, one arm around Catherine. The noise bent toward him automatically, like gravity. For the first time, Ethan didn’t feel pulled in. He just felt sorry for how heavy it must be to hold everyone’s attention all the time.

That night, the noise in the house finally died after two. Ethan couldn’t sleep. He sat on the front steps with a cigarette, watching the fog settle over the quad. Tyler appeared from the shadows, hoodie up, a cup of black coffee in hand.

“You ever think about how fast it goes?” Tyler asked, sitting beside him.

“What—college?”

“Everything. One week it’s Hell, next week it’s this.”

Ethan smiled faintly. “Guess that’s the trick. Survive long enough, and it turns into nostalgia.”

Tyler laughed softly. “Maybe. Or maybe it’s just spring making us think we learned something.”

They sat quietly, the kind of silence that didn’t need to prove anything. When Tyler left, he clapped a hand to Ethan’s shoulder — brief, grounding.

The cigarette burned to the filter before Ethan realized he hadn’t made a single wish on it.

Friday afternoon arrived clear and gold. Waverly, Kensington, St. Margaret’s—every women’s college within fifty miles—had sent their contingents, carpooling in sundresses and cowboy boots, crowding the quad like migrating birds. Vendors set up fryers and soda stands. Brothers hauled kegs and stacked coolers, pretending it was work.

By five o’clock, the sky was the color of old brass. A low hum rolled through campus—the sound of anticipation, of one more night before finals, before the year started ending. The stage lights flickered on. Someone tested a microphone.

Ethan walked the perimeter, stacking cups out of habit. Across the lawn, Tyler carried a coil of cable over one shoulder, sunlight catching the curve of his arm. Their eyes met—easy now, unspoken understanding between them. The crowd thickened, the generator kicked on, and the first bass line trembled through the grass.

He realized it wasn’t about redemption anymore.

It was just life again: loud, messy, fleeting.

By dusk the field was full. A stage ringed with string lights, plywood barricades, and a rumor—Widespread Panic. When the first chord hit, the lawn answered with a thunderous cheer. Floodlights swept the crowd in gold arcs. For a moment it didn’t feel like Westmore anymore; it felt like someplace freer, a place that could only exist for the length of a song.

Ethan and Tyler sat shoulder to shoulder on the back steps, watching the movement below. “You good?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah,” Ethan said, and meant it.

The band rolled into Ain’t Life Grand. The field surged. Brothers, sisters, alumni—everyone singing badly, arms around whoever was nearest. Jason and Clay laughed at the edge of the crowd; Connor and Teddy swayed in unison; Marco shouted lyrics that didn’t exist. No one was performing. They were just there.

Across the field, Ethan caught sight of Eli—white shirt, sleeves rolled, cigarette glowing. He wasn’t talking to anyone; just watching. For a heartbeat their eyes met. No warning this time, no secret to guard. Just recognition. Eli lifted his cup, a small, almost-toast, then turned back toward the light. The distance didn’t sting anymore. It just existed.

Tyler stood, offered his hand. “Come on.”

Ethan took it.

They pushed into the crowd, laughter and heat and rhythm closing around them. When the bodies pressed too tight to see, Tyler’s hand found his again—not hidden, not announced. Just there.

When the last chord rang out, the field erupted—cheers, whistles, the dull thud of empty cups. Floodlights flared and cut, leaving afterimages on every eyelid. They stayed until the noise thinned and the speakers went quiet.

They walked home through the littered quad, plastic cups and paper plates crunching underfoot. The bell tower loomed above them, haloed in fog from the generator lights. Mark’s voice echoed somewhere behind them, calling their names, but neither turned. The air smelled like beer and azalea and the last cool breath of spring.

Ethan looked up—at the dorm windows glowing warm, at the faint shimmer of the river beyond the trees, at the wide spread of stars above it all—and felt, for the first time since August, that the year had given him back something he hadn’t realized he’d lost.

Tyler bumped his shoulder gently. “Feels like the end of something,” he said.

Ethan smiled. “Maybe the beginning of the rest.”

Behind them, the bell rang once, late and low, echoing across the empty field.

For a moment, neither turned back. The sound just hung there—fading, familiar, like a promise that couldn’t last.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The marsh was gray in winter, and at high tide, flat as paper under the cold sun. Ethan had stopped counting how many days he’d been home. The momentum of the holiday made the first two weeks home pass in blur. Though he felt different, Ethan appreciated the traditions: he and his sister decorating the Christmas tree, the two of them still waking the whole house up to see if Santa had come. It was good to see the grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins, everyone wanting to know what school was like.

Now that the decorations were put away, the annual New Year trip to their place at Kiawah Island complete, is mother started back to asking if he was eating, if he was seeing anyone, had he chosen a major. His father, unable to sit still retreated to the National Forest with his dogs, and the silence in between filled the house like fog.

The break was supposed to feel like a reset. Instead it felt like someone had hit pause.

He was halfway through a lukewarm cup of Christmas Blend coffee (the only time of the year he enjoyed it) when the kitchen phone rang. He let it ring twice before answering. His family had a “secret ring” to signal whether or not to answer. Two back to back meant a stranger. Some excitement, Ethan thought as he picked up the receiver.

“You alive?” Tyler’s voice, low and steady.

“Barely.”

“Good enough. A few of us are heading back early. House’ll be quiet—heat barely works, but it beats another week with the fam.”

“Who’s going?” Ethan asked, already feeling the pull.

“Me, Jason… maybe Eli. There’ll probably be some other guys from our class too.” He hesitated, then added, “You should come.”

“You sure that’s allowed?”

“Allowed?” Tyler’s laugh was soft. “We survived Hell Week. I think we can handle early check-in.”

The line went quiet except for the faint hum of static.

“Alright,” Ethan said finally. “I’ll pack.”

He left before dawn the next day.

The road north was empty, the sky a pale watercolor of blue and frost. The Jeep’s heater barely worked, and the only sound was the rattle of loose coins in the cup holder and the same Beck CD that skipped every time he hit a bump.

By the time he crossed into Virginia, the sun had flattened into a dull disc. He’d smoked two more cigarettes and drained the last of his coffee before Westmore came into view—red brick, white trim, and that familiar ache between belonging and exile.

The campus was nearly deserted.

The quad stretched silent under a dusting of snow, only a few footprints marking paths between dorms. The Delta Chi house stood at the end of the row, porch lights off, the lawn brittle with frost. Ethan parked beside a gray Volvo he recognized as Jason’s and a beat-up Honda with Tyler’s swim team sticker fading on the bumper.

Inside, the air was colder than outside.

Tyler met him at the door in a sweatshirt and socks, holding a mug of instant coffee.

“You made it,” he said simply.

“Barely.”

“Same.”

Jason appeared from the kitchen, hair damp, holding a half-empty bottle of Rolling Rock.

“Welcome back to the asylum,” he said. “You look tan. That’ll fade.”

They laughed, and the house felt warmer for it.

For two days, the three of them fell into an easy rhythm.

They took turns making coffee, played half-hearted pool games, and aired out the house that still smelled faintly of sweat and beer. Jason put on an old Widespread Panic CD that seemed to run on a loop. By night, they sat by the fire with cheap beer and old stories. The quiet was companionable, unforced.

On the second night, Tyler mentioned it casually while rolling a joint at the kitchen table.

“There’s something happening in town tomorrow. A get-together. Off-campus house — couple of university kids host it every month.”

“A party?” Ethan asked.

“Sort of,” Tyler said. “More like a gathering of like-minded people.”

“Do what?”

“You’ll see.”

Jason looked up from his beer.

“He means the Underground,” he said. “They’ve been around for years. Old farmhouse near the river. Mostly university students and a few locals, but some of our guys drift in.”

He caught Ethan’s uncertain look.

“It’s not a secret cult or anything,” Jason added, smirking. “Just people who got tired of watching their backs.”

Eli arrived the next afternoon — hair longer, tan deepened by the Carolina sun, still wearing the same jacket that smelled faintly of salt and smoke. He tossed his duffel by the stairs like he’d never left.

“Couldn’t take another day of my mom’s questions,” he said, smirking. “So what’s this I hear about a reunion?”

Jason raised his beer. “You’re just in time for the field trip.”

Eli grinned. “Figures. Leave it to Delta Chi to turn a secret society into a social hour.”

He looked good, maybe too good — refreshed, newly confident. He’d already lined up interviews in Atlanta and Richmond, the way older brothers did when they were half-gone from campus but still walked its halls like ghosts. Catherine had sent him a Christmas card, he said, one with an embossed crest from her father’s law firm. “Her parents think I’m house-broken now,” he joked.

Ethan smiled politely but felt the distance like a wall. The last night he spent in Eli’s room had become a closed book no one mentioned. Eli was planning his future. Ethan was still deciding if he had one.

They drove into town just after dark — Jason at the wheel, Tyler riding shotgun, Ethan and Eli in the back. The heater only half-worked, and the windows fogged easily, turning the headlights outside into a watercolor blur. The house sat at the end of a narrow street, porch sagging under leftover Christmas lights. Someone had tied a single balloon around the mailbox like a flag half-hidden in plain sight.

Inside, the air was thick with warmth and the faint smell of patchouli and clove cigarettes. Music drifted from the stereo—Mazzy Star fading into The Sundays—and the floor creaked under too many boots.

Ethan froze a little in the doorway. The room was full but not loud, alive in a way that didn’t need volume. He expected glitter, theatrics, some exaggerated version of what people whispered about in dorm rooms. Instead he saw jeans, wool sweaters, thrift-store coats. A girl in a black beanie arguing about a film class. A guy in corduroys leaning against the doorframe, laughing with another who wore a floral scarf and combat boots. Two men slow-dancing near the kitchen doorway, unbothered by the crowd.

It wasn’t spectacle. It was just living.

What struck him most was the ease. No one scanned the room for permission to exist. The weight he’d grown used to—the constant measuring of posture, tone, and distance—didn’t seem to apply here.

Jason moved easily among them, greeting people with a kind of quiet familiarity. Tyler slipped into conversation with someone from the university, their laughter low, unforced. Eli hung back at first, hands in his jacket pockets, eyes alert. It was strange to see him off balance—his confidence had always come from control, from knowing exactly what role to play. Here, no one needed his performance.

Ethan accepted a mug of mulled wine from a woman wearing a faded “ACT UP” shirt under an open cardigan. She smiled. “You’re one of Jason’s Westmore boys, right? Don’t worry, no one’s keeping score here.”

He smiled back, unsure what she meant but comforted by the tone.

Later, standing near the record player, he found himself talking to a student from the University—soft-spoken, lanky, wearing wire-rim glasses and a Henley that looked stolen from someone older. They talked about music, about being from small towns that demanded straight lines. The guy admitted he played soccer and didn’t come out until his junior year. “Everyone assumes gay means one thing,” he said. “Turns out it means whatever you wake up as that day.”

Ethan laughed quietly. “That would blow a few minds at Westmore.”

“Good,” the guy said. “They could use the exercise.”

When the song changed, the two men who’d been dancing near the kitchen switched partners. One of them winked at Ethan as he passed, not flirtatious—just friendly, like an invitation to breathe.

Across the room, Eli had found his rhythm again, trading jokes with a grad student in a faded UVA hoodie. Tyler leaned in the doorway watching, half-smile tugging at his mouth. For once, none of it felt like a competition.

Ethan realized that he’d never been in a room where he didn’t know who he was supposed to be. It was disorienting, and freeing.

Jason drifted over, handing him another drink.

“You’re seeing it, huh?”

Ethan nodded. “I didn’t know it could look like this.”

“That’s the point,” Jason said. “Nobody here did either. Until they saw it.”

Outside, the cold air cut clean after the heat inside. Snow had started again, light and slow. Jason stood by the railing, cigarette ember glowing against the dark.

“So this is the big secret,” Ethan said.

“Pretty underwhelming, huh?”

“Not really.” Ethan leaned beside him. “They look… happy.”

“They are. At least for a few hours. We build what we can.”

Jason exhaled smoke through his nose, watching it dissolve.

“How did you get Eli to come tonight?”

Jason’s mouth twitched.

“This isn’t his first time. He’s just not ready to admit he likes it.”

Through the window, Eli’s laughter carried — louder now, polished again. He looked like the version of himself Westmore believed in: the future banker, the legacy boyfriend, the son who never misstepped.

“He’s good at pretending,” Ethan said quietly.

“We all are,” Jason said. “You just have to decide what you’re pretending for. Eli’s had his life planned out since junior high, Ethan—but I don’t think he ever expected to meet someone like you.”

Feigning surprise, Ethan looked at Jason. “Please, you aren’t fooling anyone.”

The house creaked back into silence, the way old houses do when everyone’s pretending to sleep. Rather than return to their dorms, Ethan and Tyler “borrowed” two rooms upstairs. The rest of the brothers would not be back until Sunday. Ethan lay in bed staring at the ceiling, still hearing fragments of music from the farmhouse—the guitar, the laughter, the quiet way people looked at one another without fear.

He turned on his side and caught a slice of light under the door across the hall. Tyler’s room.

He should’ve ignored it. He told himself he would. Instead, he pulled on a sweatshirt and padded barefoot down the corridor, floorboards whispering beneath him.

He knocked once, lightly.

“Yeah?”

“You still up?”

Tyler was sitting cross-legged on the bed, wearing a t-shirt and flannel pants, reading a paperback that looked like it belonged to Jason. The lamp threw a warm cone of light across the room, the rest in shadow.

“Can’t sleep?” he asked.

“Guess not.”

Tyler marked his page and set the book down. “You keep thinking about him.”

“Eli?” Ethan said, though it wasn’t really a question.

Tyler shrugged. “You don’t have to lie to me.”

Ethan sat down at the edge of the bed, the mattress dipping under his weight. “I don’t even know what I’m thinking. He’s just… already living some future version of himself, and I’m still trying to figure out who I was yesterday.”

“You’re figuring it out faster than you think.”

Ethan smiled faintly. “You always sound like you know the answer.”

“No,” Tyler said, voice low. “I just stopped asking the wrong questions.”

They sat there a while, the air thick with quiet. The heat clicked on somewhere in the walls, a thin hum beneath the silence.

“That party tonight,” Ethan said finally, “it didn’t feel like hiding.”

“It’s not supposed to,” Tyler said. “It’s just people being themselves for a few hours. It’s a start.”

Ethan turned toward him. “You go there often?”

“Now and then.”

“With someone?”

Tyler smiled, not smug, just honest. “Sometimes.”

Ethan looked down at his hands. “It didn’t look like I thought it would. Any of it.”

“That’s the best part,” Tyler said.

The silence between them shifted — not tense, just alive. Tyler leaned back against the headboard, eyes on Ethan, measuring the space that was quickly disappearing.

“You don’t have to overthink it,” Tyler said softly.

Ethan met his gaze. “I’m not.”

Tyler reached out and brushed his thumb along Ethan’s jaw — light, almost accidental. Ethan didn’t move away. The touch turned into a line along his neck, then a slow draw of breath between them that felt like gravity giving up.

When they kissed, it wasn’t sudden or cinematic. It was slow, a steady unspooling of the week’s quiet tension. Tyler’s hand cupped the back of his neck, thumb tracing the pulse there. Ethan closed his eyes and let the rest of the world fall away.

The air smelled faintly of cedar and dust and whatever detergent Tyler used. His skin was warm, steady, real. When they broke apart, both were breathing softly, like they’d climbed something without realizing it.

“That okay?” Tyler asked.

Ethan nodded, still catching his breath. “Yeah. More than okay.”

They didn’t rush it. No fevered undoing of clothes, no cinematic fade. Just two people closing distance until there was none. They lay back side by side, shoulders touching, hands finding each other naturally. Tyler turned off the lamp, and in the dark their breathing matched — slow, quiet, the rhythm of two people who’d stopped pretending.

When Ethan woke, the window was rimed with frost. Tyler’s side of the bed was empty except for the faint warmth left in the sheets. He found him in the kitchen, barefoot, frying eggs in a pan that had seen better days. Jason sat at the counter with coffee, the morning paper folded open to the classifieds.

“Morning,” Jason said without looking up. “You two look like you actually slept.”

Ethan hesitated. Tyler didn’t. “We did,” he said easily, sliding eggs onto a plate.

Jason’s smirk was small but knowing. “Good. You’ll need the rest. Semester’s coming.”

He closed the paper and gestured toward the chair across from him. “Sit down, Harris.”

Ethan did. Jason poured another cup of coffee. The kitchen light caught the beginnings of his hairline’s retreat from his forehead — barely noticeable, but it made him seem older, almost paternal.

“You know what I like about you, Harris?” Jason asked.

“That I haven’t broken anything yet?”

Jason chuckled. “That you still believe people can be saved.”

Ethan frowned. “You mean Eli.”

Jason nodded. “You’ve been circling him since September. Don’t think I haven’t seen it. And I get it — he’s magnetic. He’s also stuck. You can’t fix that for him.”

Ethan stared into his cup. “I know.”

“Then stop waiting for him to become the version you need,” Jason said. “He’s already chosen who he has to be. Let him have it.”

“And what am I supposed to do?”

“What you’re already doing,” Jason said. “Find people who don’t make you smaller just so you’ll feel safe. Build your own circle. That’s what the Underground really is — not rebellion, just survival.”

He took a sip of coffee, eyes softening. “I saw you last night with Tyler. You were just… there. That’s what peace looks like. Don’t talk yourself out of it.”

The words landed like a hand on the shoulder — grounding, not heavy.

Tyler slid Ethan a plate. “He’s right, you know.”

Jason stood, stretching. “Of course I am. I’m old.”

“You’re twenty-two,” Tyler said.

“Ancient,” Jason replied. “Now eat. And then maybe help me take down all these lights before the rest of the clowns get back.”

He left the room humming, the sound fading down the hall.

Ethan looked across the table at Tyler. The morning light fell across his face, soft and uncomplicated.

“You okay?” Tyler asked.

“Yeah,” Ethan said quietly. “I think so.”

He meant it.

Outside, the day was pale and cold, sunlight spilling across the frost-covered lawn. The quad was still empty, but it wouldn’t be for long. By next week the noise would return — doors slamming, music from open windows, the same old rhythm of Westmore life.

But this morning was theirs: the quiet before it all began again, the space where something real had finally taken root.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• 🦋 Bluesky: @thecalebreed.bsky.social

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

“The week before break hung heavy, a long exhale nobody quite finished.”

The air felt brittle, the kind that stung when you breathed too hard. Westmore’s quad was drained of color—bare trees, damp brick, a thin film of frost that clung to the steps long after sunrise. Classes were nearly done, but the college refused to exhale.

Even after initiation, the new brothers weren’t free. Clay had made it clear: “Study hall doesn’t end until grades post.”

So every afternoon that week, the six of them still filed into the library at one o’clock sharp, same long table under buzzing lights, same worn carpet that smelled faintly of dust and chalk.

Ethan sat between Connor and Teddy. Mark had already drifted toward a window seat beside two guys from chemistry—one of them tutoring him, or pretending to. The air inside the library felt heavy, soaked with boredom and fluorescent fatigue. Every sound—the scrape of chair legs, the hum of heaters—carried like confession.

Teddy clicked his pen against the table. “Feels like boot camp with better lighting.”

“Boot camp ends,” Connor muttered, face-down in his notebook.

Mark looked up from his group, grinning. “Hey, at least we’re real brothers now.”

“Yeah,” Teddy said. “Brothers in remedial biology.”

Ethan smiled faintly. He was half-listening, half drifting, watching sunlight move in slow rectangles across the table. He realized, with mild surprise, that he wasn’t tense anymore. The silence didn’t feel punishing; it just was.

By four, they were released. Mark and Connor went to the dining hall; Teddy announced plans to “study” in front of the TV. Ethan walked alone toward the bookstore, cutting across the quad where the flag barely moved in the cold wind.

Inside, the warmth hit like nostalgia. The bookstore wasn’t much—just a few aisles of textbooks, school supplies, CDs, magazines, and a counter stacked with impulse buys. The cashier, a senior named Jack who worked every semester to offset tuition, looked up from the register.

“End of the line?” he asked.

“Almost,” Ethan said.

“Good. You guys have been living in here.”

He placed his usual on the counter: one glass bottle of Arizona Green Tea with Ginkgo and a pack of Camel Lights. The bottle’s green plastic wrap gleamed under the lights, cherry blossoms curling up its side like old porcelain.

“The bottle looked like porcelain—pale green plastic, cherry blossoms and gold script pretending at calm.”

Jack rang him up. “You’re Delta Chi, right?”

“Yeah,” he said. “How’d you know?”

“I’ve seen you hanging around with Jason—he lived on my hall freshman year.”

Ethan laughed quietly, handing him his ID. Outside, the air was sharp again. He cracked the cap, the metallic ping echoing against the brick wall, and took a long sip. Sweet, cold, just enough caffeine to keep him from drifting.

Across the quad, he spotted Tyler walking out of the science building, collar turned up against the wind. He was laughing with another student Ethan didn’t recognize—a real laugh, unforced, easy. Ethan thought about calling out, then didn’t. He let the moment stay small.

Back in McClintock, the hall smelled of weed and burnt popcorn. Mark was sprawled across his bed with his Aiwa shelf stereo blaring the end of Counting Crows’ “A Murder of One,” one of the six discs stacked in its changer.

“Dude, turn it down,” Ethan said, dropping his bag.

“Finals playlist,” Mark answered, grinning. “It’s working. Barely.”

Ethan lay back, the radiator clattering awake. The semester felt like it was shrinking behind him, each sound turning faint and harmless. He thought about the porch at the house, about Tyler’s quiet grin, about Eli’s silence since initiation. All of it had stopped feeling like noise. It just sat there, like weather.

“He told himself that once finals were over, he’d feel different—lighter, maybe.”

He wasn’t sure what that meant, but he believed it.

“The Row looked like a power surge waiting to happen.”

Every house was overdoing it for the Christmas-light contest, but Delta Chi made it a mission. Strings of multicolored bulbs tangled across the roofline, nets of white lights draped over bushes, cords trailing from open windows. The sleigh Jason had pulled from the attic leaned against the porch rail, half finished, already warped by frost.

Inside, the house buzzed with pre-break energy. The downstairs stereo—an archaeological dig of mismatched components—was already thumping. Two Pioneer speakers from the eighties, a Fisher amp with no knob, and a Technics six-disc changer blinking its random order like an SOS. The stack perched on milk crates, cords running through the baseboards.

“The house stereo was a patchwork of ghosts—every brother who’d graduated left a speaker or some component behind.”

Mark and Connor were stringing garland around the bannister. Teddy had rigged a strand of lights along the bar that shorted every time someone poured a drink. The smell of bourbon and cigarettes blended with pine and old carpet.

By late afternoon, the Kingston girls had arrived, Catherine leading the charge in a green sweater and boots that clicked on the hardwood. The noise swelled instantly—laughing, music, the pop of beer caps. Eli was with her, a cigarette tucked behind his ear, running on that effortless charm he slipped into like a jacket.

When Ethan passed them in the hall, Eli’s eyes caught his for half a second—recognition, apology, habit—then the moment was gone.

Jason’s voice cut through from the porch. “Hey, Harris! Fuse blew again. Grab the ladder.”

Upstairs, Jason’s room smelled faintly of cedar and cold air. The lamp on his desk flickered as they rewired another strand.

“Festive enough?” Ethan said.

“Festive enough to kill us,” Jason replied, twisting a plug until the lights snapped back to life. He lit a cigarette, exhaling toward the cracked window.

“You’re alright, Harris,” he said finally. “Don’t let the rest of them make you think otherwise.”

Ethan nodded. He wanted to thank him but didn’t trust his voice.

Downstairs, Found Out About You bled through the speakers, the volume distorting the bass. Teddy declared it the “song of the semester.” Connor argued that Hey Jealousy had more range. The argument became a chant, a cheer, then dissolved into laughter.

“The house shook with the kind of laughter that only happens when everyone knows they’re leaving tomorrow.”

Catherine had taken over the couch, gesturing wildly as she told a story. Eli leaned close, listening too carefully, smiling just enough. When he laughed, it was the same performance Ethan had seen all semester. It didn’t sting anymore—just looked exhausting.

Later, Ethan slipped outside to cool off. The night air bit through his shirt. On the back steps, Tyler sat smoking, shoulders hunched, smoke curling in front of the colored lights.

“You heading out early?” Ethan asked.

“Soon as I wake up. You?”

“Six-hour drive. Home by dinner if the Jeep makes it.”

“Better bring a tape deck for when the Discman skips.”

Ethan laughed softly. “Already does.”

Tyler held out the cigarette. Ethan took it, the filter warm from his lips. They shared a quiet drag, watching the lights flicker across the lawn.

“It wasn’t tension anymore. Just understanding.”

“Take care of yourself,” Tyler said finally, voice even.

“You too.”

They stood. Ethan brushed ash from his sleeve, nodded toward the noise inside.

“See you next semester.”

“Yeah,” Tyler said, smiling. “You will.”

Ethan walked across the quad later, the house glowing behind him like a postcard. The noise had faded to a hum, red and green light blurring into white.

“The movement felt like a pause—an interval between lives.”

He left before dawn, frost crusting the Jeep’s windshield. The Discman balanced in the console, anti-shock long dead, a Counting Crows CD skipping every time he hit a pothole. The MapQuest pages sat folded on the passenger seat, six sheets curling at the edges from the heater vent. He’d printed them in the computer lab the night before—bold black text, capitalized turns, LEFT ONTO US-460 EAST—directions that looked more official than they were.

The bottle of Arizona Green Tea rode between the seats, the fake-porcelain design gleaming faintly in the dash light. The sweetness clung to the back of his throat. Cigarette smoke slipped out the cracked window, vanishing into the cold.

“He kept replaying the same track, even though it skipped on the chorus. Maybe he liked hearing what was missing.”

By the time he hit the highway, the sun was up—a flat, white light bleeding across the fields. He passed trucks hauling Christmas trees, the scent of sap leaking through the air vents. The road unrolled in straight lines east, toward home, toward quiet.

He thought about Tyler’s cigarette ember in the dark, about Eli’s practiced laugh, about Jason’s voice at the window. None of it hurt; it just hovered, like static on an old radio.

Around noon, he stopped at a gas station off I-95. The asphalt shimmered faintly with salt. He bought another bottle of the same tea, cold enough to fog the glass, and a bag of Combos. The clerk barely looked at him. He liked that.

Home appeared mid-afternoon, crossing the Black River, then the Waccamaw, the marsh stretching silver under a low winter sun. Finally, he was home.

The closer he got to the coast, the flatter the light became. This stretch of the state still looked untouched if you didn’t know better—tidal creeks winding through spartina, pines giving way to live oaks. He knew every curve. His family had been out here since the first houses went up, long before the golf course and the security arm. Moving out here had been its own kind of announcement back then: proof that you’d made it.

He slowed at the gatehouse out of habit, though the guard still leaned out and yelled for him to slow down. They’d been doing that since he first started driving—same guard, same bark, as if every kid who grew up here was destined to test that curve. Out of sight of the gate, he did what he’d always done: dropped a gear and gunned it over the sweeping bridge, the Jeep rising just enough to feel it in his stomach. The salt pond, covered with ducks, spread out on the left, the creek glittering on the right, the ocean a straight shot ahead beyond the dunes. If the security truck was parked at the gate, you were safe; it meant the patrol was inside, nowhere near you.

Beyond the bridge the road curved beneath live oaks, their limbs knitted together like an archway. Half the houses were lit again—North Carolina and Virginia plates in the driveways, families back for the holidays. His parents were part of the year-round crowd, the first wave who’d bought when the roads were still sand and rumor. The rules hadn’t changed: no colored lights, no noise after ten, no sign of effort. Effort, like money, was meant to look inherited.

Out back, the old johnboat was still tied to the same piling, paint worn to silver along the gunwale. His father had been running that boat since before the developers broke ground—knew every bend of the creek by smell. When Ethan was a kid, they’d go flounder-gigging after dark, the motor wide open with no light, his father navigating the sandbars and oyster beds by memory. Folks used to follow him from the landing just to see where he’d fish, but they never found his spots. The new people out here were all performance: glossy gear, spotless boots. His father never had to prove a thing.

The house could have been in one of those southern design magazines his mother loved. She had spent weeks making garlands, swags, and wreaths from the cedar, magnolia, and pine from the yard—everything finished off with an oversized red-velvet bow. It was a tasteful representation of the classic Lowcountry Christmas. This wasn’t the type of place to hang Christmas lights.

His mom was in the kitchen, potpourri simmering on the stove as she finished rolling her Christmas cookies in powdered sugar. “Why didn’t you call from the road?” she scolded. “Your daddy and I had no idea what time you would get here.” Ethan returned her embrace and kissed her cheek.

“I wish you wouldn’t smoke,” she said. “It’s so tacky.” He wanted to remind her that she was the only one in her family who didn’t smoke, but it wasn’t worth it.

“Get settled,” she said finally. “Your daddy took the dogs down to the beach, and your sister should be home from school any minute.”

Dinner was harmless—grades, classes, the house. He told the safe version: that the lights contest was a disaster, that they’d still won somehow, that Jason had nearly electrocuted himself. They laughed, and for once it didn’t feel like pretending.

He’d grown up between two kinds of perfection—his mother’s, measured in ribbon and polish, and his father’s, measured in quiet skill. Everything about the man seemed certain: how to back a trailer in one try, where the trout would be after a storm, what silence was for. That certainty had always been Ethan’s map for what a man was supposed to be. Maybe that’s why Westmore had rattled him so deeply; he’d been looking for that same steadiness and kept finding performance instead.

That night, in his old room, the posters still hung where he’d left them—Pearl Jam, Pulp Fiction—corners curled from humidity. He lay back, listening to the ceiling fan’s lazy churn, and realized how quiet the world could be when no one was demanding anything of him.

“He realized how quiet the world could be when no one was demanding anything of him.”

The next morning he walked down to the dock. The tide was low, the pluff mud shining gray beneath a thin sun. The air smelled of salt and sulfur. He sat on the edge, hands deep in his jacket pockets, listening to the creak of boards and watching the fiddler crabs looking for food.

Across the creek the new houses had their docks lit up like runways, a glow that didn’t belong to the water. His father never needed lights. He and his brothers had grown up hunting and fishing these creeks their whole lives, long before the gates and the golf carts. The new people called it lifestyle; for them it had just been life.

It struck him that the quiet wasn’t emptiness anymore. It was space.

He skipped a shell across the surface—one, two, three hops—before it vanished. Behind him, gulls cried like they were fighting over something invisible. Just beyond, he could see the back fin of a spottail bass tailing in the shallows, rare this time of year. He watched the spottail’s fin cut the surface and disappear again. You only saw them tail like that in places the world hadn’t ruined yet.

He thought of the semester like a weight shed: Eli’s masks, the noise of the house, the blur of pledging. All of it still existed, but it no longer owned him.

“The quiet wasn’t emptiness anymore. It was space.”

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

Clay’s voice was low and raw from a week of shouting. “Gentlemen,” he said, pacing the line of pledges like a man inspecting livestock, “you have survived Hell Week. That means you have earned the right to stand here.”

Ethan kept his chin up, though the collar of his shirt still clung to his neck. Released from the basement less than 8 hours ago, the six of them stood shoulder to shoulder in rumpled blazers, mud still crusted under their fingernails, faces pale from the sleepless night.

Jason stood at the front of the room, holding a tray lined with tiny pins. “Tonight,” he said, “we stop calling you pledges.” The brothers crowded the edges of the room, jackets dark, expressions unreadable. The flicker of candlelight carved shadows across the wall where the fraternity’s crest hung. Someone coughed. Someone else muttered, “Finally.”

Clay’s mouth twitched, but he ignored it. “You have been broken down and built again,” he continued. “You have learned obedience. You have learned humility.” He paused, then added, “You have learned that the house always comes first.”

Jason stepped forward. His voice carried differently — steadier, cleaner, like someone accustomed to ceremony. “When I call your name, step forward.”

The first pledge — Connor — moved stiffly. Jason pinned him with surprising gentleness, clapped his shoulder, murmured something Ethan couldn’t hear. Teddy followed, eyes glassy with exhaustion but smiling faintly. Marco winked as he stepped up, earning a few laughs. Tyler went last before Ethan, his hands steady at his sides.

Then it was Ethan’s turn.

“Ethan Harris,” Jason said.

Ethan stepped forward into the warmth of the candlelight. Jason met his eyes briefly, then fixed the small pin to his lapel. “You belong to something bigger than yourself now,” he said softly, so only Ethan could hear. “Don’t forget what it cost.”

Ethan nodded once. His throat was too tight for words.

Jason straightened, raised his voice. “Brothers—welcome them home.”

The room erupted. The sudden roar — clapping, whoops, someone pounding a chair against the floor — crashed over them. Clay grinned at last, relief breaking through his usual edge. Someone popped a beer, a bit of the spray caught Ethan’s cheek.

Catherine and the Kingston crew appeared as if on cue, it was turning into a proper party.

Ethan tried to smile, but the sound felt far away, like he was listening through water. The pin on his chest caught the light every time he breathed.

They spilled onto the porch minutes later, blinking against the night. The air felt cold and clean after the furnace of the chapter room. Someone passed around cigars; someone else dragged out a half-empty bottle of bourbon.

“Gentlemen,” Connor declared, swaying, “we are free men!”

“Free,” Teddy echoed, raising his beer, “and probably still grounded!”

Laughter rippled down the steps. Jason leaned against the railing, cigarette glowing in his hand, expression relaxed for the first time Ethan had seen. When their eyes met, he nodded — almost paternal.

“Good work last night Little Brother,” Jason said when Ethan passed him. “Get some rest. You’ll need it.”

“For what?” Ethan asked.

Jason smiled faintly, putting his arm around Ethan’s shoulders. “For pretending this changed anything.” Before Ethan could ask what he meant, Jason squeezed his shoulder gently. “Listen, Ethan—I know I haven’t been much of a Big Brother. But if you ever need someone, I’m here. Eli’s not the only one who understands.”

He flicked his cigarette into the yard and walked off.

Eli was on the edge of the porch, one step below the others, head tilted toward the street. A cigarette hung from his lips, ember bright in the dark. He looked like he’d been waiting there all along, Catherine not by his side for the first time tonight.

Ethan hesitated, then stepped down beside him.

“So,” Eli said without looking at him, “you made it.”

“Barely.”

“That’s the trick.” He smiled, still not turning. “They make you think surviving it means something. You’ll figure out soon it’s just a warm-up.”

Ethan studied him — the loose tie, the tired eyes, the faint trace of sweat on his neck. “You sound like you hated it.”

Eli exhaled smoke, watching it vanish. “I did. Everyone does. You just learn to act like you didn’t.”

They stood there a moment, the noise from the porch swelling behind them — laughter, shouting, the sharp crack of another beer being opened. The night hummed with relief and exhaustion.

“Jason said something like that,” Ethan murmured. “That it doesn’t change anything.”

Eli finally looked at him. “He’s right.”

Ethan nodded slowly. “Then what’s the point?”

“The point,” Eli said, “is that everyone thinks it matters. That’s how the whole thing stays standing.”

For a moment neither spoke. A car turned onto the Row, headlights slicing across their faces, then disappeared into the dark. Eli glanced toward the house. “You heading back soon?”

“Yeah. Mark’s probably already passed out.”

Eli’s voice softened. “Come upstairs first. Catherine’s’ halfway back to Kingston by now, something about an early class she can’t miss, whatever.”

Ethan hesitated just long enough for Eli to notice. If he was being honest, he had missed Eli this week—missed whatever it was they had started. He wanted to go upstairs, but the thought of what might follow made him uneasy.

“Relax, man,” Eli said, half-smiling. “No pressure. Just a drink.”

Ethan nodded. “Okay.”

Eli pushed off the railing and led the way through the side door, the noise of the porch fading behind them.

Eli’s door was half-open, the lamplight falling across the hallway like a thin stripe of gold. Ethan followed him in, shutting it quietly behind them.

Eli poured two fingers of bourbon into a pair of glasses, emblazoned with the Westmore crest-bookstore standard issue. “To survival,” he said, handing one over.

Ethan took a cautious sip. It burned, but not in the way the cheap party liquor did. He coughed once, then laughed. “That’s awful.”

Eli smiled. “Yeah, but it’s honest.”

They sat across from each other—Eli on the edge of his bed, Ethan in the desk chair turned backward. The silence between them was comfortable in that way that only exhaustion can make it.

Eli stared at the floor, rolling the glass between his palms. “You know,” he said, “when I was standing where you were tonight, I thought it meant something. Like, this was the start of belonging somewhere. Turns out, it’s just the start of pretending better.”

Ethan studied him. “Then why keep doing it?”

“Because the pretending pays off,” Eli said. “People stop asking questions if you play your part long enough. They’ll call you brother, buy you a beer, never look close enough to see what’s really going on.”

He looked up then, eyes tired but steady. “It’s easier to be what they expect than what you are.”

Ethan noticed Eli’s jaw clench just a bit, his shoulders tight as he turned the glass in his hands. “You really believe that?”

“I have to.” Eli leaned back, the headboard creaking. “This place isn’t built for people like me. Or you.”

Ethan laughed softly. “You say that like you know what I am.”

Eli’s eyes flicked over him, the corner of his mouth curving playfully. “I have a guess.”

Neither moved for a long time. The fan filled the silence, a steady heartbeat of air.

Ethan wanted to join him there, but resisted. Finally, Ethan spoke. “Mark asked where I’ve been sneaking off to every night.”

That landed hard. Eli’s fingers froze around his glass. “What?”

“Tonight. On the way back. He asked what I’ve been up to. I guess he’s not as dead to world as you said”

Eli sat up, every muscle tightening. “And what did you say?”

“Nothing. I said I didn’t know.”

Eli nodded once, too quickly. “Good.”

Ethan frowned. “You make it sound like I confessed to a crime.”

Eli stood, crossing the small room, needing motion. He found a cigarette, lit it, took a sharp drag. “You didn’t. But this—whatever it is—it doesn’t survive daylight. You know that.”

Ethan set his cup down, voice low. “Why not? He’s your brother. Don’t you trust him?”

Eli exhaled smoke toward the fan. “That’s exactly why. Mark talks before he thinks. He still believes this place is what it says it is—honor, loyalty, tradition. He thinks it’s safe.” He turned, eyes catching the lamplight. “If he knew, it wouldn’t stay between us. Not because he’d want to hurt anyone. Because he’d try to help.”

Ethan shook his head. “That doesn’t sound like a bad thing.”

“It would be,” Eli said flatly. “It would get you labeled. And once that happens, you don’t come back from it here. Not in this house. Not at Westmore.”

Ethan looked down at his hands. “So I just pretend too?”

Eli gave a bitter smile. “Welcome to the brotherhood, we’re all pretending to some degree.”

They sat in silence again, the bourbon warming their veins but not softening the edge between them.

Ethan spoke first. “Catherine was there tonight. After the ceremony.”

Eli didn’t flinch, but something in his posture stiffened. “She comes to everything. Part of the act.”

“Is that what she is? An act?”

Eli rubbed his forehead. “She’s…a reminder. Of what I’m supposed to want. What everyone expects me to be.”

“And what about what you actually want?”

Eli looked at him, a long, searching look that felt like an answer on its own. “What I want doesn’t fit here or where I’m heading next.”

The room went still. Outside, the wind rattled the window screen.

Ethan rose from the chair, slow and unsure. “You don’t have to keep doing this, you know.”

Eli gave a soft, humorless laugh. “And what? Walk around holding your hand? You saw what this place did to you this week. Imagine what it’d do to me.”

“I’m not asking you to hold my hand,” Ethan said quietly. “I’m just tired of acting like it didn’t happen.”

Eli met his eyes. For a moment, the distance closed. “You think I’m not?” His voice cracked on the last word, barely audible.

Ethan stepped closer. “Then why can’t I tell him? Mark. Why can’t anyone know?”

Eli’s hand trembled slightly as he stubbed out the cigarette. “Because once someone else knows, it stops being ours.”

Ethan blinked, confused. “Isn’t that the point? To stop hiding?”

Eli shook his head, standing now, so close Ethan could feel the heat off him. “He’s my brother Ethan, you don’t have that right. Besides, if he knew, it would just be a matter of time before they’d eat us alive. You, me, both of us.”

Ethan’s throat ached. “So what happens now?”

Eli looked at him for a long moment, then reached out, fingertips brushing the edge of Ethan’s sleeve. “We keep quiet. We keep it ours. For now.”

The touch lingered—soft, apologetic. Ethan’s breath caught. Eli’s hand moved up, settling against his neck, pulling him forward until their foreheads touched.

Ethan whispered, “For now.”

Eli didn’t correct him.

The kiss came slow, familiar, stripped of urgency. It felt like acknowledgment and goodbye all at once. When they pulled apart, neither stepped back.

Eli exhaled, the bourbon and smoke still warm on his breath. “You should go,” he said, though his hand hadn’t moved. Ethan wanted to stay, but wasn’t going to give Eli the satisfaction.

“I know.”

Eli’s thumb brushed the line of Ethan’s jaw, then fell away. “You did good tonight.”

“So did you.”

Eli smiled faintly, eyes tired. “Don’t say that too loud.”

Ethan’s laugh was soft, almost sad. “Goodnight, Eli.” Eli pulled Ethan into a tight embrace, his stubble like sandpaper on Ethan’s cheek. Neither wanted to break, but Ethan kissed Eli on the cheek and turned for the door.

Eli leaned against the door after he left, listening to the quiet settle back in.

The house had gone quiet.

From upstairs came only the muffled thud of someone dropping a shoe, a door shutting against laughter. The kind of silence that follows celebration—uneasy, temporary, like the night itself was catching its breath.

Ethan stepped out into it, tugging his jacket tight. The air smelled faintly of woodsmoke and wet leaves. Across the lawn, a plastic cup rolled in the breeze, tapping lightly against the curb before settling in the gutter. The row looked empty now, hollowed out by exhaustion.

His head still buzzed from the bourbon and from the conversation he couldn’t stop replaying.

Because once someone else knows, it stops being ours.

He turned it over again and again, like a riddle that refused to make sense. The night had been full of noise, ceremony, shouts of brotherhood, but the only thing that felt real was the sound of Eli’s voice saying ours like it was both promise and warning.

The walk back to McClintock was short—five minutes if you cut across the quad—but the campus felt unfamiliar. The lamps along the path hummed with that sickly yellow glow that made everything look suspended.

A pair of pledges from another house staggered by, now brothers too, still wearing their jackets like trophies. One of them nodded at Ethan and said, “Congrats, man,” without slowing down. Ethan mumbled a thank-you he didn’t mean.

He climbed the dorm stairs slowly, each step echoing.

At the door, he paused. The pin Jason had given him felt heavy on his lapel, like a lie he couldn’t take off.

Inside, the room was dark except for the streetlight filtering through the blinds. Mark lay sprawled across his bed, one arm flung over his face, breathing slow and even. His jacket was draped neatly on the chair between their beds, the same pin glinting faintly in the glow.

Ethan undressed quietly, tossing his shirt over the back of the chair. The smell of smoke clung to it, faint and familiar. For a moment he thought about shaking Mark awake—telling him everything. It would be so easy. Just a whisper in the dark. He knew that Eli was right, that Mark would try to help. Mark was loyal to a fault and Ethan knew that he would support him.

Mark asked what I’ve been up to.

He could finish the sentence this time. He could say Eli. He could say your brother.

But the words froze before they even reached his throat.

He sat on the edge of his bed, staring at the floor. The hum of the radiator filled the room, soft and rhythmic. He could still feel the shape of Eli’s touch on his skin—the small press of a thumb against his jaw, the warmth that lingered long after he’d left the room.

He reached into his pocket and pulled out the quarter. The metal was cool against his palm, the ridged edge biting faintly when he closed his hand. A pledge token, Clay had called it. A reminder to always be ready. He turned it over in his fingers, catching the light off its surface.

It was supposed to mean loyalty. Duty. Brotherhood.

But tonight it just felt like a secret.

He placed it on the nightstand beside his pin and watched the two pieces of metal gleam side by side—the symbol of belonging and the symbol of survival.

Mark shifted in his sleep, murmuring something Ethan couldn’t make out. For a heartbeat, he looked younger, almost innocent. Ethan felt a pang of something he couldn’t name—envy, maybe, or guilt.

He lay back, staring at the ceiling. The quiet pressed in, heavy and familiar. Somewhere outside, a car door slammed, laughter rose and fell, then faded down the street. The night moved on, and he stayed still.

He thought of Eli’s last words—Keep it ours. For now.

The phrase looped in his head, both comfort and curse.

He wondered how long “for now” could last before it collapsed under its own weight.

When he finally drifted toward sleep, the fan hummed against the window, steady as breathing. Across the room, Mark stirred and rolled over, mumbling something about brotherhood.

Ethan turned his face to the wall, eyes open in the dark.

“Brother.”

He whispered the word back to himself, tasting it, testing it, as if it might still mean what it used to.

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Caleb Reed for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The call came at 9:57 on a Sunday night, long after most of campus had gone still.

Clay’s voice was flat: ten minutes to pack, report to the house, bring your tokens.

That was all.

Ethan and Mark looked at each other across their desks. For a moment neither moved. Then the familiar scramble—drawers opening, books shoved aside, the panic of deciding what “for the week” even meant. A toothbrush. Deodorant. The quarter, the cigarette pack, the condom. When they stepped into the corridor pledges from the other houses were already there, the same stunned look on every face.

Outside, the night was unseasonably warm. Trucks idled along Fraternity Row, headlights cutting through mist that hung low over the lawns. Across the quad, the other houses were doing the same thing—lines of boys in coats and ties carrying duffels, moving in silence. From somewhere up the hill came laughter: Phi Rho pledges in orange jumpsuits marching two by two, wrists linked with novelty hand-cuffs. On the next lawn over, Sigma Epsilon’s newest class stood in nothing but white briefs and bow ties, shivering theatrically while upperclassmen filmed them on camcorders. The crowd that had gathered hooted like it was Homecoming. Ethan couldn’t help but stare.

Clay met them at the Delta Chi door clad in his black Fratagonia vest. “Keys,” he said, holding out a coffee can. The sound of metal hitting metal was steady, almost musical. When Ethan’s turn came, he hesitated a second longer than he meant to, then let his key ring drop. Clay smiled without warmth. “You belong to the house now.”

The basement smelled like Pine-Sol and damp carpet. Six thin mattresses were lined along one wall, blankets folded military-neat. A single fluorescent tube hummed overhead, turning skin sallow. “This is home ‘till initiation,” Clay said. “You leave only for class or meals. You move as one. You speak when spoken to. You keep your heads down. Understood?” No one answered quickly enough, so he made them shout it back until their voices echoed off concrete. Then he killed the light and left.

The rhythm of the week set in immediately.

By daylight, Westmore was a carnival of degradation. Every fraternity staged its own brand of tradition—boys in tighty-whities and ties jogging across the quad, others in tuxedo jackets and diapers singing school songs. Professors pretended not to notice. One history instructor paused mid-lecture, glanced at the line of bleary faces in the back row, and said only, “I hope ya’ll survive the Enlightenment.”

Laughter rippled through the class; no one asked for an explanation.

Between classes, pledges from different houses traded the same deadpan greetings:

“How’s your week?”

“Still vertical.”

“Drink water.”

It was a kind of code, proof they were all prisoners in the same joke.

Ethan drifted through it half-awake. Every doorway held a variation of the same scene—someone mopping a hallway in his underwear, someone else hauling trash to a cheering crowd. The entire campus smelled of bleach and stale beer. Even the professors’ dogs, brought to class for comfort, flinched at sudden shouting from the lawns.

Nights belonged to the basement.

They stumbled down the stairs together, ties loosened, voices low. Clay would appear just long enough to bark orders—push-ups, recitations, a few rounds of the creed—then vanish, leaving them with the hum of the furnace and the creak of the house settling above.

After the first two nights, the silence became companionable.

Connor filled it with stories about his high-school girlfriend; Teddy invented elaborate games that required no movement. Marco sang snatches of songs from home in a voice too good for the room. Tyler mostly listened, sitting with his back against the wall, eyes half-closed. When he did speak, everyone else went quiet.

On Tuesday night a storm rolled in. Rain hammered the tiny basement window, the glass clouded with condensation. The six of them sat cross-legged on the floor passing around a sleeve of crackers pilfered from the kitchen.

Teddy said, “You realize that other than when we’re in class, we’ve been breathing the same air for forty-eight hours?”

Connor: “Pretty sure Clay’s using us to test biological weapons.”

Laughter, genuine this time.

Ethan lay back on his mattress, watching the ceiling pipes quiver each time someone upstairs flushed a toilet.

For the first time since the call, he felt almost calm.

The storm had burned itself out hours ago. Upstairs the last door slammed, laughter muffled, then the house went still. Down in the basement, five of them slept in uneven rows, breath syncing with the hum of the furnace.

By mid-week the exhaustion had its own gravity.

They woke at dawn, went to class in wrinkled shirts, sat through lectures that blurred into static. At meals they ate mechanically, the six of them moving like a single exhausted organism. Everyone on campus recognized the look. Even the cafeteria staff served them with a kind of reverence, sliding extra biscuits onto their trays as if feeding soldiers.

On Wednesday afternoon Ethan passed a group of Waverly girls lounging under umbrellas outside the dining hall. One raised her camera, snapped a photo of the parade of pledges shuffling by, and called, “Smile, boys!”

Tyler, walking just ahead, turned his head but didn’t smile. The camera clicked anyway.

That night, the image would appear on the campus bulletin board: “Westmore Men, Week of Tradition.”

In biology lab, Dr. Carroll handed Ethan back his paper without a word. Her eyes lingered a beat too long on his unshaven face, disheveled face, then moved on.

Back at the house, the basement grew warmer, air thick with sweat and BO. No one had showered since Sunday. Clay appeared less often now; the real punishment was monotony. Hours of waiting, the six of them half-asleep, half-starved, every sound upstairs magnified—the slam of a door, the laughter of brothers, the faint thud of music.

They started talking in whispers even when no one was there.

Marco confessed he missed his mom’s lasagna more than his girlfriend.

Teddy admitted he’d been faking half the chants since day one.

Connor said nothing at all for a long time, then murmured, “I’m scared of what comes next,” and everyone pretended not to hear him.

When the light finally flicked off, Ethan lay awake listening to Tyler’s breathing a few feet away, steady and even. The sound anchored him.

The next morning, they emerged into sunlight that felt unreal. The air smelled of wet leaves and red clay. All across the quad, the spectacle continued: Phi Rho’s chain gang dragging kegs; Kappa Tau pledges wearing trash bags as ponchos; faculty strolling past as though none of it existed. A freshman touring group stopped near the fountain, their guide chirping about “the bonds of brotherhood.”

Ethan caught Tyler’s eye and nearly laughed again, but he didn’t.

By afternoon the laughter had vanished. The fatigue was too heavy.

Only the rhythm remained: class, cafeteria, study hall, basement.

Breathing, surviving, waiting for whatever came next.

By Thursday the house had settled into a low, constant vibration—music bleeding faintly through the floorboards, rain whispering against the tiny basement window. The six of them barely moved unless called upstairs for some errand or tax. Someone was always half-asleep, someone always counting the hours aloud just to prove they still could.

When Clay did come down, it was almost a relief. He barked through another round of trivia and push-ups, clipboard tucked under his arm like a shield. Nobody even groaned. They moved on instinct, bodies remembering before minds did. When it was over, he dropped a case of yellow beer on the floor and left them one each. “Hydration,” he said.

They drank in silence, foam stinging cracked lips. Connor raised his can. “To freedom,” he said. Teddy snorted. “To Stockholm syndrome.” Laughter scattered around the room, weak but real. For a moment the basement felt almost like a choice.

Later, when the others drifted off, Ethan found Tyler sitting on the bottom step, cigarette balanced between his fingers. The glow lit his face from below, turning him into something carved from the dark.

“Thought we weren’t supposed to smoke,” Ethan said.

Tyler shrugged. “Everyone’s passed out, wanna go outside then?”

They slipped upstairs barefoot, shoes in hand, easing the door closed behind them. The back deck was slick with rain, the boards cold underfoot. The air smelled of wet leaves and something electric, like the world had just been rinsed clean.

Tyler dug in his pocket, pulled out his cigarette pack and shook out two joints, hidden inside. “Figured we earned it,” he said, cupping his hand around the lighter. The flame caught, painting his face in orange. Ethan watched him exhale into the night, the smoke curling up and vanishing.

“Whole campus feels asleep,” Ethan said.

Tyler shook his head. “They’re all awake. Just pretending not to be.”

The words hung there. They passed the joint between them, the tip glowing soft red. For once there was no noise from the house, no clipboard, no rules—just the steady chirp of frogs in the trees.

Tyler glanced over. “You ever get tired of pretending?”

Ethan met his eyes. “Sure.”

Tyler’s chuckle was quiet, almost shy. “Yeah. Me too.”

The porch light buzzed, and in the thin hum of it Ethan felt something ease inside him. He leaned in without thinking. Their foreheads touched first, then a small, uncertain kiss that tasted like smoke and rain. Neither spoke; the silence said everything it needed to.

When they finally pulled apart, Ethan put his arm around Tyler’s and rested his head on his shoulder. The distance felt safe, not fragile.

Tyler flicked the roach into the wet grass. “Do you want to talk about this?”.

Ethan nodded. “We don’t have to.”

He lit the second one and passed it over; Ethan took one drag and handed it back. The smoke made the air taste like outside.

“After this,” Tyler said quietly, “are you still gonna want it? The house, I mean.”

Ethan thought about the roar above them, the lineups, Eli’s silence. “I don’t know anymore.”

Tyler nodded, like he’d already decided. “Yeah. Me either.”They stayed there another minute, the lighter flame long gone, the night holding its breath. Then Tyler opened the door, and they slipped back into the dark.

Friday morning the rain cleared. The campus looked scrubbed raw—lawns gouged by tire tracks, banners limp and stained. Pledges from other houses shuffled to class in their various uniforms of shame: orange jumpsuits, boxers, painted faces. The smell of cheap beer clung to everything.

Inside the lecture halls the professors pretended this was all normal. One English professor started to discuss Heart of Darkness and then stopped, looking over the room of glassy-eyed boys, and simply said, “You’re almost through it.” No one asked what “it” meant.

By nightfall exhaustion had burned through fear. When Clay opened the basement door and shouted “Inspection,” they didn’t even flinch. He looked almost disappointed. “You’re getting used to it,” he said, like that was the worst sin of all.

He made them polish the composite frames, scrub the concrete, line their mattresses by height order. At the end he tossed a handful of blindfolds on the floor. “Tomorrow night,” he said. “Don’t be late.”

Saturday arrived heavy and bright, the kind of autumn day that feels too calm to trust. The cafeteria buzzed with anticipation—students placing bets on which fraternity would get written up this year, who would puke, who would pass out. Every few minutes another chant broke out somewhere across the quad, echoing off the red-brick buildings like thunder. They took their time heading back to the house, enjoying the sun and fall air. Finally Ethan broke the silence. “Teddy, what is under your jacket?” drawing everyone’s attention to the bulge under his Barbour coat. Teddy grinned “Bread, I grabbed a loaf for each of us.” “Why?” Connor asked. “To eat before the line-up. My cousin at UVA told me about it. It absorbs the cheap wine, keeps you from getting too sick.” Ethan, the only science major amongst them started to argue, but just grabbed his bag. He knew he had this, he would be fine the told himself.

Back at the house, they waited. Each minute stretched thin. Connor tried to tell a joke and forgot the punchline halfway through. Teddy paced. Marco sat with his head in his hands. Tyler leaned back against the wall, eyes closed, hands resting loosely on his knees. Ethan watched him and felt the world slow to the rhythm of that breathing.

Then came the boots on the stairs. Clay’s voice, cheerful now: “Rise and shine, gentlemen. Hell Night.”

Outside, the floodlights turned the yard into a stage. The other fraternities were already in motion: Phi Rho’s “chain gang” chanting in orange, Sigma Epsilon’s pledges kneeling in rows of white underwear, every house trying to outdo the others in spectacle. Upperclassmen shouted from porches, music collided in the air until it became one enormous heartbeat.

Delta Chi’s brothers formed a ring around the six pledges. Clay paced the center, whistle hanging from his neck. “Last test,” he said. “Give us everything.”

What followed came in flashes more than sequence:

— the sting of warm, cheap wine hitting the back of the throat;

— mud under fingernails; cuts on knees

— voices blending into thunder;

— Teddy stumbling, hands out, Connor hauling him up;

— Marco laughing until he cried;

— Tyler steady beside Ethan, a shadow of calm.

At one point Ethan’s knees buckled and someone shouted his name. He looked up through the lights and saw Eli at the edge of the circle, cigarette glowing like a small red star. Their eyes met for a breath. Eli didn’t move, didn’t speak. Ethan looked away, thinking of Tyler, willing this to be over.

When the whistle finally blew, Clay’s voice cracked through the dark. “That’s it. You’re still here. That’s the point.”

They staggered back inside as the first hint of dawn bruised the horizon. The house was wrecked—mud on the floor, the smell of smoke and bourbon hanging heavy. Jason was waiting at the top of the basement stairs, hair damp, tie loose. He looked at them and smiled, not unkindly. “Sleep,” he said. “Initiation at midnight.”

He set a folded towel on the rail for each of them, small mercies neatly stacked.

Downstairs, nobody spoke. They peeled off filthy clothes, wrapped in the towels, collapsed onto their mattresses. Pipes hissed overhead as the showers upstairs came on—brothers washing away the night. The sound was oddly soothing.

Ethan lay on his back staring at the ceiling, tracing the pattern of water stains. Tyler turned over on the next mattress, eyes open.

“We made it,” he whispered.

Ethan nodded. His throat hurt too much for words.

“Barely,” Tyler added.

“I don’t think I could have done it without you” Ethan managed.

Outside, the floodlights blinked off one by one until only the gray of morning remained. The house settled into silence. For the first time all week, Ethan felt weightless—emptied out, scrubbed raw, aware of nothing but the slow rhythm of breath beside him and the thin line of light creeping under the door.

He thought of the midnight kiss with Tyler, Eli’s glance earlier. His hand drifted to the quarter still in his pocket, pressed flat against his thigh. He left it there. He settled on his side, and reached out his hand slowly. Tyler’s fingers were there and they locked pinkies.

When sleep finally came, it was dreamless.

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

Except nothing felt steady anymore. Not after Eli. The line between ordinary and impossible had blurred, and Ethan walked around with the secret buzzing in his chest like a trapped hornet.

The library fluorescents hummed above the long table where six pledges slumped with notebooks and half-dead pens. Ethan tried to focus on his Biology diagrams, the Krebs Cycle this time, but the lines blurred. His pen drifted into loops and spirals that turned into accidental initials.

Connor leaned so close their arms touched. “You’re out of it, Harris,” he whispered, smirking.

Ethan shook himself. “What?”

“Self-brain last night?” Connor said with a conspiratorial grin.

Marco groaned. “Jesus, Connor, not everything’s about your dick.”

Teddy snorted, socks off, big toe poking through a hole. “He’s just mad he can’t go five minutes without jerking it.”

Connor raised his hands in mock surrender, but his knee kept bouncing against Ethan’s. Ethan tried to shift, but there was nowhere to go. Six bodies jammed together in one row, elbows touching, knees bumping, breath sour with cigarette smoke.

“Anyway,” Connor pressed on, “you see who Travis went upstairs with last night? Anne, that Kingston brunette—one of Catherine’s crew.”

Teddy rolled his eyes. “She went upstairs with Luke two weeks ago. Trav’s just mopping up.”

Marco smirked, chewing his pen cap. “She’s been upstairs with half the house. Don’t act like you wouldn’t.”

Connor leaned back, grinning. “I heard she’s the type to narrate while she’s blowing you. Like Dick Vitale giving a play-by-play.”

Laughter shook the table. Teddy clapped his hand over his mouth, shoulders shaking. Ethan kept his eyes fixed on his notes, barely registering who Anne was. But the others lived for it.

Connor jabbed Ethan’s ribs suddenly. “Bet Harris has a crush on Anne.”

Ethan’s stomach flipped, but he managed a weak laugh. The others roared, convinced they’d found his secret.

It was cover. They didn’t see him watching Eli.

That Thursday night Ethan carried a sack of McDonald’s up to the house, grease bleeding through the paper. The place was already alive: music thumping, girls laughing too loudly, brothers barking orders.

The hallway upstairs was a crush of bodies. Doors half-open, smoke curling out, pledges sprawled on the floor in undershirts, shoulders pressed, feet tangled. Someone snored against a doorframe, shoes still on.

Jason’s room stood cracked. Inside, Jason leaned forward at his desk, hand brushing past Tyler’s side. Tyler stood shirtless, towel slung around his neck, posture taut. Jason’s arm lingered just long enough to mean something before he pulled back. Tyler didn’t move. Their eyes met, unreadable, and then the door closed.

Ethan kept walking, pulse in his throat.

At the far end, Travis bellowed at a video game, sweat dripping down his chest. Luke laughed so hard he toppled backward, legs tangled with pledges wedged together on the couch. One sprawled with his head in another’s lap, too tired or too drunk to care. Limbs crossed, breath hot, the whole scene soaked in sweat and beer.

This was what passed for normal the weekend before Thanksgiving, the football games over, the bands done for the semester. The row still thrummed, but the parties moved upstairs.

Friday night, Connor sat cross-legged on the kitchen counter, pizza box balanced on his lap. “We’re basically unpaid butlers,” he announced, waving a crust like a pointer.

“Speak for yourself,” Teddy said through a mouthful, grease shining on his lip. “I’m a Zen master of cleaning toilets.”

“Jersey guys don’t clean,” Marco added, leaning against the fridge. “We supervise.”

They cracked up, voices bouncing off tile. Empty beer cans rattled on the counter when Connor stomped his heel for emphasis.

“Don’t drift off like that in lineup, Harris,” Connor jabbed Ethan in the ribs with the crust. “Clay will have you puking into a trash can before you can blink.”

“You’ve probably got it worse,” Teddy said, pointing his slice at Ethan. “Harris has a thing for that Kingston brunette, right? Catherine’s friend.”

Ethan froze for half a second, then managed a weak laugh. Connor whooped, convinced he was right. “Knew it! That faraway look when she’s around—always the girls that get you.”

They all howled. Ethan let them. Better they thought it was Anne. It was safer that way.

As he was making the rounds upstairs the bathroom door banged open and the smell hit first: bleach mixed with something sour. A brother sat on the toilet in the stall with no door, pants around his ankles, flipping through a dog-eared Barely Legal. There were stacks of old magazines balanced on the back of the tank — Perfect 10, Maxim, covers curling from steam. Ethan kept his eyes forward and headed to the sink. Another guy stood there shirtless, razor buzzing as he trimmed hair at the porcelain. Dark stubble speckled the basin. He caught Ethan’s eye in the cracked mirror. “Big date tonight. Gotta stay groomed. Don’t look so shocked.”

Steam poured out of the shower room. Two brothers stumbled out wrapped in towels, one snapping the other’s ass hard enough to echo. Both laughed like it was nothing.

Nobody flinched. Nobody questioned it.

It was frat-normal. Absurd. And Ethan couldn’t stop the hum under his skin.

Back in the Living Room, Catherine perched on Eli’s lap like she owned him, head tipped back in laughter, pearls flashing under the light. Eli leaned into her, mask in place, cigarette perfect between his fingers.

“…swear she told me to choke her harder,” one bragged, laughing at his own story.

Catherine swatted Eli’s arm. “Listen to them,” she said, voice carrying. “God, boys are disgusting.”

The group roared. Eli grinned wider, but when his eyes flicked across the room, they landed on Ethan. Just for a second. The corner of his mouth twitched like he’d forgotten to hold it steady.

Eli grinned wider, but when his eyes flicked across the room, they landed on Ethan.

Ethan dropped his gaze, pulse quickening.

Later, after Catherine announced that the boys were “too sketchy” and led her crew to see what was going on at the other houses, Eli quietly drew Ethan upstairs.

The door clicked shut. Eli pressed Ethan back against the desk, mouth urgent. They had a rhythm now, each knowing how to get the other’s heart racing. Eli pulled Ethan over to the bed, pushed him down hard and began taking his clothes off. In between removing his own. Ethan still couldn’t help to stare. It was fast, but sweet.

Afterward, they lay side by side, breath ragged. Eli stared at the ceiling, smoke drifting from his hand.

Ethan turned to face him, studying his profile while Eli played with the lighter. He started, but hesitated before finally speaking. “Can I ask you something?”

Eli’s jaw tightened. “Let’s not do this.”

A beat. “Go ahead.”

“What’s going on with Catherine?” Ethan whispered. “What does it mean?”

Eli tapped ash into the tray, eyes still fixed upward. “It doesn’t. Not really. It’s… what they expect. My parents. Her family. Everyone.”

Ethan’s chest ached. “Doesn’t it get exhausting?”

Eli laughed once, bitter and small. “All the fucking time.” He finally turned his head, but only halfway. “You don’t get it. I graduate in May. I’ve got interviews, family watching. I can’t—” He stopped, shaking his head. “Not here. Not now.”

Ethan’s voice thinned. “But what if—”

Eli cut him off quickly, too quickly. “Don’t.” Then softer, almost pleading:

“Don’t make this harder. Just…stay. Like this. Please”

They lay quietly, the distance between Eli’s public mask and private truth hanging painfully in the air, heavy with unspoken words and possibilities they both knew were likely unreachable.

When Ethan finally slipped out, pulse still hammering, he nearly collided with Tyler in the hall. Tyler stood damp from the showers, towel hanging around his neck. Their shoulders grazed, igniting a spark of panic in Ethan’s chest. Tyler’s eyes lingered, filled with cautious curiosity and a flash of recognition Ethan couldn’t ignore.

They both froze, caught in the awareness that something was dangerously close to surfacing, yet neither could risk speaking. Ethan wanted to say something, anything to dispel the tension, but fear clamped his throat shut. Tyler’s jaw tightened, silently acknowledging their shared discomfort. After a tense moment, Tyler looked away first and moved past, leaving Ethan rooted in the hallway, heart racing.

Back in McClintock, Ethan lay stiff, staring at the ceiling fan, replaying Catherine’s laugh, Eli’s cigarette smile, Tyler’s loaded glance.

He slipped a hand around the quarter and held it until the edge bit painfully into his palm.

Ethan sat up slowly, chest aching with contradiction. For a moment he believed Eli wanted it, for a moment he believed he didn’t. But beneath the masks and the fear, one thing was certain—Eli hadn’t been pretending.

The house roared faintly across the quad. Doors slammed, laughter carried through the night. Somewhere someone shouted a name that wasn’t his.

Ethan pressed the quarter deeper into his skin. He didn’t whisper this time; he just knew it. Whatever came next, it had meant something.

Want to know what Tyler and Jason were up to?

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

If you’re paid, you can dive in now

If you’re free, catch up here first:

Also from Caleb Reed

What to do next

• Paid readers → jump into Chapter XI now

• Free readers → binge the chapters and essays above so you’re ready when Fallout drops tomorrow

  Not sure which you are? Redeem your free post and try it out today

The house sounded different at night. Not quiet, never quiet, but tuned. A stair creaked like a note played on purpose. Pipes ticked in the walls. Somewhere a stereo murmured the tail end of a mixtape, the drum fill riding out into tape hiss. The upstairs hall held the day’s heat and someone’s spilled cologne, and the carpet had a way of swallowing footsteps if you knew where to place them.

Ethan did. He placed them carefully, eyes on the thin bar of amber at the base of Eli’s door. He stood there longer than necessary, one palm flat to the panel, feeling the minute vibration of the box fan beyond. Then he knocked once, soft.

The latch turned. A slice of lamplight cut his shoes. Eli’s face appeared in the crack, a fingertip raised. “Hey,” he said, almost a breath, and the door swung just wide enough for Ethan to slip through.

It was the same room as the first time and not. Same fan rattling in the window. Same curve of light across the desk, a stack of folded shirts that never seemed to shift. But there was a new dent in the pillow and an ashtray perched on a Norton anthology, and Eli himself was looser, barefoot, shirtless in old gym shorts, the cocky set of his shoulders replaced by something that looked like relief.

“You took your time tonight,” Eli said, not accusing, not anything at all. He spoke over his shoulder as he crossed to twist the blinds closed.

“I had to get past Clay’s patrol.” Ethan nodded toward the hall. “Clipboard rounds.”

Eli’s grin flashed. “I almost forgot.” He flicked the lamp a notch lower. “You good?”

Ethan nodded as he leaned against the door until it shut, until the latch clicked the room into a sealed world. The week slipped off like a jacket. He crossed the two steps that were always two steps and put his forehead to Eli’s cheekbone, a touch that became a hug, then Eli turned his head and the point of contact became a kiss, hard, testing, the kind that asked, You here? and answered itself: I am.

They weren’t clumsy this time, except on purpose, like a joke they were in on together. Ethan’s fingertips trailed the line of hair at Eli’s sternum and Eli swatted at his wrist and said something low about cold hands, and then there was nothing to say. Shirts traveled the same arc as before, a careful toss toward the chair no one ever sat in. The fan kept its steady drone. When Ethan’s knee hit the mattress edge, Eli’s palm found the back of his neck and held, not possessive, not gentle. Familiar.

As Eli pinned him to the mattress, Ethan didn’t try to name the rush. He let it fill him. The week had been an unspooling of errands and cheap wine and the wet-throated bark of orders that rattled his bones; this was narrowing, the way the eye tightens to a single star. He let himself memorize the domestic smallness of it—the nick in Eli’s lamp shade, the faint detergent clean of the sheets, the cigarette resting in the ashtray sending up a ribbon of smoke without being smoked. He had the sudden absurd thought that if he cataloged enough of these details, the night couldn’t evaporate in the morning.

When Eli shifted, the mattress talked. When he laughed, it was quiet, a shape in his throat more than a sound. He kissed like he was teaching and learning at once. Ethan laughed once too—nervous, happy, both—and Eli hushed him by running a thumb across his lip. “Don’t wake the dead,” he murmured, then contradicted himself with a kiss that would have woken anyone attuned to it.

Reaching into the nightstand, Ethan said with a crooked grin, “I’ll try not to, but I can’t promise.” Soon Ethan was on his stomach, Eli slowly working him open Patient and sure.

“Fuck me,” Ethan whispered, no longer able to wait. Eli complied, pulling Ethan’s up by the waist slightly as he pushed inside. Ethan gasped then he felt Eli’s weight on top of him, almost suffocating as Eli began to move in and out. Arms wrapped tightly around Ethan’s chest, using his shoulders for leverage. Ethan groaned as he buried his face into the pillow, but he didn’t want it any other way.

They paused only when the room asked them to—when the house shifted, when a door shut down the hall and muffled laughter smothered into private sound. Eli’s eyes flicked to the knob. Ethan felt the flick like a static snap and watched the moment something armored slid back into place behind Eli’s face and then, just as quickly, slid away again.

After, they lay angled in the soft heat, the fan moving the smoke in lazy ellipses. Eli propped on an elbow, Ethan flat on his back counting the slow revolution of blades and the beat at his own throat. A car door slammed out on the Row. The house answered in muffled whoops, as if acknowledging a point in a game.

“Don’t—” Eli started, then stopped, thumb on Ethan’s jaw. “Just don’t tell anybody.”

“I won’t,” Ethan said, because he couldn’t imagine telling anyone and also because the rule made it feel more real. A thing you kept was a thing you had.

Eli reached past him without looking and found the cigarette, drew once, then let the ember glow hang between them. He offered it with two fingers; Ethan took it, tasted the ash of Eli’s mouth on the filter, and balanced the butt in the ashtray again without cracking the quiet.

“Can you spend the night?” Eli asked, voice softer now.

“What about Mark?” Ethan whispered.

“He’s dead to the world right now, trust me,” Eli said a little too cockily.

“Don’t get used to this,” Eli added, too quickly, like he’d practiced the line.

“I already am,” Ethan admitted, before he could stop himself. He felt the flinch and knew better next time.

They slept for a few hours or they didn’t. Time went shallow. When the thin blue of morning came up behind the blinds, Ethan woke to the soft rasp of laces pulled tight. Eli’s hair was damp, combed. He tied each shoe like he was cinching himself into armor, pulling until the leather creaked. His expression was already smoothing to nothing, the mask sliding on piece by piece. Ethan thought it was like watching a door slam shut in slow motion.

“You should head out,” Eli said. His voice sounded normal, practiced, like asking for toothpaste.

Ethan nodded, trying to get used to this. He found his shirt by touch. He left his voice on the pillow and took his feet to the door. Eli opened it just enough to cut a wedge into the hall, then stood there until Ethan stepped past him, both of them holding the small, ridiculous fiction that the move was casual.

The hallway smelled like spilled beer and Pine-Sol—the concentrated kind pledges used before alumni came to town. Closed doors held back islands of private weather. From one came a scratch of chairs against the floor, from another the soft pop of a lighter and a cough that wanted to be a laugh. The composite at the far end of the corridor had a cracked glass pane someone kept forgetting to replace. Ethan took the stairs on the tread that didn’t squeak, because he knew it now.

Back in McClintock, the radiator sang its thin winter note. Mark snored on his back, one arm flung over his eyes. Ethan stood at the window for a few breaths, watching the yellow square of the Row fade into day, then lay on his own mattress and stared at the ceiling. He could still taste smoke. He held the quarter in his pocket until the sharp edge left a crescent in his palm.

Weeks slipped forward like this. Study hall under fluorescent lights. Line-ups without warning. Endless errands at impossible hours.

One Thursday evening Ethan sat at the long table under buzzing tubes, copying notes he didn’t understand because his eyes kept going soft-focus and remaking letters into shapes. Connor nudged him.

“You’re out of it,” Connor whispered. “You do a self-brain last night?”

“A what?”

“Never mind.” Connor grinned and closed one eye in a conspiratorial way he’d picked up from somewhere. But the grin slipped a half-second too late. “You hear who got waved upstairs?”

“Do I want to?”

“Probably not. Tyler, for one. Trav’s room. Then later Jason’s. He’s everywhere at once, that one.”

Ethan stared at the mitochondrion sketch in his book until it doubled. “Why do you care where Tyler goes?”

“Because some of us have goals,” Connor said, quieter now. “And one of mine is to know what the hell happens behind those doors.”

Ethan didn’t say, I know one door. He didn’t say anything at all. He held the quarter in his pocket and imagined it was warm because of meaning and not because of his palm.

Back at the house, instead of the regular Thursday lineup, Clay ran a carousel of humiliation conducted to the tempo of his clipboard taps. This was the last home football game of the season, the final party weekend before Hell Week and Thanksgiving. The brothers wanted the house spotless.

Bleach stung eyes, and the long mops only moved the dirt from one end of the hall to the other. Ethan got yelled at for hanging the composites in the wrong order and again for using the wrong coolers. He got sent to fetch a bag of ice and returned with the wrong kind. He moved through it all submerged, taking the hits like weather, as if a storm could be offended by rain.

“Head on straight, Harris,” Clay barked, blocking his path with the board. “You’re here to serve, not daydream.”

Ethan nodded, eyes down. A line of water had worked under the tongue of Clay’s boot and left a crescent dark mark. Easier to focus on that than the fact that he almost said Yes, sir, slipping onto an old autopilot.

By nine the next night, the house was a hive again. A Waverly pair with glossy ponytails appeared like they’d been conjured, laughing too loudly at something Luke said. The Kingston crew swept in, but Catherine was absent. Eli leaned against the doorframe with two hometown brothers, laughing harder than the jokes earned.

From the sidewalk, Ethan watched for the flicker that meant recognition, half a second too long on his face. He saw nothing. Then he did: a glance so clean it could have been a blink, then gone.

Mark slid up beside him. “The circus is back,” he said. “You ever notice we do the same night in a thousand little variations?”

“Maybe that’s what makes it a tradition,” Ethan said, wanting to ask about Catherine but deciding to let it go.

“Maybe that’s what makes it jail,” Mark answered, and they both laughed, too pleased with themselves to stop.

Upstairs the order of the house became a map if you knew how to read it. Travis’s door meant volume and inertia: you went there to be swallowed by noise. Luke’s door was currency—his laugh a passport, his couch a throne. Colton’s door was sanctuary, always closed, a church that only opened to insiders. Jason’s stayed ajar just enough to suggest anything could happen; Tyler and Marco drifted in and out because they were decoration the house liked to show off. Connor hovered outside all of them, laughing too loud, wanting in. Clay belonged nowhere except the chapter room, where rules gave him oxygen. Ethan walked the hall like a cartographer, noting which doors were never meant for him.

Carrying a Taco Bell order, he passed Jason’s door and saw it ajar a clean inch. Tyler stood with his back to the hall, towel over one shoulder like the pretense of a shower had been rehearsed. Jason’s voice was low, amused; he reached past Tyler for something on his desk and his forearm brushed Tyler’s waist in a way that looked like a mistake made on purpose. Tyler didn’t move away. The door cut the scene off as simply as a card trick.

“Keep it moving, pledge,” Clay said behind him without looking up from his clipboard.

“Yes sir,” Ethan said this time, because it was easier, because the word fit the space.

He kept the picture in a pocket of his mind where it wouldn’t touch anything else. Not scandal, not proof, not even surprise—just another door in a house of doors, another invitation to a club that had its own rules.

Later, when the hallway thinned and the band downstairs knocked off for a smoke break, Ethan sat on the stairs to the second floor and pretended to mend a torn banner. He wasn’t waiting. That’s what he told himself.

Eli’s steps on the first landing came like they always did: light, even. He didn’t look at Ethan until he was even with him, and then he paused only long enough to scuff the toe of Ethan’s shoe with his own.

“You coming?” Eli asked it without question. Ethan was already moving.

This time, Ethan didn’t wait to knock. He pushed into Eli’s room with the urgency of someone who knew the path. Eli froze for a heartbeat, then smirked, half-pleased, half-annoyed at the breach of ritual, and tugged him the rest of the way in.

Inside the air felt cooler. Eli shut the door with his heel and leaned his head against the wood for a second, eyes closed, like he was bracing. Then the breath he let out was a laugh he didn’t make anywhere else.

“You look like you’re about to bolt,” he said. He crossed the room and sat on the edge of the bed, half-daring Ethan to stay.

“I’m here,” Ethan said, steadier than he felt. He wasn’t sure when the fear had shifted from being caught to not being invited.

This time there was less sweetness and more heat. Eli moved fast, impatient, like he’d been holding his breath all day and finally let himself exhale. Ethan went with him, grateful, then caught off guard by how quickly Eli rolled away, how quickly he reached for the cigarette like it was the only way to end a thought.

“You good?” Eli asked after a while, a little too late to be only about what had just happened.

“Yeah,” Ethan said.

“Don’t get soft on me.” Eli said it like a joke, like locker room talk, like any deflection that kept a person from naming what they feel. He didn’t look over.

“Duly Noted,” Ethan said, and the word lodged like a seed.

They didn’t talk long. The house made its little night music on the other side of the door. The fan remembered to rattle. When a knock came, both of them went still. The knock wasn’t for them; a voice down the hall called someone else’s name and doors opened and shut in a choreography the house could have done with the lights off.

“Go,” Eli said at last, soft, almost apologetic. “Practice.”

“Practice for what?”

“For not being an idiot.” He smiled in a way that asked forgiveness for the line as soon as he said it.

Back in the dorm, Mark sprawled with his mouth open, the fan in their window clicking where the blade hit something it wasn’t supposed to. Ethan lay down and stared into the dark until the ceiling fan’s lazy revolution matched his pulse. He thought of the doors he’d passed and the worlds they hid. Travis’, full of laughter that had already curdled by the time it reached the hall. Luke’s, a low run of voices that could talk you off a ledge if you were the right person. Jason’s, closed now. Eli’s, where the lamp shade with the nick threw an oval of light that would be there when the room was empty, and when it wasn’t.

He knew the secret shouldn’t feel like belonging, but it did. He told himself it meant something because if it didn’t then he was just another boy walking a hall of closed doors with his hands in his pockets, pretending he didn’t want to knock.

The month turned on itself. Pledges lined up with books outstretched until their shoulders burned. The dorm phone rang at 1:11 a.m., 2:22 a.m., 3:33 a.m., because Clay had discovered a new joy in patterns. Ethan got sent for food he didn’t eat and cigarettes he didn’t smoke. He learned the pharmacy’s twenty-four-hour window.

He made mistakes too. Small ones. He knocked a tray of cups over because he was looking at the stairs. He forgot a brother’s girlfriend’s name because he was running through the steps it took to get to Eli’s door without brushing the wall and leaving a scuff Clay would notice.

Jason caught him once, hand closing around his elbow just as the stack of plates he’d fumbled began to tip. “Breathe,” Jason said, his voice meant for a different kind of crisis. “No one’s timing you.”

“Clay is,” Ethan said before he could stop himself.

Jason’s mouth twitched. “Clay can’t add.”

Ethan let himself laugh.

On the quad, the daytime life stayed staged. Eli in sunglasses he didn’t need, standing with Travis and Luke and a junior Ethan didn’t know, laughing a little harder than the joke earned. Ethan felt anger at the performance, and the wicked comfort of knowing the backstage.

The mornings never softened. Eli always up first, bent over his shoes, laces cinched so tight the leather groaned, face scrubbed raw into the day’s mask. “You should go,” he’d say without apology now, as if doing Ethan a favor.

One morning Ethan lingered, hand on the knob. “Does it mean anything?” he asked, too even, too brave.

Eli blinked once...

Want to know what Tyler and Jason were up to?

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

“I think this is the first time we’ve talked since Homecoming.” Mark said as he passed the bowl to Ethan.

“Speaking of, you notice Catherine hanging around the house that night?” Mark asked, smoke curling toward the ceiling. “What did you think of her and her Kingston Crew?”

Ethan hesitated. “Yeah, I saw them. They seemed cool I guess, though Eli did seem to act weird around her.”

“Eli’s kryptonite,” Mark laughed. “They’ve been doing this dance since high school. I’m glad you saw it too. She’ll keep him spinning all year, and he’ll let her.”

Ethan didn't answer. He stared at the ceiling, listening to the fan, trying not to picture her laugh at Eli’s shoulder. Catherine wasn’t just another girl—she seemed to represent everything Eli was supposed to want, everything Ethan felt he couldn’t compete with. Soon Mark was snoring and his mind drifted to Tyler. He tried to bring up the last night of the road trip, but Tyler just shrugged him off. “Relax man, it’s cool.” being the extent of the conversation. Tyler was comfortable in his own skin, cuddling with another guy didn’t make him gay. Eli on the other hand, he was beginning to feel sorry for.

By Friday, the rhythm shifted back into routine. For once Ethan was actually looking forward to the weekend and hanging out at the house. The last two weeks had been a whirlwhind, Mark being the only pledge brother he had had time to compare notes with after the road trip. That afternoon, Ethan showered, shaved, and put on a new button-down and fleece before reporting to the house. Pledge duties were the same, but some brothers had decamped to see their girlfriends. Other than snagging beers and doling out cigarettes, it wasn’t too bad.

It wasn’t a football weekend. Campus felt quiet, half-asleep. By nightfall, Delta Chi still managed to fill with noise—music echoing down the halls, girls drifting in from Waverly and Kingston—but by midnight the crowd had thinned. Brothers disappeared upstairs with girlfriends, doors closing behind them.

Ethan was on his way out when Eli’s voice stopped him. Eli leaned against the wall, cigarette in hand, eyes catching the low light. Ethan hesitated by the door, uncertainty flickering through him. His pulse quickened as he caught Eli’s gaze, sensing something had shifted between them.

“Hang back.”

Without another word, he tipped his head toward the stairs. Ethan followed.

They passed closed doors and muffled laughter. Eli’s room waited at the end of the hall: dim lamplight, the hum of his fan, the faint smell of his cologne or whatever it was he used. Mark must use it too, he could catch a whiff every now and then, but not like Eli.

Conversation began tentatively—about classes, about family, about why Eli had walked away from lacrosse. Finally to Catherine, Eli admitting he hadn’t been as clear with the boundary as he told Mark.

“I just don’t want to be who everyone expects,” Eli admitted, voice quieter than Ethan had ever heard it.

“I get that,” Ethan said. “Feels like everything is kind of mapped out for you, but no one bothered to ask you if you wanted it.”

Eli glanced at him, the corner of his mouth twitching. “Me too.”

The space between them collapsed. Fingers brushed, a kiss followed, hesitant at first, then insistent. The weight of weeks pressed into it. The kiss deepened until Ethan felt dizzy, his nostrils filled with Eli’s smell, beer, and cigarettes. Eli’s hand slid behind his neck, pulling him closer, anchoring him. Ethan fumbled at first, nervous, until Eli slowed the pace, guiding without words.

Clothes gave way piece by piece—shirts tugged overhead, jeans unbuttoned with fumbling hands. They laughed when Ethan yanked off Eli’s belt in one swift motion, twirling it above his head like a lasso, the sound swallowed quickly in another kiss.

Ethan’s thoughts flickered: disbelief, awe, fear, then hunger. He couldn’t take it all in—only the heat, the pressure, the sense of being wanted. Eli alternated between control and softness, every move deliberate.

Ethan was surprised by how much he liked giving up control, letting someone else lead. Eli wasn’t rough, but he moved with a confidence that left Ethan breathless. After pinning him down and kissing him into the pillows, Eli stood, slipped off his boxers, and tossed them at Ethan’s face. Ethan shoved them aside, heart hammering, breath catching as he stared.

It was almost more than he could bear. He’d pictured Eli a thousand times since that first night, but the reality undid him. His body was perfect—not Tyler’s Abercrombie symmetry, but more rugged, more real. Muscle under soft blonde hair that trailed down his stomach to a thick, unkempt bush. His cock jutted upward, hard, straining against skin, glistening at the tip. Ethan wanted it—wanted to taste the bead of precum waiting there.

Before he could speak, Eli stripped Ethan’s boxers away, baring him before he had a chance to be self conscious. “Relax,” Eli murmured. “I won’t hurt you.” He lay down beside him, stroking his cock slowly, cupping his balls, then pulled him into another kiss. Hands gripped his ass, grinding them together until he gasped.

Ethan finally let himself go, exploring Eli’s chest. He threaded his fingers through the hair, buried his face in it, breathed him in. He wanted all of him, had dreamed of it for weeks. Surprising himself, Ethan went for Eli’s cock, taking it in deeper than intended, breath hitching as he pressed into Eli’s scent, the intimacy overwhelming him.

Eli hesitated, eyes softer than Ethan had ever seen. For a long second he didn’t say anything, just traced a finger along Ethan’s jaw like he was memorizing it.

“I’ve never done this all the way,” he said quietly. “Not with someone I actually cared about.”

The words landed heavier than any kiss. Ethan’s throat tightened.

“Do you trust me?” Eli asked then, and this time Ethan didn’t hesitate.

The question startled Ethan. But beneath his hesitation, he realized he truly did trust Eli—more than he’d expected, more than he trusted himself.

“Yes,” Ethan managed. That was all Eli needed before he slid down and wrapped his mouth around Ethan’s cock.

Ethan eased back, surrendering. Eli’s tongue traced his length, then moved lower, teasing his balls. They both laughed when he tried, unsuccessfully, to take both into his mouth at once. Shaking his head, Eli kept going, his tongue circling lower until Ethan stiffened, instinct telling him to pull away. But nothing had ever felt like this. Slowly, he relaxed.

Eli reached into the nightstand and pulled out a condom and a bottle of lube.

“Wait—what are you doing?” Ethan asked, the spell breaking for a second.

“I promise I won’t hurt you. Lay back down.”

Ethan obeyed, closing his eyes as Eli’s tongue worked him open, then one finger, then two. Pain gave way to pressure. Pressure to need. Ethan pushed back on Eli’s hand, wanting more.

“Yeah, I think you’re ready,” Eli said with a crooked smile.

Before Ethan could answer, Eli lifted his legs onto his shoulders. “I want it,” Ethan finally managed to whisper.

Eli pressed the tip against him, circling, teasing. “You like that?” he breathed.

“Keep going,” Ethan blurted, louder than he meant.

He tried to steady his breathing as Eli pushed inside, inch by inch, until the air left his lungs in a rush. It was too much and not enough. He wanted all of it. When Eli bottomed out, the stretch turned into a dizzy rush of heat that left his vision swimming.

Eli began to move, slow at first, then harder. Ethan tried to kiss him but broke off with a cry when Eli found his prostate. He grabbed a pillow, muffling his voice, unable to stay quiet.

“I’m gonna cum,” he gasped.

“That’s the point. Just breathe. Tell me if I hurt you,” Eli whispered, thrusting harder.

Ethan couldn’t form words. His knees trembled, his body betraying him. The orgasm tore through him deeper than he’d ever felt, leaving him shaking, spilling hot across his stomach and chest.

He felt Eli tense above him, cock throbbing inside, then a final thrust, a grunt, and heat spilling into him, his body clenching around it.

After, they collapsed together, breath ragged, the sheets sticky with Ethan’s release, skin pressed close, joined by the evidence of what they’d made.

They lay tangled, skin cooling, the box fan stirring smoke from a fresh cigarette. Eli lit it, took a drag, and passed it to Ethan. The glow pulsed in the dark. As their breathing steadied, Ethan caught Eli’s eyes drifting briefly toward the window, an unreadable expression crossing his face before he turned back and kissed Ethan’s forehead.

“You ever feel like you don’t belong anywhere?” Eli asked.

“All the time.”

“Me too.”

The words landed heavier than any kiss. They talked quietly—half confessions, half small talk—stretching the night as if it could last forever. For the first time since arriving at Westmore, Ethan felt steady. Whole. Yet somewhere in the back of his mind, Catherine lingered. He wondered if Eli would ever let her see this version of himself, or if what they’d shared was a secret he alone would carry. Finally he drifted off to sleep, Eli’s arm around him, holding him close.

Pale light cut through the blinds when Ethan woke. The sheets beside him were already cold. Eli stood by the desk, damp hair, lacing his shoes, the mask sliding back onto his face piece by piece.

He looked at the door, then back at Ethan. “If Clay or any of the brothers see you leaving my room, it won’t just be you who gets destroyed. Please—go before anyone notices.”

His voice wasn’t sharp. It was careful. Protective.

Ethan slipped past him into the hall, the knot in his chest heavy but not empty. Whatever else Eli wanted to pretend, Ethan knew it hadn’t been nothing.

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

The week after Homecoming the orders came. Forty-eight hours. Disposable cameras issued to each pledge. Lists of stops clipped to cardboard. Clay stood in front of the Annex, tapping his pen like a drill sergeant, brothers howling behind him.

“You guys are going on a little scavenger hunt, a little trip around the Commonwealth. And you better hit every fucking stop. Bring back proof or it didn’t happen,” he barked. “Film developed and back here by noon Sunday, double prints.”

The phrase itself felt archaic—nobody outside drugstore counters even used it anymore—but everyone knew what it meant. Two sets of every humiliation: one for the scrapbook, one for the box they’d drag out at reunions.

Ethan’s stomach sank. He was already worn thin from line-ups and chores, the endless pressure of remembering names and histories, the hazing masked as “tradition.” The whole last week had been a blur, he was still raw from Homecoming. Now came this—the capstone of their first semester, a forced pilgrimage across Virginia.

They decided to squeeze into one car, Ethan’s old Cherokee. Six of them jammed in: Ethan, Connor, Teddy, Marco, Mark, and Tyler. Connor looked smug: “Lucky you. I know the territory.” Born and raised in Richmond, he’d clearly been waiting for this. Marco cracked a joke about how many times they’d get lost. Teddy just sighed, shifting his tie. Mark groaned about the smoke before the first mile was done. Tyler offered to drive and slid the keys into the ignition like he’d been expecting it all along, calm, steady.

They pulled out just after dinner Friday, coats and ties—what Clay referred to as their “uniform” for the weekend—already rumpled. The autumn air was sharp, headlights bouncing off dark trees as the highway swallowed them whole. The first stretch was all nervous energy—Connor shouting over the Discman, Marco digging through his CD binder, Teddy passing a joint across the back seat, Mark grumbling about the windows, Ethan staring out the window and catching Tyler’s eye in the rearview mirror.

They reached D.C. after midnight, staggering into a shitty motel off New York Avenue. The clerk didn’t even look up as they shuffled to the counter, still in ties. “One room or two?” he asked, flat as if he’d said it a thousand times. Tyler smirked. “One’s good.”

Ethan’s face burned, wondering who he might have to share a bed with.

They crammed into doubles, snoring, coughing, the stench of smoke and sweat filling the air. Ethan lay awake on the sunken mattress, listening to Tyler’s soft snore next to him. His mind spun: Eli, Catherine, the kiss, the quarter he kept as his talisman. Eli had become the imagined reward through every hazing, and now he felt further away than ever. Tyler shifted, now facing him, his arm brushing against Ethan’s. Though Ethan’s first instinct was to freeze, afraid one of the others would notice, he let himself drift into the warmth and finally fell asleep.

Dawn came gray and wet. They dragged themselves across the Mall, breath puffing in the cold. Tourists eyed them curiously as they posed at the Washington Monument, Lincoln Memorial, Arlington Bridge. Marco made rabbit ears behind Teddy’s head. Connor snapped, “We need proof, not art.” Ethan forced smiles for the cameras, dreading the day the film would be developed.

Tyler, being from Woodbridge, knew enough to steer them to the city. After a quick snap in front of the White House, they headed to Georgetown.

Marco shrugged. “We can take the Metro.”

The rest of the group erupted into laughter. “There’s no Metro stop in Georgetown,” Connor finally said.

Ethan drove, narrow streets reminding him of Charleston. They found M Street and, by sheer dumb luck, a place to park.

“Let’s see,” Tyler said, ticking off the list. “St. Elmo’s Bar, the *Exorcist* stairs, JFK’s house, us on the towpath…”

“Hold up,” Mark interrupted. “Does anyone actually know where these are?”

The Exorcist Stairs were easy enough, and everyone there was snapping pictures. After several people laughed in their faces, another student clued them in.

“The bar in the movie is based on The Tombs. There is no St. Elmo’s Bar—the sign was just an exterior shot on a set. And JFK? He lived all over Georgetown. Pick a house.”

They played along, grabbed a shot in front of The Tombs, posed at one of the Kennedy houses on N Street, and got back on the road.

By Saturday afternoon they were on 81, deep in the Valley. Lexington loomed—a place Ethan’s mother would’ve called “historic” with reverence. Washington & Lee’s campus sprawled with white columns and manicured lawns. Tyler pulled the Jeep into a lot and they set to make a plan. The list called for Lee Chapel, a photo in front of Lee’s tomb, Traveller’s remains. Other groups of pledges were already there, lined up like tourists.

Connor saluted like an idiot in front of the crypt, Marco pantomimed a musket, Teddy just stood stiff. The General lying in repose behind them. The flash popped, cementing the absurdity. They returned the favor for the next group and headed out.

At VMI they posed outside the barracks, cadets in gray moving past without glancing. Ethan felt the weight of the place—stone, discipline, the smell of polish—and thought how foreign it felt.

They found the fraternity “rock,” a granite monument outside headquarters. Clay had underlined it on the list. “Tradition.” They crouched awkwardly, arms draped over it like tourists. Ethan crouched too, heart sinking. Just a rock. Another piece of invented ritual.

Charlottesville gave them an hour to breathe. They parked on the Lawn at UVA, strolled past red brick and the Rotunda, tried to look casual as Marco lit a cigarette. They ducked into a diner, split milkshakes, snapped photos with tired waitresses. It felt almost normal—students milling, Saturday buzz in the air. Ethan almost forgot he was on display.

The drive east stretched long. Arguments over music flared. Connor swore by Phish, Marco by Wu-Tang, Teddy by classic rock. Tyler just shrugged. Ethan finally let his tape play—Counting Crows bleeding into Nirvana, then Smashing Pumpkins. Nobody mocked him. Connor even hummed along. For once, he felt part of it.

At one gas stop, Ethan and Tyler ended up side by side again at the counter, brushing hands as they grabbed sodas. Tyler didn’t move his away for a moment longer than necessary. Ethan’s stomach lurched.

By dusk they hit Short Pump. Connor straightened in the passenger seat, cigarette dangling, proud on home turf. “Welcome to my kingdom.”

“You mean Goochland. I thought you were from Midlothian,” Teddy jabbed. Connor blushed. Mark snorted, and the car cracked up.

Connor merged onto Monument Avenue and followed it toward downtown. Bronze riders loomed above the wide lawns, shadows sharp under the lamps.

“Second highest murder rate in the country,” Connor said proudly, as if it belonged to him. “Tim Kaine says he’ll fix it. The Fan’s fine—just don’t go past Boulevard after dark.”

The list called for The Arthur Ashe Jr. monument. It had just been installed, the city still raw from the fight over it. “Caused a huge uproar from the minute they proposed it,” Connor said. Marco mimed a serve. Teddy stared at his shoes. The flash went off. Ethan held his smile, then let it drop. It wasn’t an accident. The brothers picked it because it was raw. Pose in front of Lee’s tomb, then here. The first monument constructed in almost 70 years, and not to a Confederate general, but to a Black man, a professional tennis player. The quiet joke was the point.

They continued up Monument, passing Jeb Stuart, until Franklin and the Jefferson Hotel. Tyler straddled the bronze gator under the portico, grinning for the camera. The flash went off, tourists gawking, valets shaking their heads. Ethan froze. The Jefferson wasn’t just another stop. It was the only hotel his grandmother would stay in when she came to Richmond. Watching his pledge brothers howl on the gator felt like desecration. He pasted on a smile, but inside he was horrified.

Leaving the flashers on and a few bucks for the valet, they walked down to the Commonwealth Club, lit gold against the night. Saturday meant tuxedos and pearls drifting in and out, valets hustling cars down the drive. The list said get a photo with the doorman.

Teddy groaned. “Jesus. My dad and granddad are members here, guys, come on.”

Connor lit up. “Knew it! West End royalty.”

The doorman, immaculate in tails, didn’t blink as six rumpled college boys clustered around him. The flash lit Teddy’s red face. Ethan caught it, recognized the look—privilege you couldn’t escape and shame you couldn’t voice.

Leaving the Jefferson, they rolled up Main, past VCU’s red brick and neon. Students leaned on porches, smoke curling. The marquee of the Mosque glowed half-burnt, red bulbs sputtering. Marco jeered at their coats and ties. “We look like undertakers.”

Connor pointed out Sidewalk Café. “We’re stopping there.” They piled inside, splitting Sidewalk Subs, posing like it was a prize hog. The waitress rolled her eyes, snapped the shot. Marco jousted with the bread, Connor smirked, Tyler leaned back calm. Ethan laughed despite himself, though his eyes kept drifting to Tyler’s shoulders against the wood paneling. This is all in my head, he thought—Eli, now Tyler.

From there Connor directed Tyler down Boulevard, pointing like he was leading a tour bus. “Devil’s Triangle,” he said, nodding at the neon of The Triangle Bookstore. The sign buzzed red, the block half-deserted. “Local landmark. Don’t come down here unless you’re looking for trouble.”

Marco whooped, “But it’s on the list!” Teddy groaned, but they all spilled onto the sidewalk in ties and blazers, snapping a photo under the glowing sign. Ethan forced his grin, stomach tight. Teddy explained Devil’s Triangle to the rest, ending with, “We could get shot down here.” Those prints would be sliding past strangers at Target tomorrow morning.

“Alright,” Connor said, triumphant. “Next stop—Carytown.”

They parked and walked down Cary Street, neon glowing off brick facades. Passing the Byrd Theatre, they could hear the organ playing. It was approaching midnight, Carytown in full tilt.

“Of course they want us to go to Babes,” Teddy said, rolling his eyes.

“What is that?” Ethan asked.

“You take this one, Connor.” Teddy smirked.

“It’s a gay bar,” Connor finally coughed out, catching his breath.

Of course it was. Just ahead Babes squatted low, its windows covered with black plywood, faint neon humming. The bouncer smirked at their IDs and waved them off.

“Come on man, we just need a picture at the bar,” Connor pleaded.

“Ain’t happening,” the bouncer said, checking another group’s IDs.

A couple of men in line laughed.

“Must be a fraternity prank. Let them in—they look so cute in their ties.”

The pledges cracked up, but Ethan felt it in his gut. He’d heard the stories about guys being spotted here. The joke barely reached him. Deflated, they posed for a picture with the two men behind them. At least they tried.

The last thing on the list: get a picture behind the deli and snag some rainbow cookies. The Carytown Ukrop’s sat dark, lot empty. “I told you it would be closed.” “Doesn’t matter,” Connor said. “Get the shot.” They rattled the locked doors, posed under the glowing sign. Teddy wheezed with laughter. Ethan hung back, staring at the wholesome façade paired with the boarded windows of Babes just a few blocks over. Finally they called it a night.

They ended the night at a cheap motel off Broad. Neon buzzed, mildew in the curtains. The clerk didn’t blink at six boys in ties. They asked for two rooms. Mark, Teddy, Marco, and Connor paid for their double. When it was Tyler and Ethan’s turn, the clerk asked flatly, “You boys want one bed or two?” The guys waiting for the elevator doubled over in laughter. “They just need one, right guys?” Mark joked. Ethan froze, he could feel his face starting to flush. “Two beds please,” Tyler finally said. Ethan noticed he wasn’t laughing either.

They crammed into doubles. Marco sprawled, Connor snored, Teddy muttered in his sleep.

Down the breezeway, Mark lay snoring in the other bed, the neon bleeding through blinds. Ethan felt the bed shift in the dark. Tyler was now laying beside, knees brushing, then shoulders. Ethan held his breath, and Tyler pulled him into a spoon. Neither said anything. Imperfect, awkward, secret—but real.

Morning brought stale air and pounding heads. They dragged themselves to greasy brunch, eggs sliding off plates, orange juice lukewarm. Connor cracked a grin. “So, you two fuck last night?” he asked once the waitress left. Ethan wanted to crawl under the table. Tyler didn’t flinch. “So what if we did,” he said, biting into bacon. The table erupted. Ethan stared at his plate, face burning — and yet some part of him felt shielded by Tyler’s indifference, even if it only deepened his confusion.

At Target the disposable cameras were dropped, film spooling out behind glass. Families waiting on their prints turned to watch as shot after shot slid onto the conveyor: Tyler on the gator, Ethan outside Babes, the whole pledge class under Ashe. Strangers saw them before they did. Ethan’s stomach twisted. He gripped the counter while the clerk stacked the envelopes. Tyler nudged him under the table later. “They’re just pictures.” But Ethan knew better.

Grabbing the double prints, they hauled back down 360, CDs sliding, Discman skipping, Connor singing off-key. They pulled into Westmore by noon, filthy, sunburned, ties undone. Clay waited with his clipboard, pretending to scowl. Some other brothers started cat calling from the porch. “Go get some sleep guys, nicely done,” Clay waved them off.

Across the grass, Eli stood with arms folded, gaze locked on him for a moment too long. Just enough to remind Ethan of the thread tying them still.

“Hey Ethan”, he finally said, “you guys come tell me all about it.” “I’m beat,” Mark tossed behind him.

Ethan hesitated a split second before turning around.

He reached into his pocket. The quarter sat cool against his palm. Not punishment now—proof he was surviving.

Further Reading

If you like this series and are curious about books that have inspired me, I’ve curated a collection on Bookshop.org. Buying through that link supports independent bookstores—and it helps sustain this project.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

By late October, Westmore had transformed. The air had that crisp edge that made bourbon taste sharper, and the trees along the quad glowed bronze and gold. Homecoming was the high mass of the Fall semester. It meant striped tents sprouting like mushrooms along the football field, alumni in bowties and laminated nametags shuffling in with their wives and children, and a sudden flood of women from every nearby college. For a school that had only recently gone coed, the weekend felt like a balancing act—three women for every guy, a spectacle the brothers treated as their birthright.

Ethan saw it differently. To him, it felt staged, a page torn from Southern Living: monogrammed cocktail cups, silver trays overflowing with country ham biscuits and barbecue flashing under white tents. He knew better. By midnight those trays would be sticky with beer and sweat, the hedges would be trashed, and the pledges would be on their knees, scrubbing it all away.

The first wave of women arrived Wednesday night. Carloads from Waverly, St. Margaret’s, and Kingston, loud and laughing before the doors even slammed. They clustered on the porches of fraternity row like they owned it, smoking cigarettes and calling to brothers by name. By Thursday afternoon the place had the thrum of a carnival, music echoing across the lawns, beer flowing before classes were even done.

That evening another car pulled up, headlights sweeping across Delta Chi’s lawn. The doors opened and a pack of Kingston girls spilled out—pearls flashing, Marlboro Lights in gold packs tucked against cans of beer, one or two managing the impossible grip of cup, pack, and cigarette in a single hand. In the other, designer handbags swung like pendulums. They were louder than the rest, laughing like they had been drinking since lunch.

In the middle of them was the girl in the green dress from weeks before.

Catherine Whitfield.

She was radiant in a way that seemed practiced but effortless—hair loose, boots muddy from the Virginia clay, voice carrying over everyone else. Eli met her at the edge of the porch, posture taut as a pulled string. Around her, he seemed to expand—smiling wider, talking louder, moving with a swagger Ethan hadn’t seen before. Catherine touched his arm, laughed at his stories, pulled him closer with every gesture.

Ethan stood off to the side, cooler in his arms, something burning low in his chest. She looked familiar, but why did Eli change the second she walked up? Before he could shrug it off, Mark appeared beside him, grin wide.

“You haven’t met her?” Mark said, nodding toward the porch. “That’s Catherine. Eli’s on-again, off-again. Mom would throw a parade if Eli married her tomorrow. It’s exactly the kind of respectable box-checking they eat up.”

The words landed like a stone. Catherine wasn’t just another girl drifting through the party—she was the girl. Ethan’s stomach twisted as Eli leaned into her, hand brushing her waist like he had done it a hundred times.

Thursday night raged again. Brothers skipped class, pledges cleaned. Marco called it “bailing a sinking ship with a teaspoon.” Clay barked orders from behind his clipboard. Connor cracked jokes until Clay’s glare silenced him. Teddy hummed as he worked, eyes red but smiling. Tyler never stopped, unloading bag after bag in silence.

Friday was more of the same. By sunset Ethan’s arms ached from ferrying kegs, his hands cracked from the cleaning. Catherine and her friends drifted in and out of rooms, orbiting Eli. Ethan caught glimpses of them on the porch, smoking, laughing too loud, tugging at his sleeve, looking up at him with puppyish devotion. He tried not to watch, but his eyes betrayed him.

Saturday began with a voice.

Clay had programmed his phone to send an automatic message that rang each pledge’s room at 5:30 a.m. His voice came flat and merciless: “Wake up, pledges. Black shoes, coats and ties. Be at the house in ten.”

“How does he do that?” Mark called over his shoulder.

“Connor says he’s friends with the switchboard operator,” Ethan muttered. “Apparently she slipped him the manual.”

The pledges stumbled through the dew, jackets wrinkled, eyes bloodshot. Clay was waiting with his clipboard.

“Today,” he said, grinning. “We’re going to put lipstick on this pig. Clean enough for your mamas to use the facilities.”

They scrubbed the chapter room until the wood paneling gleamed, polished the composites until their arms shook—still not enough unbroken glass to fill a whole wall. Tables and chairs lined up with military precision. At the Annex, couches were dragged onto the lawn, Pine-Sol poured across the floors, windows cranked open against the stench. Marco muttered, wondering if it would ever be enough. Clay scribbled on his clipboard.

By mid-morning, striped tents rose along the football field. Pledges ferried trays of barbecue, stacked ham biscuits, and poured Brunswick stew into silver tureens. Bottles of bourbon, scotch, and vodka stood in military rows, catching the autumn sun. The Jäegermeister had been on ice since last night. No Bowman’s this weekend. Even Ethan had to admit, it looked pretty respectable.

By kickoff the crowds swelled, shoulder to shoulder. Alumni in bow ties, professors with their families, students in blazers, their girlfriends in pearls. Ethan spotted Mark and Eli’s parents by the tent. Their mother clasped his hand warmly, pride radiating as she pulled him into an embrace.

“You just missed Mom rattling off Eli’s high school exploits—top of his class, lacrosse captain, full-ride offers,” Mark said, rolling his eyes.

Eli stood stiff, face flushed, eyes briefly flickering toward Ethan before quickly pulling back. Ethan took it in quietly: Eli wasn’t like the others. He was sharper, brighter, loaded with expectations—and, Ethan realized, maybe just as trapped. He’d chosen Westmore to stay close, not because he had nowhere else to go. Ethan tucked it away like evidence.

Watching Eli with his parents, Ethan felt two things at once: pity at how his mother paraded him, and envy at how natural he still looked in the spotlight. Even embarrassed, Eli carried himself like someone who belonged. Something Ethan wished he could do as effortlessly.

The second half of the game blurred into chants and genteel drunkenness. Westmore won, the crowd swarmed the field, students tearing down the goalpost. The pledges didn’t rush the field—they were already ferrying trays back to the house.

No one remembered whose idea the oyster roast had been, but Travis had them delivered from Richmond. They looked to Clay for instructions. Clay only laughed.

Ethan was the only one who had steamed oysters before. He’d grown up on the water, harvesting with his father, steaming until the shells hissed. Marco stared at the pot like witchcraft. Ethan moved with quiet competence, shucking and serving like he’d done it all his life. His father had taught him this—patiently, skillfully how to harvest them, how to steam them. For once, Ethan felt genuinely connected to home, proud even. But then the yard dissolved into noise, his one skill swallowed by chaos, fading to nothing.

By midnight the Row pulsed with bands at every house, students spilling across lawns like floodwater. The older alums had gone back to hotels, leaving brothers and a few new grads proving they still had it. Clay finally waved the pledges off, told them to have a good time. They had been “sober drivers” all weekend, shuttling alums back and forth to their hotels and the Annex.

Finally able to break from the circus, Ethan found Teddy leaning against a wall, bowl in hand.

“Here, man,” Teddy said, passing it to him. “Join me.”

They smoked, passing it back and forth. Teddy chuckled. “You know, was a lax star in high school too. Didn’t want to bother with it here. Being a star’s not my thing man. But honestly, can you even name one pro lax player?”

Ethan laughed, realizing he couldn’t. Until Eli, lacrosse had been an abstraction.

From their spot they watched the party unfold—Connor desperate for laughs, Travis shirtless, Tyler drawing every eye like he’d stepped out of a magazine. “Half-pint doesn’t stand a chance with those dudes around,” Teddy muttered.

It was true. Even Ethan, wary of Tyler, couldn’t deny it.

“These guys are all just trying to get their dicks wet. Let’s see what’s going on upstairs,” Teddy said.

Walking down the hall Ethan knew that each room contained its own private after-party. Brothers settling in with girlfriends or whoever they planned to hook up with, others preferring to quietly keep the party going. Some of the seniors were locked in Travis’s room doing God knows what. Tyler, catching him staring, wondering if Jason was in there, assured him it was best to leave it alone.

Across the hall Eli’s door was cracked open and they could hear Catherine’s voice.

The fan hummed in the window. Eli sat cross-legged on the rug, hoodie loose. Luke smoked beside him. Teddy leaned glassy-eyed against the bed. Catherine perched in a desk chair, bottle in hand, cheeks flushed. For just an instant, Ethan noticed a flicker of uncertainty cross her face as Eli turned away. But then she laughed again, louder than before, and the moment passed. An old head alum slouched in the corner with a plastic cup of bourbon balanced on his knee. A bong leaned against the wall, still warm.

Ethan dropped into the circle, finally handed a beer, finally included. The bong came his way; he coughed smoke, eyes watering.

“Remember the Robinson game?” Catherine asked, pointing her bottle at Eli. “Four goals in one half. You should’ve seen him.”

Eli grinned, cocky and modest at once. “They didn’t have a defense.”

“You loved it,” she teased. “The whole crowd chanting your name. Don’t pretend you didn’t.”

Luke smirked. “Still loves the attention.”

“Please,” Eli said, rolling his eyes, but his grin widened.

Catherine’s hand landed on his knee. “He misses it,” she slurred. “He pretends he doesn’t, but he does.”

“You talk too much when you drink,” Eli said.

“Because it’s true.” She laughed, leaning closer. “God, you used to strut around like you owned this place. You still do.”

The old head raised his cup. “Once a killer, always a killer.”

Then Catherine turned toward Ethan. “You don’t know what it was like—he was a god back then. Girls lined up. Still are.”

Ethan froze, face hot, wishing he could disappear. She draped herself against Eli, giggling, brushing hair from his eyes. Eli grinned as if nothing was wrong.

For everyone else, it was an exaggerated story told during a late night session. For Ethan, it was unbearable. The boy who had whispered in the dark was gone, replaced by someone unreadable.

His chest felt hollow. Glued to the floor, not knowing what to do. Catherine continued to laugh as she told more stories. Ethan just listened, watching as Catherine’s hand landed on Eli’s knee. Ethan’s eyes locked onto Eli’s fingers—hesitant at first, before finally brushing against hers, accepting. Eli looked away, eyes briefly meeting Ethan’s in a silent apology or perhaps just acknowledgment. Ethan couldn’t tell anymore.

Finally Teddy broke the spell.

“Hey, what happened to those girls you were talking to? Did they all leave with Tyler, or are you the only one that struck out.”

Confused, everyone looked up to see who he was talking to. Connor appeared in the frame, grinning crooked. “Clay wants us downstairs. He says we’ll thank him later if we start cleaning now.”

Teddy jumped up to join him, nudging Ethan to do the same.

The laughter from Teddy’s joke hardly registered for Ethan. Downstairs, he was in a daze. “Are you OK?” Tyler asked.

“I’m good, just tired.”

Sensing something off, Tyler looked at him. “Go crash, man. We’ve got cleanup.” Marco lugged a trash bag. Connor and Teddy waved lazily. Unspoken solidarity.

Ethan stepped into the October night. The Row still throbbed with music, girls laughing as they crossed from house to house, bands howling their last sets. Oyster shells glittered in the grass, silver trays sticky, bourbon stains soaking the linens. Tomorrow at eight, they’d be back here cleaning it all up again. No reason to think Sunday would put an end to the celebration.

The farther he walked, the tighter his chest grew. The whole semester pressed down at once—the grind of pledging, the sleepless nights, the endless cleaning, the weight of classes piled on top. First time being on his own. He had endured it by telling himself it meant something, that Eli saw him, that the kiss had been proof. Tonight stripped that bare. Eli belonged to Catherine, to the applause, to everything Ethan wasn’t.

By the time he reached his dorm, his fists were shoved so deep into his pockets the quarter dug into his palm like punishment, an imprint he couldn’t shake. Just a token, he told himself. Not an anchor. Not a promise.

The hallways were silent. The bathroom was empty. Ethan stripped, turned the water hot, stepped under the spray. At first he stood there, letting it pound the back of his neck. Then it all came at once—the exhaustion, the fear, the shame, the gentle brush of Eli’s lips in the dark, the whispered promise he’d believed was real. The image of Eli with Catherine shattered everything he’d built inside his head.

His chest heaved. His breath caught. The sobs ripped through him, raw and loud. His knees buckled and he slid to the tile, curling forward as water poured over his back. He shook so hard his teeth rattled. Alone in the steam, he sobbed until his throat burned. Grateful no one was there to see him.

When it finally passed, he dragged himself up, skin raw, eyes swollen. Dressed quickly, stumbled back to his room, collapsed into bed.

He told himself Eli had only been playing. He told himself that whatever he thought had happened between them was already gone.

And he almost believed it.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store

By mid-October, Ethan felt like time itself was playing tricks on him. Classes happened, meals happened, nights happened—but all of it blurred into one long corridor with no doors. Sleeping through showers, the other guys’ laughter bouncing off the tiles. Morning lectures in Broadmoor (Dr. Holcombe insisted the windows stay open and the AC off) where his pen slipped across the page in half-legible notes. Wednesday nights at the Annex smelled like a hundred years of spilled beer, cigarettes, and Pine-Sol—only because the pledges were cleaning regularly now.

And underneath it all, the rhythm of pledging. Line-ups. Reciting founders’ names until his tongue went dry. Shouting until his voice cracked. Drinking until his stomach revolted, then stumbling back to the dorm with a buzz that never felt earned. It wasn’t the shock of any one moment—it was the repetition. The grind. *Taxing.* That was the word the Brothers used when something wore you down past reason. And pledging was nothing if not taxing.

“Taxing.” That was the word the Brothers used when something wore you down past reason. And pledging was nothing if not taxing.

The weeks settled into a rhythm that felt both suffocating and strangely intoxicating. Four nights a week, pledges trudged to the library for Study Hall. Rows of tired faces slumped under fluorescent lights while Pledge Marshals patrolled the stacks. Occasionally, the Marshals dropped off “leadership packets” from headquarters—glossy handouts on ethics, teamwork, personal responsibility. Everyone knew it was garbage. The only purpose of Study Hall was to give pledges a fighting chance of keeping up with classes. Technically “off limits” from the constant “Pledge Duty” and endless “Taxes.” Some studied. Most dozed in chairs, jerking awake when their heads tipped forward. Ethan drifted somewhere in between, half-studying, half-watching the others, grateful for the rare reprieve.

Mark joked constantly to mask his nerves, always the first to break silences on car rides. Eli, quieter, watched everything with careful eyes. His silence carried a thoughtful weight Ethan couldn’t decode.

But the minute Study Hall ended, the leash snapped tight again. The dorm phone never stopped ringing. Brothers called at all hours, and God help the pledge who didn’t answer. Unplugging the phone was suicide—if a Brother got a busy signal, he simply called the rooms around until someone picked up. More than once, Ethan heard his name bellowed outside McClintock by an enraged Brother convinced he was hiding.

These constant tasks became their lives. Loads of laundry, fast-food runs at two in the morning, crisscrossing the county for Taco Bell or Wendy’s. Domino’s delivered, but that was for drunks too lazy to leave their rooms. Everyone else expected pledges to drive. Ethan sat in cars with other pledges, watching neon signs flicker while waiting for a sack of greasy food. Those moments blurred into camaraderie: laughter laced with exhaustion, the smell of sweat and French fries filling the car.

Other tasks were worse. Sober rides from the Annex at all hours, half-carrying Brothers who could barely walk, their bodies sagging against Ethan’s shoulder. Cigarettes became currency—Brothers demanded them constantly. Ethan burned through cartons, always expected to have one ready. And then the cleaning: the house scrubbed top to bottom every Saturday and Sunday morning while Brothers slept it off. Bathrooms, floors, kitchens—everything. By Sunday night, the place looked respectable. By Sunday midnight, it was trashed again.

The Annex was its own beast. A farmhouse half in ruins, filled with trash and stains that never came out no matter how hard you mopped. Cleaning it was like bailing out a sinking ship with a teaspoon.

Humiliating, yes. Absurd, definitely. Each task pulled Ethan deeper into a cycle he knew he should despise, yet found himself craving. The thought that he might be becoming like the Brothers—a contradiction of warmth and cruelty—was terrifyingly attractive. But not without moments that gave him pause.

It was on the long drives to the women’s colleges that he started to notice the cracks. All an hour or more away, two late roads cutting through hills, headlights carving narrow tunnels into the dark. Ethan drove, a Brother in the passenger seat, silence settling between them. Then the masks slipped. A Brother who’d barked at him earlier might sigh and admit his girlfriend was impossible. Another joked about hating his major. Some stared out the window, too tired to talk. And always, eventually, came the shrug: we had to go through it, so you do too.

Ethan started cataloging them almost without thinking. Who was loudest in line-ups but quietest one-on-one. Who smirked after a cruel joke, signaling they didn’t believe it either. Who swaggered when girls were around but slouched in sweatpants when they weren’t. It wasn’t admiration. It was study. Survival. Learning the language of belonging.

And sometimes, when the car was silent except for the hum of tires, Ethan felt that same restless current rise again. In the nearness of another body, in the manliness on display even when no one was watching. He hated himself for noticing. Hated it more because he liked it.

The threat of line-ups never went away. They hovered like thunderclouds. No schedule, no warning. Just a barked “Line up!” and the pledges scrambling into formation, hearts pounding. They shouted trivia until their voices cracked, braced for trash cans, braced for humiliation. Ethan hated it, hated the fear in his gut every time. But even then, in the sweat and shouting, shoulder to shoulder with the others, he felt the pulse of that same energy. The more he denied it, the stronger it seemed to hum beneath his skin.

Some nights Ethan lay in the dark, staring at the slow churn of the ceiling fan above his bed. Mark was always out cold, sprawled on his mattress, breathing even and easy. Ethan’s body throbbed with bruises: skinned knuckles, scraped knees, a purple bloom at his elbow from where he’d hit the wall during a line-up. His lips still remembered Eli’s kiss, a memory that cut sharper because of the silence that followed. One night he was wanted; the next he was invisible, another faceless pledge.

One night he was wanted; the next he was invisible, another faceless pledge.

He told himself not to think about it. The harder he tried, the louder his mind became. Once he reached for the dorm phone, thumb hovering over the number home—but set it back gently, like even picking it up had been too much.

On Thursday Ethan stayed behind after lab, sponge in hand slowly wiping the old soapstone bench with Lysol. Three passes, like they were working with biohazards. Still, the benches never looked clean. The room was a time capsule—battle scared soapstone, faded “NO PIPETTING BY MOUTH” signs, nothing changed since the 70s.

His advisor, Dr. Carroll, moved toward his row, hands clasped behind her back. Westmore’s first female faculty appointment, she made rooms go silent without raising her voice. She stopped at his bench, eyes falling to his swollen knuckles.

“Those aren’t from the Lysol,” she said evenly.

Ethan fumbled for a smile. “Door jam,” he said—too quick, too rehearsed.

Her gaze flicked to the faint bruises shadowing his knees. “Do you have a minute?”

Her tiny office was crammed with books and journals. Ethan usually lingered at the doorway, never realizing there was another chair. She gestured. “Sit down.”

“This place has a way of testing boys,” she told him. “Be careful what you let them take from you.”

The words landed heavier than any shouted order. He wanted to ask her what she meant, if she knew. But she shifted, warning him that premed coursework was brutal even without pledging.

Ethan stood with his backpack, heart hammering. He wondered if she’d once been tested herself—first to walk into these rooms where men smirked and dismissed. He wondered if she saw him and recognized something she’d learned long ago.

That night the Brothers locked themselves in the Chapter Room for their weekly meeting. Pledges weren’t allowed near it, so the six of them gathered in the basement. The space looked pieced together from leftovers: sagging couches, a Coke machine that hadn’t worked in years, a dartboard missing half its darts. The air was damp, the dehumidifier wheezing like it was giving up.

A pizza box sat on the coffee table, five sad slices left. Connor perched backward on a chair. “There’s always a pecking order,” he declared. “Every campus has it. Here it’s practically doctrine.”

“Preach,” Teddy muttered from the couch.

“Phi Rho?” Connor said, ticking it off. “All Richmond clones. Same haircut, same drawl, same Sperrys. Kappa Tau? Holier than thou, act like they invented Westmore. Sigma Epsilon?” He smirked at Ethan. “That’s where you would’ve ended up if you’d played the game. Carolina kid, yacht-club tan, sir and ma’am—you’d have been in.”

Ethan shook his head, smiling. “Guess I missed my shot.”

“Lucky for you.” Connor leaned back. “Delta Chi’s the catch-all. Misfits. First to initiate a Yankee—downhill ever since.”

Mock horror filled the room. Marco, the Jersey kid, lobbed a napkin at Connor’s head. Laughter broke the tension.

“The other houses do crazier shit anyway,” Teddy added. “Buzz cuts. Orange jumpsuits. Tighty-whities and a midnight Bell streak.”

“The Bell’s tradition,” Connor argued. “My cousin did it in ’92. Says it changed his life.”

“Changed his arrest record,” Marco shot back.

The Coke machine sputtered, then died. Someone fumbled the Greek alphabet, botched Xi, everyone laughed too hard. Ethan leaned against the wall, watching. This was the grind: long hours, waiting, filling the silence with noise.

Not terrifying—taxing. Wearing them down one joke, one sip, one repetition at a time.

Ethan let the laughter echo and studied the room. It struck him that this, too, was part of the training—not just the line-ups or the errands, but the hours spent inventing noise in a damp basement to cover how drained they all were. The mock horror, the napkin fights, the overdone punchlines—it was practice at carrying on, at performing the part of a Brother long before the title was official. He realized how easily survival could blur into belonging.

Later that week, the Big Brother list appeared on the corkboard outside the kitchen, typed on a machine with a failing ribbon. The letters already looked faded. Ethan found his line:

“Harris, Ethan → Jason Whitmore.”

Jason found him first. “That’s me,” he said with an easy grin. Tall, lanky, all elbows. “You need anything—food, notes, someone to tell you when you’re about to do something stupid—come to me.”

He pressed a pack of cigarettes into Ethan’s palm. “Emergency rations. And rule number one: if you borrow a blazer, check the pockets before you return it. If you find anything illegal, it wasn’t there when you wore it. You are shocked and appalled.”

Ethan laughed. “Shocked.”

“Appalled,” Jason said, stone-faced, then winked.

It wasn’t Eli. It wasn’t supposed to be. But Jason’s awkward steadiness was reassuring. A brotherhood of another kind—one that didn’t set his stomach on fire.

Subscribe now

By Friday night, rumors swirled about a road run. Forty-eight hours, a list of places across Virginia, photos for proof. Some classes got it, some didn’t. Part scavenger hunt, part survival exercise. Bridges, statues, diners, a high school football stadium, a bend in a river older than any of them.

Jason overheard the speculation, passing by with a stack of plates. “Perfect time to bond,” he said. “Or kill each other. Fifty-fifty.”

Ethan smiled, the idea tugging at him. A trip away from the Annex, away from line-ups, away from the grind. Proof he’d been somewhere else.

Though it was a dead weekend - Away Game, Saturday night the house looked like it always did—seconds from collapse. The porch light flickered, boards sagged under too many feet. Inside, the Brothers drank and shouted, music blaring.

Then came the voice from the next room: “Pledges can go. We’re done with you tonight.”

Relief swept the air. Pledges moved for the door. But Eli’s voice cut through.

“Harris. Hang back.”

Mark threw Ethan a look but didn’t wait. Soon the room was empty except for Eli, leaning against the fireplace, cigarette glowing faintly. The wood-paneled walls seemed to hold the heat of a fire even without flames.

“You holding up?” Eli asked softly.

“I don’t know,” Ethan admitted.

Eli flicked ash into the hearth and stepped closer. He plucked the cup from Ethan’s hand and set it on the mantle. “Don’t let them break you,” he said. Not advice—maybe a warning. Maybe a confession.

“That depends on who ‘them’ is,” Ethan replied.

Eli’s mouth twitched. He stepped in like it was inevitable. His hand lifted to Ethan’s jaw, tilting it up. The kiss landed harder than the first, urgent, pressing Ethan back against the paneling. Ash and beer, unsaid things already certain.

Ethan’s hands moved without thought—one tracing Eli’s jawline, the other sliding under his shirt to feel his chest. Eli inhaled sharply, muffled into Ethan’s mouth. Voices moved distantly outside, footsteps passing, none of it mattered.

When Eli broke away, he rested his forehead against Ethan’s for a moment. “Come upstairs he whispered.” Eli didn’t say it like a dare. He said it like an invitation he’d been carrying around for a while, casual enough to pass as nothing in a crowded room.

Ethan’s point of view

The hallway felt narrower than it ever had, the wood under my shoes loud enough to wake the whole house. Eli moved ahead of me, not rushing, a hand trailing the rail like he was giving me time to turn around. I didn’t. I couldn’t. I had been imagining some version of this since the first party, since that cigarette on the porch, since I found out his laundry smelled like clean summer. I’d built whole nights in my head out of the fact that he’d looked at me for longer than a second. None of those nights had a staircase that creaked like this one, or my heart trying to beat a hole through my ribs.

His room was half-dark, a desk lamp turned low, sheets pulled tight because he was the kind of person who did things that way. There was a pile of books and his lacrosse stick in the corner, and on the dresser a roll of quarters. It smelled like clean laundry and something warmer that I’d started to learn was just him.

He closed the door gently, like he was keeping the whole house from tipping over. For a second we just stood there, as if we’d both walked into the wrong place by mistake. Then he stepped forward and the space between us wasn’t a question anymore.

The kiss landed softer than downstairs, but deeper, like we’d stepped off a ledge and were finding out the fall wasn’t that far. I felt the scrape of his stubble and the way his mouth changed when I leaned into it, and there was this ridiculous thought that I’d been dreaming about this for so long and here it was—ordinary and impossible at the same time. His hand found the back of my neck, steadying me in a way that made my knees feel unsteady, and I heard my own breath catch like I was new at it.

His shirt was one of the soft ones, thin from a hundred washes. When my fingers slid under the hem it felt like crossing a border. Heat. Real skin. Not the idea of it, not the memory of a locker room or a quick glance in a shower, but the actual warmth of another body meeting my hand and not pulling away. He didn’t pull away. He exhaled through his nose and pressed closer, like he’d been waiting to be touched there.

I wasn’t graceful about it. I didn’t know where to put my hands first—ribs or back, shoulder or the place where his side curved down to his waist. I wanted to map him like a coastline, to know where the bones sat and where the muscle held, to know what was sharp and what gave under my palm. He made a sound—quiet, almost surprised—when I traced up under his shirt and flattened my hand just below his chest. “Yeah,” he said, but not a word really, more like permission.

He tugged my t-shirt up and I raised my arms before I knew I was doing it. The air felt cool for a second, then he was there and the cool was gone. Skin to skin. I’d thought about it in the abstract, sure, but I hadn’t accounted for the weight of another person leaning into you, the absolute certainty of being held in place by contact alone. I could feel his heartbeat where our chests met, a fast counter to my own, and the point where his hip pressed mine like an off-rhythm drum.

“Ethan,” he said into my mouth, and I didn’t realize how much I’d needed to hear my name like that until I did.

I wanted to look at him, not as a whole but in parts, to memorize what I was never supposed to see. In the lamp light his skin looked like something I’d never had a right to touch: the small hollow at his collarbone, the line down the center of him, the way his stomach tightened when I dragged my fingertips there. He caught my wrist once, not to stop me, I don’t think, but to slow me down, the way you’d stop someone from drinking too fast when the bottle was finally theirs.

“Okay?” he asked.

I nodded. My voice wasn’t going to be useful.

When I moved lower, it felt like walking into the rest of my life. Not because we were going to do anything more than this, not because of any particular line crossed, but because the old world—where I didn’t know what a man’s skin felt like under my hand, where I hadn’t heard that sound he made when I touched the place where his side meets the top of his jeans—didn’t exist anymore. My palm found the firmer curve of his hip, the hard ridge of bone there, and the way his breath changed told me more than any instruction would have. I followed the band of his waistband with my thumb, not inside, just there, and the heat that rose under my hand made my own lungs forget how to work for a second.

He leaned back enough to see my face like he needed to check something. “You sure?”

I laughed once, without meaning to, because the idea that I could be anything else felt absurd. “I didn’t think people like you existed,” I heard myself say, which was not what I planned and also exactly true.

Something softened in him that had nothing to do with muscle. He kissed me again, slower, like he was answering a question I hadn’t wanted to ask out loud. His hands were steadier than mine, but not by much. He slid them up my back, under the edge of my shoulder blades, down again like he was confirming I was as real to him as he was to me.

We found the bed without thinking about it. He sat and pulled me with him and the mattress dipped under us, springs giving a tired little sigh. I ended up half on my side, propped on an elbow, the other hand still at his waist like I was holding onto the idea of him. He ran his fingers down my arm, the inside where the skin is thinner, then up to my shoulder and across my chest in a line that felt like being drawn correctly. When he reached my sternum he flattened his palm and stayed there, and everything else—house noise, music two rooms over, the worry that any second a door would bang open—fell to the edges.

“Tell me if—” he started, then didn’t finish, because I’d already tipped forward again. We kissed like we were figuring out a language, stopping to find breath and then forgetting to care about breath. I moved my hand back down, slower this time, letting the path itself be the point. Stomach. The small hollow just above the band of his shorts. The fine line of hair there like a road you could follow if you didn’t get lost first. He shivered. I don’t think he meant to.

“Ethan,” he said again, and my name in his mouth was a kind of blessing.

I didn’t go further. Not because I didn’t want to—God, I wanted to—but because there was something in the stopping that felt like the difference between a thing you fall into and a thing you choose. I let my hand rest flat where it was and felt the rise and fall of him, the barely-there tremor that said this wasn’t just mine. His fingers found the back of my neck and stayed, thumb tracing the same small circle like he was grounding me or himself or both.

We stayed like that long enough for the room to come back into focus—the lamp’s slow hum, the clock radio’s red numbers, the soft complaint of the old building settling. Neither of us said the obvious things. We didn’t make promises or pretend we knew what came next. We just breathed in the same space and let our bodies memorize what we’d been pretending we didn’t want.

He pulled me in until my forehead hit his collarbone and I could feel his laugh without hearing it. “You’re shaking,” he said, like it was interesting, not embarrassing.

“Yeah,” I said. “I know.”

He didn’t tease. He didn’t try to make it bigger than it was. He just slid his hand up and down my spine once, twice, until my breath evened out, and then he leaned back against the headboard, our shoulders pressed together, and stared at the ceiling like the answer might be written there. He held me close to his chest and I imagined falling asleep right there.

We put our shirts back on eventually. Not because we had to, but because it felt like a way to mark that we weren’t going to be stupid about this. He picked mine up from the floor and handed it to me without looking away from whatever he was thinking about. I pulled it over my head and the cotton felt wrong now, like a curtain I wasn’t ready to close.

When I stood, my knees argued with me. He stayed on the bed, elbows on his knees, fingers laced. “You good?” he asked, and I nodded, because there wasn’t a word for I have been waiting to be real my whole life and tonight I was.

At the door he said my name one more time. I turned. “Don’t let them break you,” he said, and it sounded different upstairs, like he wasn’t just talking about pledging. I opened my mouth to say something back and nothing came, so I just looked at him until I couldn’t anymore and slipped out into the hall.

On the way down the stairs the house sounded like a house again—someone laughing too loud, a door shutting, the thud of feet on old wood. I pressed my palm to the banister, felt the smoothness worn by other hands, and thought about the way his skin had felt under mine. It wasn’t a dream. It wasn’t a maybe. It happened. And somewhere under the noise in my head, a quiet truth settled: I hadn’t imagined him. He existed. And he had wanted me there.

Outside, the porch had thinned. Someone strummed three wrong chords on a guitar and laughed. Ethan stepped into the cool night air, body thrumming.

Taxing days. Stolen nights. He wasn’t sure which would break him first.

Stay Connected

• 📖 Subscribe to Line & Verse for weekly chapters and essays.

• 📸 Follow along on Instagram: @caleb_writes

• 🧵 Join me on Threads: Caleb_Writes

• 📘 Facebook: Caleb Reed

• Visit my Bookshop.org Store